I don't know if that'd be against the forum-rules, it's like we're ganging up on him for doing his job. I aggree that he's too harsh imo, I think it'd be the best and fairest way if you write to an admin and state your problem. You can say that you're not the only one who thinks so, and name the people, you can say that I'm willing to state my case too. That way, one of his friends will tell him what people are thinking, making him think over himself hopefully. I don't want him to step down or anything, because I tell you, I already was in unmoderated forums, that is not what you and me want. Maybe we should state to the admin that trolling has various lvls, and that up to our opinion, only really bad trolling should be punished, because be honest, trolling often is a lot of fun for everybody (even for the target) .