Peace Theme Elimination Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
America- 22
Arabia- 22
Assyria- 20
Austria- 20
Aztec- 21
Babylon- 11
Brazil- 17
Byzantium- 21-3=18 Kinda boring theme and way too depressing for a peace theme.
Carthage- 14
Celts- 17
China- 20
Denmark- 17
Dutch- 21
Egypt- 17
England- 21
Ethiopia- 21+1=22 This is a theme that I can listen to for hours without ever getting tired. It's simply amazing.
France- 20
Germany-20
Greece- 20
Huns- 20
Inca- 20
India- 21
Indonesia- 20
Iroquois-14
Japan- 18
Korea- 20
Maya- 20
Mongolia- 17
Morocco- 20
Ottoman- 20
Persia- 21
Poland- 23
Polynesia- 20
Portugal- 20
Rome- 2
Russia- 17
Shoshone- 21
Siam- 17
Songhai- 15
Sweden- 22
Venice- 21
Zulu- 20
 
Ethiopia's score should be 23, not 22. Han didn't take into account cpm's vote and so made Killbray's scoring is now wrong.
 
UPDATED SCORES:

America-22
Arabia-22
Assyria-20
Austria-20
Aztec-21
Babylon-11
Brazil-17
Byzantium-18
Carthage-14
Celts-17
China-20
Denmark-17
Dutch-21
Egypt-17
England-21
Ethiopia-23
France-20
Germany-20
Greece-20
Huns-20
Inca-20
India-21
Indonesia-20
Iroquois-14
Japan-18
Korea-20
Maya-20
Mongolia-17
Morocco-20
Ottoman-20
Persia-21
Poland-23
Polynesia-20
Portugal-20
Rome-2
Russia-17
Shoshone-21
Siam-17
Songhai-15
Sweden-22
Venice-21
Zulu-20
 
Sorry about that, thought I'd fixed it. Anyone think Rome will be saved by some sorcery?
 
Sorry about that, thought I'd fixed it. Anyone think Rome will be saved by some sorcery?
Nope, it's getting too much hate to even get the whopping two upvotes it needs to survive even a single downvote. Won't happen... I think I'm going to lose my 20 nonexistent smackaroos :(
 
America-22
Arabia-22
Assyria-20
Austria-20
Aztec-21
Babylon-11-3=8
Brazil-17
Byzantium-18
Carthage-14
Celts-17
China-20
Denmark-17
Dutch-21
Egypt-17
England-21
Ethiopia-23
France-20
Germany-20
Greece-20
Huns-20
Inca-20
India-21
Indonesia-20
Iroquois-14
Japan-18+1=19
Korea-20
Maya-20
Mongolia-17
Morocco-20
Ottoman-20
Persia-21
Poland-23
Polynesia-20
Portugal-20
Rome-2
Russia-17
Shoshone-21
Siam-17
Songhai-15
Sweden-22
Venice-21
Zulu-20

Sorry folks, I still dislike Babylon's more :p

I'll add a vote for Japan. That's a really pleasant theme.
 
America-22
Arabia-22+1=23
Assyria-20
Austria-20
Aztec-21
Babylon-8
Brazil-17
Byzantium-18
Carthage-14
Celts-17
China-20
Denmark-17
Dutch-21
Egypt-17
England-21
Ethiopia-23
France-20
Germany-20
Greece-20
Huns-20
Inca-20
India-21
Indonesia-20
Iroquois-14
Japan-19
Korea-20
Maya-20
Mongolia-17
Morocco-20
Ottoman-20
Persia-21
Poland-23
Polynesia-20
Portugal-20
Rome-2-3=-1 ELIMINATED
Russia-17
Shoshone-21
Siam-17
Songhai-15
Sweden-22
Venice-21
Zulu-20

Arabia: I've lived in Jerusalem for the past two years, and sometimes, when I went to the Old City Market, I would hear this song playing in my head.

Rome: Congratulations! You, Rome, have lost the most weight and have become the BIGGEST LOSER!
 
CURRENT RANKINGS: (Check the first post from now on to see the up to date rankings)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
43. Rome
 
America-22
Arabia-23
Assyria-20
Austria-20
Aztec-21
Babylon-9 Why is Babs so low this theme has crazy atmosphere.
Brazil-17
Byzantium-18
Carthage-14
Celts-17
China-20
Denmark-17
Dutch-21
Egypt-17
England-21
Ethiopia-23
France-17 Outclassed by the Netherlands' peace theme in being the happy one in the game.
Germany-20
Greece-20
Huns-20
Inca-20
India-21
Indonesia-20
Iroquois-14
Japan-19
Korea-20
Maya-20
Mongolia-17
Morocco-20
Ottoman-20
Persia-21
Poland-23
Polynesia-20
Portugal-20
Russia-17
Shoshone-21
Siam-17
Songhai-15
Sweden-22
Venice-21
Zulu-20
 
America-22
Arabia-23
Assyria-20
Austria-20
Aztec-21
Babylon-9
Brazil-17
Byzantium-18
Carthage-14
Celts-17
China-20
Denmark-17
Dutch-21+1=22 I agree with the previous poster, this theme is full of energy
Egypt-17
England-21
Ethiopia-23
France-17
Germany-20
Greece-20
Huns-20
Inca-20
India-21
Indonesia-20
Iroquois-14
Japan-19
Korea-20
Maya-20
Mongolia-17
Morocco-20
Ottoman-20
Persia-21
Poland-23
Polynesia-20
Portugal-20
Russia-17
Shoshone-21
Siam-17
Songhai-15
Sweden-22
Venice-21-3=18 It just doesn't have anything that makes it stand out, it sounds rather boring
Zulu-20
 
America-22
Arabia-23
Assyria-20
Austria-20
Aztec-21
Babylon-9-3=6
Brazil-17
Byzantium-18
Carthage-14
Celts-17
China-20
Denmark-17
Dutch-22
Egypt-17
England-21
Ethiopia-23
France-17
Germany-20
Greece-20
Huns-20
Inca-20
India-21
Indonesia-20
Iroquois-14
Japan-19
Korea-20
Maya-20
Mongolia-17
Morocco-20
Ottoman-20
Persia-21
Poland-23
Polynesia-20
Portugal-20
Russia-17
Shoshone-21
Siam-17
Songhai-15
Sweden-22+1=23
Venice-18
Zulu-20

Sweden: Brilliant theme. It just gets better as it goes along.

