View Full Version : Election T8 - Science Leader


Chieftess
Mar 28, 2003, 07:16 PM
This poll will remain open until the end of the month (GMT).

Strider
Mar 28, 2003, 07:48 PM
I'm scared... Does that say:


Civanator 0 0%

FortyJ 1 20.00%

gunning1 0 0%

Strider 4 80.00%

Abstain 0 0%

Or am I seeing things?

Zarn
Mar 28, 2003, 08:21 PM
No, you have 6 (of 7) votes now.

Strider
Mar 28, 2003, 09:00 PM
Whoa... Amazing... I was expecting FortyJ/Gunning to beat me out... Seriously...

I'm surprised... 0-1-0-7-0 right now.

CivGeneral
Mar 28, 2003, 09:02 PM
Can someone say Strider Go Strider :D

@Strider - When I stop by in Strider's Haven, hop into the Bar Car and Campaing along with me :).

Octavian X
Mar 28, 2003, 09:23 PM
Go FortyJ for unparalleled service, who hopefully won't quit in the middle of term...

Donovan Zoi
Mar 29, 2003, 12:03 AM
:crazyeye: :eek: :crazyeye:

The results so far show that Fanatika loves uncertainty. I am tempted to vote for Strider here just to see if he can pull off the resignation hat trick the minute one of his proposals meets even the slightest resistance.

Um, kidding. With FortyJ, you get his dedication for the entire term. Also, doesn't anyone remember:

1. The Cartographic Office?
2. FA Civ Spotlight discussions(as FA deputy)
3. Domestic settler maps?
4. The benchmark Term 5 Presidency?

I can't wait to see what his plans are for the Science Department. As it stands right now, it looks like I'll have to wait until about April 15th. :lol:

naervod
Mar 29, 2003, 12:06 AM
Strider for experience in the Department. While I feel FortyJ is a hard worker and a great planner, he has no experience in the Science Department while Strider has by far the most.

Cyc
Mar 29, 2003, 02:01 AM
I have to vote for 40J here. Everything everyone says about his work is true. Maybe we'll get a bonafide research system going finally.

Chieftess
Mar 29, 2003, 06:54 AM
Wow, 40J is catching up! Poor Civanator and gunning are being left in the dust.

Noldodan
Mar 29, 2003, 07:07 AM
Vote FortyJ! He has Presidential experience (always useful) and has NEVER quit halfway through a term!

Strider
Mar 29, 2003, 08:45 AM
Just to clear this damn thing up.

I only resigned because I had time restraints and felt like I could not get anything done in the Science Department at that time. I thought that resigning and giving it up to a more able person would be to the benefit of Fanatika and the Science Department. Other leaders other than me have resigned, but you seem to not hold that against them do you?

Civanator
Mar 29, 2003, 08:50 AM
VOTE FOR ME!!!!!

Goonie
Mar 29, 2003, 09:25 AM
It is quite sad that a former President and very dedicated Fanatikan is losing this election to a person who has quit office twice. I am sorry, but this makes me very angry. I wanted 40J to be president. In my mind he would have won that election no contest, but alas he choose Science, and I never expected any him to have any difficulty winning this one.

Shaitan
Mar 29, 2003, 10:18 AM
For the record I do hold it against leaders that resign. Since Strider has done it twice I can't support him for a leadership position.

In any case, FortyJ has shown amazing dedication and industry in every office he has held. In fact, he's shown that outside of any office with the several critical "not for profit" positions that he maintains. He has my vote and my full support.

Noldodan
Mar 29, 2003, 10:21 AM
FortyJ's catching up! GO FORTYJ,GO!

Chieftess
Mar 29, 2003, 10:22 AM
And now it's a tie! Another close race! But, gunning has no votes! :eek: And Civanators prior bans seem to still be known... 2 canidates with a rep hit.

Strider
Mar 29, 2003, 10:28 AM
Originally posted by Chieftess
And now it's a tie! Another close race! But, gunning has no votes! :eek: And Civanators prior bans seem to still be known... 2 canidates with a rep hit.

Do you mean 2 canidates with a rep hit as in Civanator and I or Gunning and Civanator?

