Unique Unit Elimination Thread

B-17- 19
Minuteman- 18
Camel Archer- 20
Jaguar Warrior- 21
Chu-Ko-Nu- 23
Longbowman- 21
Ship of the Line- 21
Foreign Legion- 21
Musketeer- 20
Landsknecht- 20
Panzer- 14-
Companion Cavalry- 16
Hoplite- 17
War Elephant- 21
Mohawk Warrior- 21
Samurai- 25
Zero- 2
Janissary- 24
Sipahi- 20
Immortal- 21
Bastilla- 20
Legion- 21
Cossack- 21
Naresuan's Elephant- 23
Mandekalu Cavalry- 21
 
B-17- 19
Minuteman- 18
Camel Archer- 20
Jaguar Warrior- 21
Chu-Ko-Nu- 23
Longbowman- 21
Ship of the Line- 21
Foreign Legion- 21
Musketeer- 20
Landsknecht- 20
Panzer- 14-
Companion Cavalry- 16
Hoplite- 17
War Elephant- 21
Mohawk Warrior- 21
Samurai- 26 (+1)
Zero- 0 (-2)
Janissary- 24
Sipahi- 20
Immortal- 21
Bastilla- 20
Legion- 21
Cossack- 21
Naresuan's Elephant- 23
Mandekalu Cavalry- 21

The Zero is just a unit that lacks a good use whereas the samurai combined with the Japanese UA is super powerful.
 
B-17- 19
Minuteman- 18
Camel Archer- 20
Jaguar Warrior- 21
Chu-Ko-Nu- 23
Longbowman- 21
Ship of the Line- 21
Foreign Legion- 21
Musketeer- 20
Landsknecht- 20
Panzer- 14-
Companion Cavalry- 16
Hoplite- 15 -2
War Elephant- 21
Mohawk Warrior- 21
Samurai- 26
Janissary- 25 +1
Sipahi- 20
Immortal- 21
Bastilla- 20
Legion- 21
Cossack- 21
Naresuan's Elephant- 23
Mandekalu Cavalry- 21

zero got removed from list
 
B-17- 19
Minuteman- 18
Camel Archer- 20
Jaguar Warrior- 21
Chu-Ko-Nu- 23
Longbowman- 21
Ship of the Line- 19
Foreign Legion- 21
Musketeer- 20
Landsknecht- 20
Panzer- 14
Companion Cavalry- 16
Hoplite- 15
War Elephant- 21
Mohawk Warrior- 21
Samurai- 26
Janissary- 26
Sipahi- 20
Immortal- 21
Bastilla- 20
Legion- 21
Cossack- 21
Naresuan's Elephant- 23
Mandekalu Cavalry- 21

There are no Keshliks so I voted for Jans as a second choice.
I voted against Ship of Line because naval UUs, air UUs & UUs coming late in play are not that useful.
 
B-17- 19
Minuteman- 18
Camel Archer- 20
Jaguar Warrior- 21
Chu-Ko-Nu- 23
Longbowman- 21
Ship of the Line- 17
Foreign Legion- 21
Musketeer- 20
Landsknecht- 20
Panzer- 14
Companion Cavalry- 17
Hoplite- 15
War Elephant- 21
Mohawk Warrior- 21
Samurai- 26
Janissary- 26
Sipahi- 20
Immortal- 21
Bastilla- 20
Legion- 21
Cossack- 21
Naresuan's Elephant- 23
Mandekalu Cavalry- 21
 
B-17- 19
Minuteman- 18
Camel Archer- 20
Jaguar Warrior- 21
Chu-Ko-Nu- 23
Longbowman- 22
Ship of the Line- 17
Foreign Legion- 21
Musketeer- 20
Landsknecht- 20
Panzer- 14
Companion Cavalry- 17
Hoplite- 13
War Elephant- 21
Mohawk Warrior- 21
Samurai- 26
Janissary- 26
Sipahi- 20
Immortal- 21
Bastilla- 20
Legion- 21
Cossack- 21
Naresuan's Elephant- 23
Mandekalu Cavalry- 21
 
B-17- 19
Minuteman- 18
Camel Archer- 20
Jaguar Warrior- 22
Chu-Ko-Nu- 23
Longbowman- 22
Ship of the Line- 17
Foreign Legion- 21
Musketeer- 20
Landsknecht- 20
Panzer- 14
Companion Cavalry- 17
Hoplite- 13
War Elephant- 21
Mohawk Warrior- 21
Samurai- 26
Janissary- 26
Sipahi- 20
Immortal- 21
Bastilla- 18
Legion- 21
Cossack- 21
Naresuan's Elephant- 23
Mandekalu Cavalry- 21


Edited, copied the wrong standings.
 