Babylon: Babylon, you're next. The theme just sounds boring.
 
America-22
Arabia-23
Assyria-20
Austria-20
Aztec-21
Babylon-6-3=3
Brazil-17
Byzantium-18
Carthage-14
Celts-17
China-20
Denmark-17
Dutch-22+1=23
Egypt-17
England-21
Ethiopia-23
France-17
Germany-20
Greece-20
Huns-20
Inca-20
India-21
Indonesia-20
Iroquois-14
Japan-19
Korea-20
Maya-20
Mongolia-17
Morocco-20
Ottoman-20
Persia-21
Poland-23
Polynesia-20
Portugal-20
Russia-17
Shoshone-21
Siam-17
Songhai-15
Sweden-23
Venice-18
Zulu-20

I'm going to vote Babylon again it's a boring theme.

As for Dutch both themes are awesome so they deserve more votes.
 
America-22
Arabia-23
Assyria-21 Super majestic and beautiful
Austria-20
Aztec-18 Most of this song is buildup, and not interesting buildup at that.
Babylon-3
Brazil-17
Byzantium-18
Carthage-14
Celts-17
China-20
Denmark-17
Dutch-23
Egypt-17
England-21
Ethiopia-23
France-17
Germany-20
Greece-20
Huns-20
Inca-20
India-21
Indonesia-20
Iroquois-14
Japan-19
Korea-20
Maya-20
Mongolia-17
Morocco-20
Ottoman-20
Persia-21
Poland-23
Polynesia-20
Portugal-20
Russia-17
Shoshone-21
Siam-17
Songhai-15
Sweden-23
Venice-18
Zulu-20
 
Babylon is hanging by a silk thread! It's my goal to make the Iroquois fall third :D
Anyways...

America-22
Arabia-23
Assyria-21
Austria-20
Aztec-18
Babylon-3
Brazil-17
Byzantium-18
Carthage-14
Celts-17
China-20
Denmark-17
Dutch-23
Egypt-17
England-21
Ethiopia-23
France-17
Germany-20
Greece-20
Huns-20
Inca-20
India-21
Indonesia-20
Iroquois-14 - 3 = 11 If I wanted to hear birds and crickets, I would go to the Amazon and meditate. Notice how I don't live in the Amazon...*
Japan-19
Korea-20
Maya-20
Mongolia-17
Morocco-20
Ottoman-20
Persia-21
Poland-23 +1 = 24 Semi-Immunity to 2 downvotes =:banana: :crazyeye: :D
Polynesia-20
Portugal-20
Russia-17
Shoshone-21
Siam-17
Songhai-15
Sweden-23
Venice-18
Zulu-20

*I have nothing against birds and crickets. The environment and nature are great and all that. The point I'm trying to make here is that when I plop down in to my chair at my computer desk to fire up a game of civ, I expect to hear enlightening music, not the sounds of an underdeveloped, nonindustrial society that was the Iroquois in Hiawatha's days.
 
America-22
Arabia-23
Assyria-21
Austria-20
Aztec-18
Babylon-3-3=0
Brazil-17
Byzantium-18
Carthage-14
Celts-17
China-20
Denmark-17
Dutch-23
Egypt-17
England-21
Ethiopia-23
France-17
Germany-20
Greece-20
Huns-20
Inca-20
India-21
Indonesia-20
Iroquois-11
Japan-19
Korea-20
Maya-20
Mongolia-17
Morocco-20
Ottoman-20
Persia-21
Poland-24
Polynesia-20
Portugal-20+1=21
Russia-17
Shoshone-21
Siam-17
Songhai-15
Sweden-23
Venice-18
Zulu-20

Bye, Babylon. I do think it's a theme that doesn't bring much by itself. Others are more pleasant, more ambient, more majestic... Even Carthage's is more interesting, and it uses the same source material.

Much of what I said about Portugal's war theme applies here. It's a really good arrangement that fits the country it represents.
 
America-22
Arabia-23
Assyria-21
Austria-20
Aztec-18
Brazil-17
Byzantium-18
Carthage-14
Celts-17
China-20
Denmark-17-3 = 14
Dutch-23
Egypt-17
England-21
Ethiopia-23
France-17
Germany-20
Greece-20
Huns-20
Inca-20
India-21
Indonesia-20+1 = 21
Iroquois-11
Japan-19
Korea-20
Maya-20
Mongolia-17
Morocco-20
Ottoman-20
Persia-21
Poland-24
Polynesia-20
Portugal-21
Russia-17
Shoshone-21
Siam-17
Songhai-15
Sweden-23
Venice-18
Zulu-20

First off, Denmark is one of the only leaders where their peace theme takes a long time to actually start (yeah, there's a few drums, but not much else), and the beginning of the theme is what people are going to hear most.

As for my up-vote, I chose Indonesia as I love the blend of instruments used in their theme.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom