All Things Star Wars

Sith or Jedi?

  • Sith

    Votes: 32 37.2%
  • Jedi

    Votes: 51 59.3%
  • Chuck Norris

    Votes: 3 3.5%

  • Total voters
    86
"Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on WU!"

Here's Why Gina Carano Was Fired From 'The Mandalorian'
The former MMA fighter is no stranger to controversy, but fans of the Disney+ show say they have had enough of her right-wing trolling.

Cheyenne Roundtree

Entertainment Reporter

Updated Feb. 10, 2021 11:20PM ET / Published Feb. 10, 2021 4:57PM ET

Actress Gina Carano was swiftly fired from the hit Disney+ series The Mandalorian on Wednesday night after she reshared a post that seemed to suggest having a differing political view in 2021 was similar to being Jewish during the Holocaust.

“Gina Carano is not currently employed by Lucasfilm and there are no plans for her to be in the future,” the production company said in a statement. “Nevertheless, her social media posts denigrating people based on their cultural and religious identities are abhorrent and unacceptable.”

The Daily Beast has also exclusively learned that Carano was dropped by her publicists at ID in fall of 2020 due to her social media activity.

The popular Star Wars franchise had finished season 2 and Carano’s character Cara Dune seemed poised for a return in some form. She had reportedly recently apologized in private to Disney for her posts in hopes that she could land her own spinoff series, reported We Got This Covered.

Earlier in the day, fans took to social media to call for the former MMA fighter, who often shares controversial takes on her social media, to be axed.

Carano had gone on a reposting spree, sharing memes that made fun of the mask mandate in California, compared former President Donald Trump’s second impeachment trial to Groundhog Day, and claimed Jeffrey Epstein didn’t kill himself.

But in arguably her most offensive post yet, Carano reshared to her Instagram story a photo of a Jewish woman in her undergarments screaming as she ran away from men and young boys armed with clubs. The famed image is from 1941 during the Lviv pogroms, where Jewish men and women were massacred by their own neighbors in modern-day Ukraine due to German influence in the area.

“Jews were beaten in the streets, not by Nazi soldiers but by their neighbors…even by children,” the post, which originated elsewhere, read. “Because history is edited, most people today don’t realize that to get to the point where Nazi soldiers could easily round up thousands of Jews, the government first made their own neighbors hate them simply for being Jews. How is that any different from hating someone for their political views?”

It did not go over well, and Carano was quickly accused of amplifying anti-Semitic messages.

She's transphobic, anti-mask, alt-right who parrots QAn*n conspiracies, doesn't believe in systematic racism, and now shares anti-semitic images. @starwars @Disney #FireGinaCarano
@DinsDarksaber

“This is f--king vile and unnecessary,” a tweet read. “Gina carano needs to be held accountable. the oppression my people have faced because of our religion and ethnicity is NOT the same as political disagreements.”

“The level of cognitive dissonance is appalling,” another added. Many of the tweets included the hashtag #FireGinaCarano and tagged the accounts for Disney, Star Wars, and Lucasfilm.

As backlash grew online, Carano quietly deleted the offensive posts from her Instagram story and began furiously liking tweets that applauded how she “counters all of the social media negativity with such grace.” Many of the praise-worthy tweets used the hashtag #istandwithginacarano and #weloveginacarano.

Representatives for Carano did not respond to The Daily Beast’s request for comment by the time of publication.

But Carano has been down this road before.

“The whole reason I started speaking out is because I feel like there is a large group of people that were being silenced this year and being forced to play this game of wokeism or whatever it is...”

She was previously accused of being transphobic when she updated her Twitter bio in apparent mocking of pronouns to say “beep/bop/boop.” She later apologized and said she was educated by her co-star Pedro Pascal, who recently publicly praised his sister for coming out as transgender.

“He helped me understand why people were putting them in their bios,” Carano wrote. “I didn’t know before but I do now. I won’t be putting them in my bio but good for all you who choose to.”

She also encouraged people to follow her on the app Parler, which had been embraced by right-wing groups and where many broadcast the siege on the Capitol in January. Over the summer, the actress also pushed QAnon, coronavirus, and Pizzagate conspiracies.

She attempted to explain her hot takes to the right-wing news outlet The Federalist on its radio show in January.

