Shhhhhh Don't use logic, people hate it when you do that @OP From the code. Each Civ has a WARMONGER HATE metric. This metric, like all others, has the capacity to go up/down +-2 each game. SHAKA's base WARMONGER HATE is 4, but could go up to 6 if the RNG comes out that way. If you see the thread I posted into here : http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=503339 It explains how the WARMONGER THREAT and WARMONGER SCORE is calculated, and where WARMONGER HATE comes into it. You will have to scroll down till you find my reply with code samples. Hope that helps.