NOTICE
Change of Management
Hi, everyone!
So Gedemon poked his head in recently to give me the nod to take over updating the official version of R.E.D. Modpack for the time being. I'm going to be a little busy for the next couple of weeks, but in the meantime I'd like to revive the conversation from posts #
973-983, and make another call for suggestions for changes based on my unofficial version (
DOWNLOAD HERE).
To the extent it helps,
here is my spreadsheet of changed units (note it may have a few errors or omissions, but it's fairly close) [it's a bit easier to read if you download it and view it in Excel]. The key for the colored X's and highlights can be found in the upper right.
* * * * *
I just went through and highlighted all of the units that BrutalSamurai22 lists in his
Ethnic Units mod to investigate the oft-stated claim that it has "more units."
Ethnic Units hasn't been updated in nearly a year, so perhaps I can carry on the torch for his mod also.
Regarding the highlighting, the cells in green don't have a R.E.D. counterpart, the ones in yellow do, and the ones in red are unique units anyway, so they don't really matter (unless the user is using a mod that changes the uniques for that civ; R.E.D. also has some of these, but I didn't think it was worth counting).
For those who care about the count, here are some statistics:
Number of units applied (though R.E.D. does more sharing than E.U.):
E.U.:
545
R.E.D.:
766 810 and counting!
Number of models included (though many units contain multiple models):
E.U.:
619
R.E.D.:
818 966 and counting!
That being said, Ethnic Units does include
quite a few units that R.E.D. doesn't, and some unit types that see some coverage in E.U. aren't included at all in R.E.D.
So, checking out what BrutalSamurai22 does with those units where there is green highlighting in my spreadsheet is the first order of business.
For instance, I do quite like the ancient/medieval reskins for America (they have insignias of a white star on a blue field). [These have been added.]
What are ya'lls thoughts on following Ethnic Units' lead, and changing the anti-aircraft and anti-tank lines from artillery pieces into armored vehicles, enabling the use of some of the specialized tanks from danrell's WWII pack? There are some interesting models, but in the end I find that it just makes it hard to tell tanks from guns, so at the moment I'm leaning against it.