“The whole reason I started speaking out is because I feel like there is a large group of people that were being silenced this year and being forced to play this game of wokeism or whatever it is,” she said. “No matter who you voted for, no matter who you are, I want to create a platform where everybody can have an opportunity. Everybody.”

The first time this broke, one of my first thoughts was, "Hold on, she was in RA3 opposite Jenny McCarthy! EA sure knows how to pick 'em..."
 
Perhaps not the best time to post that.
 
So, as someone completely alien to the Mandalorian, Twitter, and Instagram, and thus this whole controversy, what is it that happened?

And if she's an alt-right troll (I mean I don't know, but from the article and other snippets I've got, that's what it looks like), why do you stand with her?
 
So, as someone completely alien to the Mandalorian, Twitter, and Instagram, and thus this whole controversy, what is it that happened?

And if she's an alt-right troll (I mean I don't know, but from the article and other snippets I've got, that's what it looks like), why do you stand with her?
Back in November she came under fire for COVID-19 denialism, peddling D'ump's election conspiracy, and alleged transphobic trolling. (@Clubber Lang had originally posted an article on this but was #cancelled.) The backlash led to an apology and a scrub of the posts, but apparently earned her probation from Disney. The recent post seems to have convinced them she wouldn't shape up.

But yeah, given Carano's channelling the same crybully chuds and Russian trollbots that unpersoned Kelly Marie Tran for the crime of *checks notes* playing an unpopular character, I'm more than a little surprised Laurana is so insistent on defending her.
 
People are entitled to any views they like, but if they make their employer embarrassed to represent them, then they'll be out of a job, whether they're a famous film star or Joe down at the supermarket.
 
I’ve largely kept out and been on the fence about the cancellation of Gina largely because I’m burnt out from Twitter drama and only kept my attention to the less controversial segment of Twitter and YouTube (though the only controversy I’ve payed attention is with historical creators on YouTube giving justifiable criticism against YouTube censorship on historical subjects. But that’s a different subject).

People are entitled to any views they like, but if they make their employer embarrassed to represent them, then they'll be out of a job, whether they're a famous film star or Joe down at the supermarket.
It’s precisely why there’s typically an employer policy in regards to social media. If you can sweep aside the sensational fat and clickybaity articles being thrown in the media, it’s what basically boils down to is a breach of employer policy in regards to Disney’s employee policy in regards to social media usage. Though I’m deferring to Occum’s Razor and there may be other details I may have missed that are completely alien for me when it comes to employer-employee relationship in acting and anything to do with Hollywood (eg. Was she under contract?) since I’m only familiar with the employment practices that most people deal with on a daily basis. Especially in regards with At-Will Employment here in most US states.
 
Well, if there's been a breach in contract, we'll probably hear about it soon, but as you note, the US is not exactly renowned for its pro-workforce employment laws.
 
I'm a little bummed out that someone whose work I enjoyed has turned out to be kind of a dope but, let's face it, I never loved her for her intellect. Famously, sports writers back in the day would edit commentary and interviews with athletes as a professional courtesy, and now we live in an age when anyone can publish anything, instantly, with no editor and with a readership of hundreds of thousands or millions, who can in turn instantly share what they read with everyone they've ever met. I think society hasn't come to grips with that. Celebrities just happen to be out in front. (I don't really know what to do about it, either, other than more funding for public education, but that's a topic for another thread.)

I don't really fault Disney for deciding they just don't want to be dealing with this kind of headache over and over, and removing Cara Dune won't exactly shake the foundations. She was fun, but she was a supporting character with no depth or connection to anything.
 
Well, if there's been a breach in contract, we'll probably hear about it soon,
That would be true and, as you said, we would know about it. If she were under contract (and this would also fall under with workers in a union shop), Gina would still be eligible to be fired if it were for a good cause.

Me, if I was in Lucasfilm’s HR department (I know it’s an oversimplification of how they do things in Hollywood, but it’s a framework in more familiar with as with day to day average Joes-n-Janes) and the company policy states, in a nutshell, in their social media policy “Don’t make yourself an ass as we don’t want your online activities to harm our image”. I’d end up having to fire Gina due to her previous conduction of her previous actions (I presume, in comparison with regular employment that we go to, Hollywood would be far less lenient in terms of their discipline policies) because her actions on social media would do more harm to Lucasfilms.