Zero's been gone for a while...

I think you copied the wrong list.

EDIT: OK, that's fine now :)
 
B-17- 19
Minuteman- 18
Camel Archer- 20
Jaguar Warrior- 22
Chu-Ko-Nu- 23
Longbowman- 23
Ship of the Line- 17
Foreign Legion- 21
Musketeer- 20
Landsknecht- 18
Panzer- 14
Companion Cavalry- 17
Hoplite- 13
War Elephant- 21
Mohawk Warrior- 21
Samurai- 26
Janissary- 26
Sipahi- 20
Immortal- 21
Ballista- 18
Legion- 21
Cossack- 21
Naresuan's Elephant- 23
Mandekalu Cavalry- 21

Fixed typo
 
B-17- 19
Minuteman- 18
Camel Archer- 20
Jaguar Warrior- 22
Chu-Ko-Nu- 24
Longbowman- 23
Ship of the Line- 17
Foreign Legion- 21
Musketeer- 20
Landsknecht- 18
Panzer- 14
Companion Cavalry- 17
Hoplite- 13
War Elephant- 21
Mohawk Warrior- 21
Samurai- 26
Janissary- 26
Sipahi- 20
Immortal- 21
Ballista- 16
Legion- 21
Cossack- 21
Naresuan's Elephant- 23
Mandekalu Cavalry- 21
 
B-17- 17
Minuteman- 18
Camel Archer- 20
Jaguar Warrior- 22
Chu-Ko-Nu- 24
Longbowman- 23
Ship of the Line- 17
Foreign Legion- 21
Musketeer- 20
Landsknecht- 18
Panzer- 14
Companion Cavalry- 17
Hoplite- 13
War Elephant- 21
Mohawk Warrior- 21
Samurai- 26
Janissary- 27
Sipahi- 20
Immortal- 21
Ballista- 16
Legion- 21
Cossack- 21
Naresuan's Elephant- 23
Mandekalu Cavalry- 21
 
Ok, I'll lend you a hand, Sparthage.
I've re-read all posts since the first one, and took note of the votes, instead of the lists (since most of them were wrong anyway). Updated with glaivemaster, we have:

-War chariot eliminated by ccv
-zero eliminated by Resident Mario (so Fatlob's vote against it doesn't count).
-Hoplite 13 (+1 -8)
-Panzer 14 (-6)
-Landsknecht 16 (-4)
-Ballista 16 (-4)
-Ship of the line 17 (+1 -4)
-Companion cavalry 17 (+1 -4)
-B17 17 (+1 -4)
-Minutemen 18 (-2)
-Camel archer 20 (+2 -2)
-War elephant 21 (+1)
-Mohawk warrior 21 (+1)
-Cossack 21 (+1)
-Immortal 21 (+1)
-Legion 21 (+1)
-Mandekalu cavalry 21 (+1)
-Foreign Legion 21 (+1)
-Jaguar warrior 22 (+2)
-Longbowman 23 (+3)
-Naresuan elephant 23 (+3)
-Chu-Ko-Nu 24 (+4)
-Samurai 26 (+6)
-Janissary 30 (+10)

If there's a UU missing, it means that nobody has neither voted for it nor against it.
Since the voting rythm has calmed down, it is no longer really necessary, but I strongly second Vexing's post #33 for the organisation of the thread.
 
