6-Best Remix
to mix the elements in a different way.
The central criteria is basing the submission off of something I know already, and changing it to suit your culture in such a way that both the original themes and cultural themes are evident.
1st Lokki242 for Ildaris
2nd Tycho for Vahlshallah
3rd erez87 for United Egyptian Empire
Tycho and Lokki both remixed CLASSIC jokes. And I found them BOTH hilarious and fitting for their cultures. Although Lokki won because his was more unique and stayed within the criteria better, I honestly preferred the Jokes to the Anti-jokes. It was rather hard to pick 3rd, and there were several good choices. The Egyptian ones edged out on the basis of how their jokes are established. So good job Erez. Iggy and Christos were high up in this criteria as well.
8- Most Concise
expressing or covering much in few words; brief in form but comprehensive in scope; succinct; terse
The winning submission has to combine both briefness with wide scope point of view on the subject.
Note: This doesnt mean the shortest wins, but the
Densest.
1st Optical for Ulyan
2nd Arrow Gamer for Amir
3rd Christos for Japan
Opticals was short, sweet and delicious. Arrow gamers although it seems longer, that is more due to formatting than anything else. In addition, I found jokes within jokes. Its hilarious and speaks much about his society. Christos is similar if more story-based, but Arrow Gamers density won out.
10-Best Stretch
This criteria is looking at how well the submission stretches a current culture to new frontiers and ideas.
1st Lord Iggy of Hyak
2nd SamSniped of Leon
3rd Eltain of Alfrenks
This is the hardest. By definition, the minigames are meant for you to explore details about your culture. I have thus defined this as by the DEGREE it stretches the culture without contradicting any element of that culture so far, and the AMOUNT it adds new cultural information.
Going through all of these, Lord Iggys view points has remained remarkably stable even as it expands and encompasses new views. SamSniped would perhaps fit better in narrative stretch, but the mere weight of the additions to his culture and to the prompt specifically give him the edge. Eltain is similar. If it does stretch by a fewer amount, it stretches a further degree, brining insight on the values of the Alfrenks towards guests and their role in the world.
Again, this seems (and is) somewhat arbitrary but when I judge them specifically to the merit of the criteria, these three came up.
Most Relevant
This criteria is looking to see how closely the submission answers the prompt.
As this prompt is set before the establishment of relevancy, and the fact that this prompt is rather bad to judge for relevancy, I have left it out.
Mods Choice
Completely subjective, this criteria looks at what I like the most, up to 5. I may or may not choose to rank them.
I really enjoyed Lord Iggys and Erez more structured stereo-type joke system, although Eltains short narrative was a breath of fresh air. I definitely enjoyed everyone, but it must be said I laughed the *most* at Tychos and Christos entries. (not the hardest, which I will not reveal for the sake of maintaininga appearances.)
1st goes to Lokki242 for Ildaris. Going through the three criteria, it won the Remix with his excellent anti-jokes and reinterpretation of modern jokes. His was very concise compared to some other entries, which must be considered as the density of his post goes for him. Finally, it added much more to the Ildarin contempt of the Keltian home country; other than the pilgrimage areas of Nessos, of course.
2nd goes to Lord Iggy of Hyak. It isnt very concise, but it is unquestionably dense. I enjoyed his subversions a lot, and it is by far the best at building and expanding what his culture actually is.
3rd goes to Christos of Japan. Ok, this IS somewhat interesting, but bare with me. I have an asian background, and the way he remixed their stereotypes into his new ones appealed to me (even if somewhat crude
). It was quite concise, although the stretch was only brought out from the last parts for the priests and the young emperors training. The fact is, my enjoyment of his submission puts it just over the edge over many other VERY qualified ones.
Again, with such excellent submissions these are ALL hard choices. You are all winners in my final book.
Now, what do our three finalists win? Their people will be easier to become more confidence and harder to discourage. They amuse themselves with the misfortunes of others, while they can laugh at their own mistakes slightly better. Laughter is the best medicine, and they (and I) recieved generous doses.
I advise all to read every submission with an open mind, a loose mouth, and a cup of milk to spray out their nose.