If she were under contract; I’d end up having to have a team of HR specialists and lawyers who are specialized in employment law to ensure that I have a case of “good cause” for firing Gina when she breached a company policy. More so to avoid retaliation from Gina if and when she files a wrongful termination suit.

Celebrities just happen to be out in front. (I don't really know what to do about it, either, other than more funding for public education, but that's a topic for another thread.)
Typically, people who are out in the public or deals with the public has a certain degree of expectation. There just needs to be more awareness that their actions, especially if their account has their real name attached to it, would have consequences when they “make an ass of themselves”.

Gina does have a right to her opinion and views, but she has to realize that she’s also a public figure and that her actions can harm an image of her employer and by extension their brand.

By the looks of Disney and Lucasfilm, and by Thor’s link he made in his last post (though I’d argue that she’s actually in a warning period than probation since that’s usually more often reserved for newly hired employers in their first 60-90 days here in the US), she’s already on thin ice and on a final warning.
 
I wonder if she's important enough to have a good contract. Man, you should SEE the contracts nobodies get - there outta be a law...
At this point, I don’t think other studios would want to touch her for quite awhile unless she pulls a Robert Downey Jr. career resurrection redemption arc in a short order.
 
Typically, people who are out in the public or deals with the public has a certain degree of expectation. There just needs to be more awareness that their actions, especially if their account has their real name attached to it, would have consequences when they “make an ass of themselves”.

Gina does have a right to her opinion and views, but she has to realize that she’s also a public figure and that her actions can harm an image of her employer and by extension their brand.
I agree. I think the celebrities who don't post on social media very much probably have the right idea.

By the looks of Disney and Lucasfilm, and by Thor’s link he made in his last post (though I’d argue that she’s actually in a warning period than probation since that’s usually more often reserved for newly hired employers in their first 60-90 days here in the US), she’s already on thin ice and on a final warning.
I haven't kept apace of this particular drama, but yes, it seems like this was a "last straw" situation. I imagine Disney could be looking ahead and asking themselves if they really need to deal with this, going forward. It's unclear to me whether they voided an existing contract or simply decided not to renew her. If it was the latter, I can imagine them thinking the juice just isn't worth the squeeze.

At this point, I don’t think other studios would want to touch her for quite awhile unless she pulls a Robert Downey Jr. career resurrection redemption arc in a short order.
I do worry about people getting "blackballed." But otoh, Hollywood is a rough business anyway, and nobody's guaranteed anything. I don't see any reason Gina Carano should get work when Deborah Ann Woll can't. I guess I'm also assuming that Carano isn't going to be living on the streets while she's in a timeout. I mean, we're not talking about migrant day-workers, here.
 
One may also note that a lot of the groups that she took potshots at over her time on social media just so happen to be groups that Pedro Pascal is part of (latin-american, refugee (from a right wing dictatorship even!), naturalized american), or closely linked to (trans people, given his sister). And now she's taken to liking posts attacking him directly.

May just be me, but I struggle to think of a job where constantly and gratuitously antagonizing a more senior member of the team (he's the lead actor, she's a supporting actress) is a healthy career choice.
 
Well, that would stand to reason, as Shapiro's whole deal is about manufacturing culture war.
 
I guess I owe you a plate of cookies since apparently the “Facts Don’t Care About Your Feeling” Guy (Ben Shapiro for those not in the know), has picked her up for his Daily Wire production.
Associating herself with that little gnome seems like it would do more damage to her brand than twitter conspiracy-posting. The twitter stuff makes like her look ignorant and mean, but this makes her look like a dork, and when you whole persona is about being an MMA tough-girl that's a pretty fatal blow to your image.
 
Last edited:
not a particular rant or anything but ı have discovered some evil website had a contest about re-imagining Star Wars in which anything goes like Boba Darth the train robbers

z0cimyairyaosuriqwgd.jpg


and hints of cool redesigns and stuff ... But the site doesn't allow access to the thread ...

and possibly unrelated but Darth Ahtapot , octupus in Turkish , as referenced in pages past

--
alexey-mordovets-dart-octopys.jpg
--
 
Top Bottom