(CONFIRMED) Military Academy Bug

T

The_CatSnack

Warlord

Joined

Aug 31, 2005

Messages

180

• Jul 20, 2007

• #1

Not sure if this is a bug or not. Maybe I overlooked something in the tech tree, but I can't explain as to why I can build a Military Academy with my great general BEFORE i have the Military science technology. The game lists this as a prerequisite tech and yet in my last game I built one in one of my cities without a problem.

 

M

MacGyverInSpace

Monarch

Joined

Mar 30, 2007

Messages

312

Location

a.k.a. a.a.5, toasters. . . .

• Jul 20, 2007

• #2

Maybe its like FFH, and a certain trait allows Military Academies to be built normally, but only with the right tech. IIRC you can build "Command Posts" using the Great Commander in FFH regardless of techs, but need "Military Strategy" and organized to build them without. The odd similarity sounds like its based off of FFH.

 

G

GMTemplar

Chieftain

Joined

Jul 8, 2007

Messages

41

• Jul 20, 2007

• #3

This is definitely a bug. Even though the Military Academy says it needs Military Science, it doesn't. You can build one as soon as you get your first Great General (even before Education which was the prequisite before IIRC).

 

ainwood

Consultant.

Administrator

Moderator

Joined

Oct 5, 2001

Messages

30,085

• Jul 20, 2007

• #4

Believe it or not, a save file would be useful here. It means that firaxis can see the problem without having to play through a game or define a worldbuilder game to set-up this issue.

 

ainwood

Consultant.

Administrator

Moderator

Joined

Oct 5, 2001

Messages

30,085

• Jul 20, 2007

• #5

Bug Description:
A great general can build a military academy before the player has the Military Science technology.

Expected Behavior
A great general should not be able to build a military academy until the player has discovered military science. When a great general is selected, the pop-up info (bottom left of the screen) note (in red) "Requires Military Science". As such, the "build military academy" unit action button should be disabled, and the building unavailable.

Actual Behavior
The "Build Military Academy" button is not disabled, and the building can be built.

Steps to reproduce

1. Download the attached zip and extract the save file.
2. Load the save and activate the Great General in Moscow.
3. Observe that the pop-up says (in red) "Requires Military Science". Observe that the "Build Military Academy" unit action is not disabled.
4. Push the "Build Military Academy" button, and observe that military academy is in fact built in Moscow.

 

sigmakan

Warlord

Joined

May 7, 2006

Messages

217

• Jul 31, 2007

• #6

Um . . . this is quite similar so I figured I'd post it in the same thread.

The same thing applies to Great Spies and scotland yard. It looks even more ridiculous than the Military Academy. THere shouldnt be a skyscraper in a Classical Era city.

 

JesusOnEez

Emperor

Joined

Jan 5, 2006

Messages

1,030

Location

Braintree, UK

• Aug 13, 2007

• #7

This is weird. I have noticed the Build Academy button is 'live', but when pressing it it will not build the Military Academy. The button remains after pushing it. I can only build the MA after MS. I thought it was a bug that the button should be live, albeit not working (should be ghosted, or not there at all).

 

50_dollar_bag

Imitation Louis Vuitton

Joined

Jun 13, 2005

Messages

977

Location

36 52 S 174 45 E

• Aug 13, 2007

• #8

Does the Military Academy have an effect before Military Science is discovered? I did this last night but just assumed the production bonus would kick-in with the right tech. (i meant to click Military instructor anyway )

 

U

Underdawg

King

Joined

Oct 10, 2005

Messages

672

Location

Wet Coast... er... West Coast, CAN

• Aug 14, 2007

• #9

50_dollar_bag said:

Does the Military Academy have an effect before Military Science is discovered? I did this last night but just assumed the production bonus would kick-in with the right tech. (i meant to click Military instructor anyway )

Click to expand...

Yep.

Solver's Unofficial Patch fixes this BTW.

 

C

CMOS4

Chieftain

Joined

Aug 14, 2007

Messages

12

• Aug 14, 2007

• #10

As I understand it, that is the whole point of the great General. He allows you to build the building WAY BEFORE you would otherwise be able to do it. I think that this is an intended benefit. The cofusing part is that they describe it as a unique building which it is not. I usually create military instructors, but if you are ina big war early on, a military acedemy is a nice benefit.

 

MrPopov

King

Joined

Jul 25, 2006

Messages

985

• Aug 15, 2007

• #11

CMOS, Military Academy's can ONLY be built using Great Generals.

The idea is that not until you discover Military Science should you be able to use a GG to build a Mil. Academy.