Hopefully the last poll for the tribe-restriction

Which tribes should be not allowed?


  • Total voters
    13

PaGe

Warlord
Joined
Aug 19, 2006
Messages
247
Location
Germany
Hi guys,

servell ideas came out to forbid some tribes, that this DG get's something special and not the classical celts vs. iros game.

Please only vote here, if you play at one of the fanatics teams. For the Civforum-teams there is also a poll at the civforum. That would make it much easier to get the result.
 
This is a bad poll, PaGe. How are you going to interpret the results? Thanks for making it public, but it runs forever, no deadline. And it should have been just options for "No AA UU" and "No Agri" "Niether" and "Both". With the amount of CIFO voters compared to the amount of CFC voters, CIFO will be able to pick and choose what they want. A multiple choice poll is usually a bad idea. I know CIFO likes them, but they are usually a bad idea.
 
There is no need to sum the counts of both forums together since the civforum seems to have more activ voters. With more respect to the fanatics, they polls can be analyzed individually.
The results must be interpreted by the refs. They can decide, that all Tribes with more then 50% of the votes at both forums will be discarded. When only one forum has 50%, then the other poll must at least have 33% or whatever.
 
There is no need to sum the counts of both forums together since the civforum seems to have more activ voters. With more respect to the fanatics, they polls can be analyzed individually.

Yes, I think this poll will give us very precise numbers on which we can base a decision. At least we will know precisely what every single person thinks.
Also, weighting the polls according to the number of active voters at each site sounds like a fair idea. Something like "if you get more than 50% at each site, you are out"...
 
Ich werde hier bei keinen Poll wg der Zivwahl mehr teilnehmen.
Wolln wir nicht noch auspollen ob wir überhaupt pollen wollen?
Ihr tickt doch nicht ganz richtig.

Sry, aber nur weil eine Person nach n neuen Poll schreit,müssen alle anderen wieder warten.

Long live Helios
 
Memento states that he gets the impression that everyone got nuts over these polls. He does not intend to participate in any more of those.

let me say that I assume good faith with everyone who participated in the organization of this event. but this discussion has gone WAY too far already to where it only appears like stickling for details.

templar_x
 
Nette Übersetzung templar ;)

Without my Helios choice, its the same before this Poll.

CiFo choice:
Spoiler :

PHP:
Keine. Alle Zivs erlauben.
Gurkensalat, mike the pike, Newly, Strahler, Vikitor
        5    19.23%
Azteken: (Law, Mil; Jaguarkrieger 1,1,2)
Arminius, Cotta, d73070d0, Der Kantelberg, Gabelbart, Hawkeye, JimmyderLegion, kleinerHeldt, Lenina, McCauchy, Oberostler, PaGe, shädöw, Theseus
        14    53.85%
Inka: (Law, exp; Chasqui 1,1,2)
Arminius, Cotta, d73070d0, Der Kantelberg, Gabelbart, Hawkeye, JimmyderLegion, kleinerHeldt, Lenina, McCauchy, Oberostler, PaGe, shädöw, Theseus
        14    53.85%
Irkosen: (Law, kom; Irokesenkrieger 3,1,2)
Arminius, Cotta, d73070d0, Der Kantelberg, Frederick Steiner, Gabelbart, Hawkeye, JimmyderLegion, kleinerHeldt, Lenina, Masqurin, McCauchy, Oberostler, ori-gm, PaGe, shädöw, Theseus, Uaargh!?
        18    69.23%
Maya: (Law, ind; Speerwerfer 2,2,1)
Arminius, Cotta, d73070d0, Der Kantelberg, Gabelbart, Hawkeye, JimmyderLegion, kleinerHeldt, Lenina, McCauchy, Oberostler, PaGe, shädöw, Theseus, Uaargh!?
        15    57.69%
Kelten: (Law, rel; Gallischer Schwertkämpfer 3,2,2)
Arminius, Cotta, d73070d0, Der Kantelberg, Frederick Steiner, Gabelbart, Hawkeye, JimmyderLegion, kleinerHeldt, Lenina, Masqurin, McCauchy, Oberostler, ori-gm, PaGe, shädöw, Theseus, Uaargh!?
        18    69.23%
Niederlande: (Law, see; Schweizer Söldner 1,4,1)
Arminius, d73070d0, Der Kantelberg, Frederick Steiner, Gabelbart, Hawkeye, JimmyderLegion, kleinerHeldt, Lenina, Masqurin, McCauchy, Oberostler, PaGe, shädöw, Theseus, Uaargh!?
        16    61.54%
Sumerer: (Law, Wis; Enkidu 1,2,1)
Arminius, d73070d0, Der Kantelberg, Gabelbart, Hawkeye, JimmyderLegion, kleinerHeldt, Lenina, McCauchy, Oberostler, PaGe, shädöw, Theseus, Uaargh!?
        14    53.85%
Persien: (wis, ind; Krummsäbel 4,2,1)
Cotta, d73070d0, Der Kantelberg, Frederick Steiner, Gabelbart, kleinerHeldt, ori-gm, PaGe, shädöw
        9    34.62%
Römer: (mil, kom, Legionär 3,3,1)
PaGe, shädöw
        2    7.69%
Hethetien: (kom, exp; Dreier-Streitwagen 2,2,2)
Gabelbart, shädöw
        2    7.69%
Ägypten: (rel, ind; Kriegsstreitwagen 2,1,2)
Gabelbart, ori-gm, shädöw
        3    11.54%
Babylon: (Wis, rel; Schw. Bogenschütze 2,2,1)
shädöw
        1    3.85%
Zulu: (mil, exp; Impi 1,2,2)
Der Kantelberg, Gabelbart, shädöw
        3    11.54%
GriechenlandWis, kom; Hoplite 1,3,1)
Der Kantelberg, shädöw
        2    7.69%
Kathago: (ind, see; numidischer Söldner 2,3,1)
Der Kantelberg, shädöw
        2    7.69%
Byzanz: (wis, see; Dromon 2,1,3(4))
ori-gm, shädöw
        2    7.69%
Egal
apollon, Erpel, Fonte Randa
        3    11.54%

So we play only without agri?

Is this the final Poll, or need we another? :mischief:
 
Top Bottom