View Full Version : Egypt's UP
Bob III Oct 26, 2007, 05:39 PM Ok... we all know that Egypt's UP is useful in the beginning, but worthless later in the game. So I have come up with a new one, also representing a powerful aspect of Egypt. It is the "Power of the Desert" which is this: Enemy units recieve __damage per turn while in the desert within your cultural borders. This is in likeness to the fact that it was difficult to attack Egypt, due to the loss of soldiers in the desert. I would say the power would become obsolete in the Industrial/Modern era (when the enemy enters it, not you)
So... thoughts? And Rhye, how difficult would this be to implement?
Rex rgis of Ter Oct 26, 2007, 05:44 PM Interesting. I do always have problems with Impi and Arabia because of such a weak military. It is too much like the Russian Up though.
sennomulo Oct 27, 2007, 12:11 AM Well frankly, the Egyptians, like the Babylonians, aren't meant to survive into the late game. Plus, the AI has enough problems getting the Arabians to expand into northern Africa like they should. This UP would make it nearly impossible for them if Egypt hasn't collapsed yet. I like things the way they are.
onedreamer Oct 27, 2007, 01:54 AM I agree with sennomulo, plus I would add that a UP of military nature wouldn't really suit Egypt, and that the current one is just about perfect for their UHV (one of the easiest I achieved thanks to the UP). Impis are absolutely not a problem with the copper, all you need is to build 2-3 axemen. This said, I think it's ok because I wouldn't imagine an Egyptian victory if not in the pre-medieval age.
Zhuge_Liang Oct 27, 2007, 09:20 AM Agree with sennomulo. You won't see their war chariots in the medieval age or the renaissance and besides, if the AI egyptians go for the UHV, they'll have many culture because of the great library and others.
Lokolus Oct 27, 2007, 11:09 AM How about "power of the Nile"?
Rivers in Egypt's borders get +1 gold. the Nile was the most important trade route and transpotation in Egypt.
Rex rgis of Ter Oct 27, 2007, 11:48 AM ^Nice idea
Śmarth Oct 27, 2007, 03:11 PM Was it difficult to invade Egypt though? Sure it's hard to fight in desert, but hardly anybody lives there anyway. So you generally just need to claim you own huge areas of desert and have nobody disagree rather than actually do much might fighting. And imo strongly suggests Egypt as being a bit of a "wimp", following the Persian conquest it came under the successive ownership of the Greek, Roman, Arab, Ottoman and British empires - never gaining independence for a significant amount of time until the last century. The new unique power I think would not reflect that.
SilverKnight Oct 27, 2007, 05:42 PM How about "power of the Nile"?
Rivers in Egypt's borders get +1 gold. the Nile was the most important trade route and transpotation in Egypt.
Now there's a good one. :) More original, other than an "Egyptian Winter," lol.
SilverKnight
tariqari Oct 27, 2007, 11:12 PM How about "power of the Nile"?
Rivers in Egypt's borders get +1 gold. the Nile was the most important trade route and transpotation in Egypt.
That's a great idea! Actually before I got into Rhyes for CIV 4 (was still in CIV 3 for awhile..), I had thought since all the civs get UPs, Egypt would have something to do with the Nile.
tariqari Oct 27, 2007, 11:12 PM Was it difficult to invade Egypt though? Sure it's hard to fight in desert, but hardly anybody lives there anyway. So you generally just need to claim you own huge areas of desert and have nobody disagree rather than actually do much might fighting. And imo strongly suggests Egypt as being a bit of a "wimp", following the Persian conquest it came under the successive ownership of the Greek, Roman, Arab, Ottoman and British empires - never gaining independence for a significant amount of time until the last century. The new unique power I think would not reflect that.
Good point
onedreamer Oct 28, 2007, 02:07 AM the Nile bonus wouldn't help their UHV and it's quite unoriginal (not unique). I think that converting a couple of river deserts into flood plains would help more than this power ^^
Did you know the word desert comes from egyptian btw ?
Virdrago Oct 28, 2007, 04:52 PM Egypt was conquered by Assyrians, Persians, Greeks, Arabs, etc. coming south from the Nile delta by following the river. The Nubians took Egypt by going north up the Nile. None of them bothered going through the desert. The Egyptians all lived around the river, so controlling the Nile meant you controlled Egypt. So, I'd say the power of the desert would be moot.
|
|