I don't think Gunning has a rep hit... It's me. :)

Posted by Shaitan
For the record I do hold it against leaders that resign. Since Strider has done it twice I can't support him for a leadership position.[/QUOTE]

I did not resign twice. I thought about it once... and actually went as far as post it, but in the end I decided not to resign.

Also... If you have something against a leader resigning because of an unsuspected RL crisis then good luck getting new leaders.

Chieftess
Mar 29, 2003, 10:35 AM
eh em... I wonder if Strider and Shaitan like thread jacking election threads. Especially science election threads. ;)

Strider
Mar 29, 2003, 10:38 AM
Originally posted by Chieftess
eh em... I wonder if Strider and Shaitan like thread jacking election threads. Especially science election threads. ;)

No... I think it's just polls overall, but elections are a speciality of are's :)

BTW... was that a warning?

Shaitan
Mar 29, 2003, 11:50 AM
Not actually threadjacking as the comments apply to this election. :p

Cyc
Mar 29, 2003, 12:46 PM
To state my opinion on the matter, Strider, I thought you had resigned 3 times over the course of your recent career. I consider you the only person that has resigned more times than Falcon02.

CivGeneral
Mar 29, 2003, 12:55 PM
:eek: 40J is catching up to Strider. Could this mean a Run-off Poll or 40J finaly Defeating Strider.

Goonie
Mar 29, 2003, 02:51 PM
Go 40J!!

Bootstoots
Mar 29, 2003, 03:07 PM
I think that Strider's 6-term experience as Science Leader makes him the better candidate despite his resignations.

Strider
Mar 29, 2003, 03:12 PM
Originally posted by Cyc
To state my opinion on the matter, Strider, I thought you had resigned 3 times over the course of your recent career. I consider you the only person that has resigned more times than Falcon02.

No... I've only resigned once.

Also... 1-11-0-12-0 right now... Winning by only one vote.

A few hours ago when I checked it was 1-11-0-10-0 and I was losing to forty.

FortyJ
Mar 29, 2003, 04:31 PM
Originally posted by bootstoots
I think that Strider's 6-term experience as Science Leader makes him the better candidate despite his resignations.
The issue is not really about experience in this position. After all, up until last term, the science department has been essentially non-existent (we have been purchasing all of our techs until then).

The issue should be about who we think is best suited to lead our science department into the Modern Era. Personally, I think I have ample experience in organization matters. I also can assure everyone that I will not resign in mid-term, no matter what curves real life throws my way.

But, then again, I'm biased... ;)

gunning1
Mar 29, 2003, 05:12 PM
Hmm, wow, I suck...1 vote...All done by me! Hmm, go whoever! :(

Strider
Mar 29, 2003, 05:24 PM
Originally posted by gunning1
Hmm, wow, I suck...1 vote...All done by me! Hmm, go whoever! :(

Gunning... I think that it's not that you suck... Just that people don't want to see me as Science Leader or Don't want to see Forty as Science Leader so is voting for whoever has the most votes that is not the person they want in.

FortyJ
Mar 29, 2003, 11:57 PM
Originally posted by Strider
No... I've only resigned once. While technically correct, you have threatened to resign on more than one occasion in what some would describe as nothing more than a tantrum resulting from not getting your way.

To illustrate, I direct everyone's attention (everyone that's still paying attention, that is... ;)) to the following links:

Resignation Threat #1 (Term 3) (http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=36704&highlight=resignation)

Resignation Threat #2 (Term 6) (http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=44572&highlight=resignation)

While you now claim that you made these decisions out of concern for your real life obligations, I think anyone who reads these threads will be inclined to disagree.

This is not intended as a personal attack on Strider. After all, I too have voted for him in the past. I am simply asking all voters to carefully consider their options before casting their votes.

I am a dedicated patriot to our cause. I have managed to run a business, raise a newborn child and perform numerous repairs to my house while holding several elected positions in addition to my extremely time-consuming position in the Cartographic Office, and not once have I even threatened to resign from any of my positions.

So, once again, I urge you to carefully consider your options and remember that a vote for FortyJ is a vote for commited leadership.

Thank you.

