View Full Version : The hardest life- St Kilda


Kafka2
Mar 23, 2003, 02:30 PM
The UK consists of many islands, and we've proved to be as tenacious as barnacles when it comes to inhabiting them. At the absolute extreme lies the eight small islands and stacks that make up St Kilda.

These islands are so remote and obscure that they are rarely shown on British maps. They lie out in the Atlantic, 40 miles west of the Outer Hebrides in one of the stormiest seas on the planet. The largest island in the group is Hirta, with a surface area of just under two square miles. They are the most forbidding islands I've ever seen- despite their tiny size they have the highest sea-cliffs in Britain, soaring up to 1400 feet dead vertically from the sea. This trend reaches it's peak in the astonishingly vertical island of Boreray, which boasts cliffs 1000 feet high despite having a surface area of less than 190 acres.

It's also one of the windiest places on the planet, with westerlies frequently hitting 130mph. Combined with the cliffs and poor natural harbours, the islands are totally inaccessible for months on end. Put bluntly, if they'd ever been used as a penal colony they'd have made Devil's Island look like Monaco.

Yet despite all this, St Kilda was continuously inhabited for 5000 years. Nominally part of Scotland, it was a strange little self-contained world that very occasionally made contact with it's bigger neighbours to the west. The largest known population was 180 on Hirta (the only inhabited island) in 1697. None spoke English- all were Gaelic-speakers- and they scratched a living from their homes. They had sheep, which they grazed on all the island. The sheep beggar belief- they are incredibly wild long-legged creatures with long horns, as sure-footed as mountain goats. Zoologists say they are practically unchanged from the sheep of Neolithic times, and they still roam the islands today.

They also had millions of seabirds. St Kildans lived on a diet of seabirds, young seabirds, and seabird's eggs, dried or smoked. Only occasionally would they have mutton or fish. Hunting their food up and down the immense cliffs made the St Kildans the most renowned climbers in Britain. Each young man seeking a wife had to prove he could feed her. To do so he had to climb 850 feet to the Lover's Stone, a small and terrifying sloping platform. Once there, he had to stand on one foot, holding his other foot in his hand. If he survived, he could marry.

Twice a year, the St Kildans would pay their rent. This meant taking a small, 2-man rowing boat and rowing across 40 miles of ocean, negotiating the whirlpools around the Hebrides, and rowing across the stormy 40 miles of The Minch to Skye. Then rowing all the way back. It's said that no St Kildan ever died in bed- they either fell or drowned.

Life on St Kilda was hard. It had the highest recorded rate of infant mortality in the entire world- 80% of babies died within 7 days of birth due to tetanus (caused by the tradition of smearing the navel in a mixture of dung and oil extracted from the crops of Fulmars).

None of the events I've described here are accounts of immense antiquity- all these practices continued through into the 19th century. However the encoachment of the modern world brought upheaval to St Kilda. At first it was benign- in 1877 the islanders were astonished by their first sight of an apple brought ashore by a sailor. By this time steamers had started visiting St Kilda, bringing tourists to gawp at the funny primitives.

War came to St Kilda for the only time in 1918 when a Royal Navy detachment was stationed there. A german U-Boat fired 72 shells at it's radio aerial, destroying the Kirk and several houses. However the real damage was done in trickles- a young man or several leaving to go to the mainland, or Australia very few years.

By 1930, only 36 St Kildans remained on Hirta, and the community could no longer support itself. The distraught and half-starved islanders were evacuated on HMS Harebell in a traumatic severance since celebrated in songs and poems. Every islander left a pile of oats and a Bible in their deserted houses, in the hope they would one day return.

They never did. Just their houses and their sheep remain to commemorate one of the most moving accounts of human endurance at the very edge of the world.

nixon
Mar 23, 2003, 02:43 PM
That is...fantastic. :eek:

Did the government force them to leave the islands, or did they leave voluntarily?

Again, it's amazing.

Panda
Mar 23, 2003, 03:02 PM
But still not as bad as Paraguay, hmm? ;)

Kafka2
Mar 23, 2003, 04:04 PM
Originally posted by nixon


Did the government force them to leave the islands, or did they leave voluntarily?



It was voluntary. After tourist ships started calling, the St Kildan's found it easier to make a living by selling souvenirs. This eroded their self-sufficiency and made them dangerously reliant on the mainland. Eventually they decided they couldn't go on.

Constantine
Mar 23, 2003, 05:10 PM
Wow That is amazing they surived for long. Kinda shows how soft we've all become

Cpt. Cynical
Mar 24, 2003, 09:27 AM
Interesting, but I question the sanity of someone who would force their child to do a handstand on the side of a cliff. Very stoic folks, though.

test_specimen
Mar 24, 2003, 09:57 AM
Have you been there Kafka?