-Hoplite 13
-Panzer 14
-Landsknecht 16
-Ballista 16
-Ship of the line 17
-Companion cavalry 17
-B17 17
-Minutemen
-Camel archer 20
-War elephant 21
-Mohawk warrior 21
-Cossack 21
-Immortal 21
-Legion 21
-Mandekalu cavalry 21
-Foreign Legion 21
-Jaguar warrior 22
-Longbowman 23
-Naresuan elephant 23
-Chu-Ko-Nu 24
-Samurai 26
-Janissary 30
-Sipahi 20
-Musketeer 20
 
I think this one's going to take a bit too long... What info didn't we get from 10 points that we'll get from 20?

-Hoplite 13
-Panzer 14
-Landsknecht 16
-Ballista 16
-Ship of the line 17
-Companion cavalry 17
-B17 15 (-)
-Minutemen
-Camel archer 20
-War elephant 21
-Mohawk warrior 21
-Cossack 21
-Immortal 21
-Legion 21
-Mandekalu cavalry 21
-Foreign Legion 21
-Jaguar warrior 23 (+)
-Longbowman 23
-Naresuan elephant 23
-Chu-Ko-Nu 24
-Samurai 26
-Janissary 30
-Sipahi 20
-Musketeer 20
 
Zero's been gone for a while...

I think you copied the wrong list.

EDIT: OK, that's fine now :)

don't worry,after this elimination,we can make it. now i'll vote:

-Hoplite 13
-Panzer 14
-Landsknecht 16
-Ballista 16
-Ship of the line 17
-Companion cavalry 17
-B17 13 (-2)
-Minutemen 18
-Camel archer 20
-War elephant 21
-Mohawk warrior 21
-Cossack 21
-Immortal 21
-Legion 21
-Mandekalu cavalry 22 (+1)
-Foreign Legion 21
-Jaguar warrior 23
-Longbowman 23
-Naresuan elephant 23
-Chu-Ko-Nu 24
-Samurai 26
-Janissary 30
-Sipahi 20
-Musketeer 20

+1 for Mandekalu cavalry,that is the second best uu in the game(the first one is keshik,but it doesn't have here)
 
-Hoplite 13
-Panzer 14
-Landsknecht 16
-Ballista 16
-Ship of the line 17
-Companion cavalry 17
-B17 11
-Minutemen 18
-Camel archer 20
-War elephant 21
-Mohawk warrior 21
-Cossack 21
-Immortal 21
-Legion 21
-Mandekalu cavalry 22
-Foreign Legion 21
-Jaguar warrior 23
-Longbowman 23
-Naresuan elephant 23
-Chu-Ko-Nu 24
-Samurai 26
-Janissary 30
-Sipahi 20
-Musketeer 21

Musketeer, because more strengh is universally good and it's a key unit...
B17, because it's the latest UU, can't be game changing: you're either in front or behind everyone then it's useless...
 
-Hoplite 13
-Panzer 14
-Landsknecht 16
-Ballista 16
-Ship of the line 17
-Companion cavalry 17
-B17 11
-Minutemen 18
-Camel archer 20
-War elephant 21
-Mohawk warrior 21
-Cossack 21
-Immortal 21
-Legion 21
-Mandekalu cavalry 22
-Foreign Legion 21
-Jaguar warrior 23
-Longbowman 23
-Naresuan elephant 23
-Chu-Ko-Nu 24
-Samurai 27 (+1)
-Janissary 28 (-2)

-Sipahi 20
-Musketeer 21

Let's keep this a bit more of an even match, shall we?
 
-Hoplite 13
-Panzer 12 (-2)
-Landsknecht 16
-Ballista 16
-Ship of the line 17
-Companion cavalry 17
-B17 11
-Minutemen 18
-Camel archer 20
-War elephant 21
-Mohawk warrior 21
-Cossack 21
-Immortal 21
-Legion 21
-Mandekalu cavalry 22
-Foreign Legion 21
-Jaguar warrior 23
-Longbowman 23
-Naresuan elephant 24 (+1)
-Chu-Ko-Nu 24
-Samurai 27
-Janissary 28
-Sipahi 20
-Musketeer 21
 
hm, I have never seen samurai as that superior, the shock I and more general production are nice, but not #2 ( at the moment ) or did i miss there something ?

The other thing is minuteman, even when it is too early to say which place they will take, Imho I see them higher, ignoring terrain costs is nice.
 
Top Bottom