Noldodan
Mar 30, 2003, 06:46 AM
OMG! The vote is tied once again at 12-12!

Strider
Mar 30, 2003, 09:30 AM
Originally posted by FortyJ
While technically correct, you have threatened to resign on more than one occasion in what some would describe as nothing more than a tantrum resulting from not getting your way.

To illustrate, I direct everyone's attention (everyone that's still paying attention, that is... ;)) to the following links:

Resignation Threat #1 (Term 3) (http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=36704&highlight=resignation)

Resignation Threat #2 (Term 6) (http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=44572&highlight=resignation)

While you now claim that you made these decisions out of concern for your real life obligations, I think anyone who reads these threads will be inclined to disagree.

This is not intended as a personal attack on Strider. After all, I too have voted for him in the past. I am simply asking all voters to carefully consider their options before casting their votes.

I am a dedicated patriot to our cause. I have managed to run a business, raise a newborn child and perform numerous repairs to my house while holding several elected positions in addition to my extremely time-consuming position in the Cartographic Office, and not once have I even threatened to resign from any of my positions.

So, once again, I urge you to carefully consider your options and remember that a vote for FortyJ is a vote for commited leadership.

Thank you.

commited? I've been commited to this demogame and as science leader before your name was even known. I led the demogame through 6 straight months as science leader and before that I was science chat rep and science deputy. I've fought my way up the ladder as trade deputy (two times) and vice president.

Anyone who wish's to disagree with that is through my attempt to keep my personally real life obligations to myself. Give me one reason why I should reveal my personal life to abunch of strangers?

Also... Do you know anything about the science department? Can you get a rough estimate of how many turns it takes an AI civ to research? Can you calculate how many turns it'll take for us to research a tech and how much it'll cost to buy/sell? (you can get a utility to do this, but you can also do it with pen and paper)

I have the experience to do this job. Where as FortyJ has been known to support proposals that drop are science research. Something we need drastically of at the closing of this game. We have to take the lead in science research and keep it. If we drop behind we might find that are panzers are unable to fight mech infantry effectively... Where as modern armor can effectively kill infantry.

This is a Demogame. I doubt any of us here will meet eachother in real life. This election is not a life or death sitution... As it seems Forty does not seem to understand. Yes, he even said that it was not a personal attack, but that does not change wether it is or it isn't.

FortyJ
Mar 30, 2003, 11:27 AM
Strider
You are correct: I have supported proposals in the past that would require a reduction of science funding. I did so because it was the right thing to do for Fanatika at the time. In our current situation, thanks in no small part to some Greek generosity, we are able to sustain an impressive level of research funding and I wholly support this. I certainly hope we can continue to lead the world in research. However, if the situation changes, I certainly would not blindly insist that we continue to pursue 100% science funding, if it were not in the best interest of Fanatika.

With respect to my "personal" attacks on your character: even if I had wanted to attack you personally, I couldn't - I don't know you that well. In fact, on a personal level, I don't have anything bad to say about you. I enjoy your participation in the demogame and enjoy your presence in the chats, particularly your Chat Room Challenges. And, nobody is going to dispute your longevity in the Demogame, nor what you have accomplished in it.

Nonetheless, the recent facts are quite clear: in this game, you have resigned (or at least attempted to resign) at least twice before. I felt that your attempts to brush this under the rug and dismiss them were an injustice to not only your fellow candidates, but also to the people casting their votes.

If the citizens of Fanatika wish you to run the Science Department in Term 8 despite your previous attempts to resign from this office, then I will support them, and you, 100%. I simply felt that the people should be properly informed before making their decisions.

Shaitan
Mar 30, 2003, 12:10 PM
Strider, 2 of the things you just said cry out for a response.Originally posted by Strider
Give me one reason why I should reveal my personal life to abunch of strangers?
You didn't site personal reasons in any of your resignations. Your stated reasons were:
I am very sorry to announce that I am resigning. I have decided that the game is no longer fun and I should not waste my time on standing up for something that I believe is right just to have a bunch of people ignore me without question to get there own way.
I feel that my effort and time spent as science leader is not relized and personally I don't feel like spending 5 hours of my sleeping time coming up with something that is just going to get voted down.
In both cases it was because you didn't get your way.
Originally posted by Strider
Also... Do you know anything about the science department? Can you get a rough estimate of how many turns it takes an AI civ to research? Can you calculate how many turns it'll take for us to research a tech and how much it'll cost to buy/sell? (you can get a utility to do this, but you can also do it with pen and paper)
I have never seen such an analysis from you in any of your terms.