I bet they must have had some problems with incest. If their maximum population was 180 they were less people at some time. Perhaps that is a reason for those wedding rituals.

Kafka2
Mar 24, 2003, 11:48 AM
No- I've never been there. It's quite difficult and expensive to get there, and you need to take all your supplies with you.

Incest may have figured in earlier years, but they were very religious (initially Catholic, later Scottish Free Church) which would have restricted it. Then again, in a community that size the gene pool probably got pretty murky.

Mojotronica
Mar 24, 2003, 12:07 PM
Another fascinating historical tidbit, Kafka2 -- thanks!

Archer 007
Mar 24, 2003, 09:04 PM
Thanks Kafka for another great article. Keep up the good work :goodjob:

lord_byron_nz
Mar 24, 2003, 10:35 PM
Kafka, this is another supreme piece. In between the Iraq threads in OT and the lack of interesting material in the History forum, I though CFC was getting a bit tired. You've proved me wrong, however. :)

I must admit, on reading the subject line I thought you meant St Kilda, Melbourne :crazyeye:

covok48
Mar 24, 2003, 10:47 PM
Wow Fafka....you're good. Got any more pics of those islands? I'm Fascinated!

redtom
Apr 02, 2003, 05:42 PM
I was just about to add a thread on Kildan democracy.

Basically, the men of Kilda would stand in the 'main street' of the island and discuss what they should today. If they didn't agree they didn't do anything, they just went back into their houses and slept. Whilst the women toiled in the fields.

Kafka2
Apr 03, 2003, 12:55 PM
When your workplace is on the end of a rope, dangling off a 1000 foot cliff, I can understand a tendency to say "Sod that. Looks like mutton again, wifey."

rilnator
Apr 03, 2003, 08:33 PM
Yeah The story of St Kilda is tradgic. One of Melbourne's proudest football teams and yet never making the top 8. 2003 is looking better for them though with a couple of promising up and comers. I think they'll miss Spider Everett.
Thanks for drawing attention to the 'Saints' Kafka2. Don't you think it would have better suited to the sports talk section though?

Bose
Apr 03, 2003, 09:30 PM
These people are going to have no idea what ur talking about rilnator... and Spider is a liability!

Great story Kafka, any more pics? Definately a good read... keep it up.

As for the embattled St Kilda Saints, their year is only going to get worse...

Kafka2
Apr 04, 2003, 08:53 AM
Of course, the St Kilda in Melbourne was named after the original St Kilda by emigrants looking for an easier life. Most of them died en route.....

sydhe
Oct 04, 2007, 06:41 PM
I wonder if St. Kilda was a partial inspiration for Neal Stephenson's Qwghlm islands in Cryptonomicon and The Baroque cycle?

Plotinus
Oct 05, 2007, 02:29 AM
Now there's a bump! I imagined that Qwghlm was based on the Isle of Man, but that's just a guess.

A fortunate bump, though, as I hadn't read this. I'm amazed they didn't all die of scurvy.

Taliesin
Oct 05, 2007, 08:47 AM
The Wikipedia article is really excellent, if anybody wants to read more about St Kilda. There was a catastrophe in 1727, when the clothes of a St Kildan who had visited the Outer Hebrides and died of smallpox were unaccountably returned to the island. Everybody there was killed, save nineteen on Hiorta (only one adult) and eleven men on a hunting trip to one of the smaller islands. St Kilda had to be repopulated from elsewhere.

You can arrange to camp on the island, if you're interested.

Cheezy the Wiz
Oct 07, 2007, 10:45 AM
Now there's a bump! I imagined that Qwghlm was based on the Isle of Man, but that's just a guess.

A fortunate bump, though, as I hadn't read this. I'm amazed they didn't all die of scurvy.

Depending on what they grew, and if they kept goats or anything like that (can you milk a sheep? I don't think you can, but I wouldn't be surprised), they could've kept a fair supply of Vitamin C in their diet.

What I'm having trouble figuring out is: what would posess people to go there in the first place?

ohcrapitsnico
Oct 07, 2007, 11:22 AM
Wow amazing, I had no idea a place such as this would exist.

Dame Edna
Oct 25, 2007, 08:08 AM
That St Kilda (suburb of Melbourne) and it's Football Club should be named after such a tragic place is poetic. I'm interested to know more about the place, particularly why anyone would stay there if it was possible to get away and why they might have gone there in the first place.

manlyboy
Oct 26, 2007, 01:59 AM
Wow! That's intriguing stuff. Very well written, too. I felt like I was there. The St. Kildans deserve an honorable mention in the "worst form of human life in history" thread.