Diamondeye said:Beefy187
CCRunner v2.0
classical_hero
Double A
DrumStudent
Lord OST
Snerk
I'm guessing Snerk, Classical and CCRunner. Not sure though.
Autolycus said:Ooh, Ooh pick me!!!
I'm going to guess that Snerk is Saruman, Beefy is Grima Wormtongue, CCRunner is Lurtz, and I was Ugluk.
Mordor was composed of Gothmog: Stuck in Pi
Witch King: Civplayah
Sauron: Sprig
Nazgul Dark Rider: tycoonist
Nazgul Fell Beast Rider: Civgeneral.
I might have gotten those last two backwards.
RRRaskolnikov said:Ok here are my guesses (have been reading the thread but not thinking much at it since my death, so i hope it provides you with a good laugh ):
Saruman: Classical hero
Wormtongue: Beefy
Lurtz: The Last One
Ras
Takhisis said:OK,Camikaze said:Takhisis said:Here we go:
Do I have to justify my choices?
- Snerk-Saruman
- Beefy-Wormtongue
- CCRunner-Lurtz
You don't have to, but it would be interesting...
Snerk=tipoff 8was obvious anyway, as I was already suspecting him, but I thought he was either Wormtongue or Lurtz until...
Beefy: he claims to be Mafia, he's diverting attention from the big fish (who's been very helpful to the good guys and is a terribly good mole) and, to cream it off, you yourself have said that the only way to win was to kill Beefy before Lurtz revived.
CCRunner... he replaces a lurker instead of being WOG'd like the rest of them.
Classical_hero ain't, Autolycus had been PM'ing loads of dung C_h's way, and now Snerk's bandwaggoning on him.
I'm pretty sure I was yeah.Was Snerk lynchable before my death?
Was Snerk lynchable before my death?
I'm pretty sure I was yeah.
I just want to say that when it came to guessing what Camikaze would and would not do as a GM, I got it wrong every single time.
Yeah, Mordor had both sprig and civplayah as initially unlynchable (?), and Isengard had Wormtongue. The clue in the write-up that I was trying to hint to was when you tried to lynch Beefy a second time. It said something like, "he could not be killed until one other had died". And then Autolycus died. So after Auto died, you could've, and should've, killed Beefy. For the town to have had any realistic chance of winning, they needed to lynch Beefy on Day Seventeen, although if they lynched Beefy on Day Eighteen, Isengard would've won anyway.
Is this a good thing or a bad thing?
The Torch, when used, gave the leaders of Gondor, Denethor, and Rohan each other's cover roles. At that time, that put me in contact with atpg and diamondeye.
Snerk did use his ability. We all had access to our own and our cover roles' abilities.
I'd say the primary thing that broke this game was Beefy's immunity to lynch while I was alive. We lose if that hadn't been there. Speaking of which, much sadness at Beefy for replying to everyone when I BCCed him, I might have survived if he hadn't done that. On another note, was Snerk lynchable before I died? If so, then I am sad that I didn't try to get him lynched to make myself the Dark Lord Ugluk.
What??? I voted for Snerk and was right... and I voted Earthling foe antagonising pretty much everyone.Wish you'd been just a little more adventurous with your voting, Takhisis;
So that's why you were hiding.... actually, that's canon, as Gríma is the one who kills Saruman.I'm pretty sure I was yeah.
Try arguing more by private. You suddenly clammed up and stopped answering.I was so dead certain that Bad Player was not mafia (and DEFINITELY IN CAPITAL LETTERS not Ugluk), but I didn't know how to convince anyone else.
Oh I see...Well, correct, but...incorrect reasoning. CCRunner was converted after Auto's death. He was chosen by Beefy and Snerk because he had been scanned innocent. So I didn't WOG Charles Li, but rather replaced him, not because it was a major role )it was pretty minor until he was converted), but because Charles Li had said that he would give up his role is someone came to take it. And CCRunner did.