[Vote] (7-33) Skirmisher & War Chariot RCS Proposals

[Recursive]

Voting Instructions
Players, please cast your votes in the poll above. Vote "Yea" for every proposal you'd be okay with if it were implemented. Vote "Nay" if you'd be okay if these proposals weren't implemented. You can vote for any number of options.

All votes are public. If you wish, you can discuss your choice(s) in the thread below. You can change your vote as many times as you want until the poll closes.

VP Congress: Session 7, Proposal 33
Discussion Thread: (7-33) Skirmisher +1 RCS
Proposer: @Stalker0
Sponsor: @azum4roll

Proposal Details
Proposal: Raise Skirmisher RCS from 8 to 9 (+1). CS stays the same. Horse Archer UU also receive +1 RCS

Rationale: Skirmishers sit at a unique place in teh game. They have a hefty tech requirement, cost, and just the ability to get horses at that point is still sometimes difficult. For that they do less damage than even a basic archer. Giving them an equal attack power makes sense in that context.



VP Congress: Session 7, Proposal 33a
Discussion Thread: (7-33a) Egypt UU - War Chariot Rework
Proposer: @Yngwie
Sponsor: @azum4roll

Proposal Details
Problem: Upon upgrading War Chariot into Skirmisher by spending Gold and Horses, you gain a Unit with less attack power (9 RCS of War Chariot vs 8 RCS of Skirmisher)

Current War Chariot: 9 CS, 9 RCS
Proposed War Chariot: 9 CS, 8 RCS and +15% attack bonus as part of current special promotion

Rationale: attack bonus instead of Basic CS will solve the problem of upgrading - Egypt will be in the same conditions with all Civs (8 RCS to 8 RCS on upgrade)


Host Notes:

• If neither is implemented, War Chariot will be 9 CS, 9 RCS and Skirmisher will be 12 CS, 8 RCS.
• If only (7-33) is implemented, War Chariot will be 9 CS, 9 RCS and Skirmisher will be 12 CS, 9 RCS.
• If only (7-33a) is implemented, War Chariot will be 9 CS, 8 RCS (+15% attack bonus on promotion) and Skirmisher will be 12 CS, 8 RCS.
• If both are implemented, War Chariot will be 9 CS, 8 RCS (+15% attack bonus on promotion) and Skirmisher will be 12 CS, 9 RCS.
• The War Chariot's promotion is kept on upgrade.

 

[rkkn]

• If neither is implemented, War Chariot will be 9 CS, 9 RCS and Skirmisher will be 8 CS, 8 RCS.
• If only (7-33) is implemented, War Chariot will be 9 CS, 9 RCS and Skirmisher will be 8 CS, 9 RCS.
• If only (7-33a) is implemented, War Chariot will be 9 CS, 8 RCS (+15% attack bonus on promotion) and Skirmisher will be 8 CS, 8 RCS.
• If both are implemented, War Chariot will be 9 CS, 8 RCS (+15% attack bonus on promotion) and Skirmisher will be 8 CS, 9 RCS.
• The War Chariot's promotion is kept on upgrade.

but current Skirmisher has 12 CS 8 RCS
It's Chariot Archer that has 8 CS 8 RCS

 

[Recursive]

Timestamp post to arrange all the threads in a neat order.