Winner
Diverse in Unity
Winner masks his racism towards Arabs by pretending to be naive.
Winner is just sick of people who use the R-word wrongly to insult opponents.
He claims that the only way of solving Israeli-Palestinian problem is, well, giving all the Palestine (and Golan Heights, and Shebaa) to israel, and none other than destroying Palestinians altogether, by expulsing them and making them assimilate.
That's a patent and vile lie, Squonk. I have always said that the acceptable way is to transfer the population, I have never said it should be destroyed or force-assimilated. If you say otherwise, quote me on that and we can discuss it, otherwise I expect your apology.
That is not only one-sided, but also short-sighted and clearly dumb. I won't discuss the first part, why is it unfair towards Palestinians etc, because it's obvious.
What may not seem obvious is why it won't solve anything.
It's not dumb just because you don't like it. It's a radical solution, but an effective one - a solution which would end the acute phase of the conflict.
First, it will not solve problem, but export it outside Israel's borders.
Which is an achievement in itself. Furthermore, I didn't say it will end the conflict, it will just help to end it in a long term.
People wanting revenge on Israel, people wanted it to perish won't disappear, instead they will grow tenfold, among palestinian and other arab and muslim populations.
Your claim, nothing more, nothing less. Since some 99% of Arabs want to destroy Israel already, it would make much difference.
It will increase the pressure on neighbour lands not to sign deals with Israel. It will destabilise them internally.
Israel couldn't care less if some governments don't sign an official peace treaty. Israel isn't threatened as much by conventional attack from neigbouring countries, it is threatened by unconventional warfare and the demographic bomb.
It will make open borders between Israel and arab countries completely impossible for a century or more.
A low price for lasting peace withing Israel and the annexed territories.
It will make Israel lose any support it has not among western nations, apart perhaps for people of Winner's kind.
Stop talking about me as if I wasn't here, Squonky, it's rather lame. Israel doesn't have much support in the West anyway, so it could hardly get any worse. In the end, Western nations would simply accept it as a final solution to the problem and move on, like they always do. There would be fallout and a lot of anger in the Islamic world, but Israel can live with that, just as it lived with it for the past 60 years.
It can't live with a rapidly growing impoverished and increasingly radicalized hostile population within its borders which is hell bent on destroying the state of Israel. It's a recipe for a catastrophe much worse than a tranfer of 3 million Palestinians to other Arab countries could be.