budweiser
King of the Beers
Pretty clear why that is. Keshiks only have 16 ranged combat strength, while CAs have 21 ranged combat strength out of the box. Although Keshiks have the quick study promotion, so they earn promotions 50% faster, each percentage promotion for a CA packs far more punch than the same promotion for Keshiks. There are 3 promotions that increase ranged combat strength by 45%, plus volley for an additoinal 50% vs. cities and fortified units.
So the max punch of a Keshik (without volley) is only a bit greater (23.2 strength) than an unpromoted CA. A fully promoted CA will earn 30.45 ranged strength without volley, which rises to 40.95 with volley, while a Keshik will max out at 31.2 with volley.
These two games really put that in perspective for me. I went into this thinking the Keshik would be enough just by itself. It has just moved down a little bit in my list of greatest UUs and the CA has moved up.
But, combine the bonus vs CS with Keshik and maybe you are back to even with CA. So should the Mongol player just go around conquering CS until he has a huge wide empire then coast to victory at the expense of reputation?