Strider
Mar 30, 2003, 12:16 PM
Originally posted by Shaitan
Strider, 2 of the things you just said cry out for a response.
You didn't site personal reasons in any of your resignations. Your stated reasons were:
I am very sorry to announce that I am resigning. I have decided that the game is no longer fun and I should not waste my time on standing up for something that I believe is right just to have a bunch of people ignore me without question to get there own way.
I feel that my effort and time spent as science leader is not relized and personally I don't feel like spending 5 hours of my sleeping time coming up with something that is just going to get voted down.
In both cases it was because you didn't get your way.

I have never seen such an analysis from you in any of your terms.

So... I'll explain to you how you get a rough estimate of how to figure an AI's research rate.

Works only if your behind in techs

Check the AI every turn. When they get a new tech then mark that as Turn 0. Keep marking the turns as Turn 1, 2,3, etc. intill the AI complete's/buys a new tech. You have a rough estimate of how fast the AI is researching then. Also the AI has a tech order of importance that I'm still testing out, but I believe it go's mainly for goverments first.

Civanator
Mar 30, 2003, 12:50 PM
Jeese people, does all this really matter? You vote, your done. No attacking each other with accusations. You sound like a bunch of kindergarteners. I'm not saying that I'm perfect either, we all do regretful things. No offense, but it's a game. Once you stop digging up dirt everyone might come out clean. How about we drop it here and forget the whole thing happened? Please?

Noldodan
Mar 30, 2003, 01:03 PM
Originally posted by Civanator
Jeese people, does all this really matter? You vote, your done. No attacking each other with accusations. You sound like a bunch of kindergarteners. I'm not saying that I'm perfect either, we all do regretful things. No offense, but it's a game. Once you stop digging up dirt everyone might come out clean. How about we drop it here and forget the whole thing happened? Please?

You're just miffed that you only got your own vote. ;)

Strider
Mar 30, 2003, 01:10 PM
Originally posted by Noldodan


You're just miffed that you only got your own vote. ;)

Actually.... He prob doesn't want it to get nasty... I doubt it will though.... I'm not the type of person to sit here and dig up dirt on someone to win a election in a game. It's what you call fair play.... If forty wants to sit here and insult me all day it doesn't matter... Either I'm Science Leader and Trade Deputy... Or Trade Leader and Science Deputy... Either is fine by me.

Civanator
Mar 30, 2003, 01:24 PM
That's right, I don't want it to get nasty.
And Noldodan, I haven't won a science election since I helped Strider in the First demogame, Term 3. No big deal for me, and that vote was my own ;)

Strider
Mar 30, 2003, 01:27 PM
Originally posted by Civanator
That's right, I don't want it to get nasty.
And Noldodan, I haven't won a science election since I helped Strider in the First demogame, Term 3. No big deal for me, and that vote was my own ;)

Yup... The Civanator/Strider Science Leadership... Then came Curufinwe... Then Stuck/Gunning/CivGeneral..... Whoa... Never noticed how many there really is.... lol

Civanator
Mar 30, 2003, 01:33 PM
but Curu disappeared. I talked to him a while ago. He said he won't be back till summer vacation. Maybe sooner. Look where we've gotten everyone to...

Shaitan
Mar 30, 2003, 03:34 PM
There hasn't been a single insult leveled here. There have been quoted remarks and recitations of actual fact. Fair play does not include making false accusations, Strider.

Strider
Mar 31, 2003, 07:24 AM
YES!!!

1-12-1-13-0 right now.... Heading to school and won't have a access to a computer though :(

Bootstoots
Mar 31, 2003, 01:59 PM
Civanator has another vote, and there's another tie between Strider and 40J (13-13)!

Civanator
Mar 31, 2003, 02:23 PM
bootstoots, your the best. ;)