Another annoying "helpful" feature from Google

BuckyRea

Boldly Going
Joined
Jan 19, 2005
Messages
1,415
Location
Texas
Two, actually.

First, when I start to type a search string into Google, it starts trying to guess what I'm searching for, throwing out new suggestions with each new letter I type. I don't need another distraction on the internet. Internet usage has already made me flaky and distraction prone. This is just making matters worse. While I'm trying to find out info on the Constitutional Convention, Google starts guessing as I type...

Co - "Do you want Comcast? Costco? Corpse Flower? What corporation should I send you to?"

Con - "Do you want Continental Airlines? Conroe ISD? Conroe Courier? What, what, what do you want, huh?"

Cons - "Do you want Consumer Reports? Consolidated Communications? constant contact? Well? What is it? Tell me!"

Const - "Do you want constant contact? constipation? constellation energy? C'mon, man, spit it out. Well?"

Consti - "Do you want constipation? constitution? constitutional amendments? I think I'm figuring you out, human!"

It's not so much that I can't handle the distractions (I can't, though) but the annoying thought that I'm not in control of my computer. I used to live under the illusion that when I hit the "search" button, that was when I was allowing my search, my thoughts, to become part of Google's searches. Now it's clear to me that Google is reaching into my computer, into my head in a sense, to try and pull out ideas before I've fully formed them. It's the internet equivalent of talking with someone who's constantly interrupting you--someone in this case who can't even wait for me to finish my thoughts, or even to finish a single word of dialog, before running off with a litany of irrelevant suggestions in the hope that one of them will hit the spot.

Now it even starts popping up suggested websites for me to go to before I finish typing. It just seems rude to me. No matter how fast you are, Google, no one likes a show off--particularly a show off who's getting it wrong with 95% of its guesses.

The second feature appears after I hit the "search" button. Instead of being able to scroll down the page with my down cursor key, a little blue triangle appears on the left hand, toggling along to each of the 10 search suggestions. "You may want to scroll with your down cursor key, chump," it seems to be saying to me, "but I say you gotta use the mouse to do that now. Do not attempt to adjust your Google. We are controlling transmission. We control the vertical. We control the horizontal."

I like a smooth scroll, just like my eyes scan when I'm running through a newspaper column. But Google insists on making me jump from suggestions 1-5 to 6-10 as it they're on separate pages. I can work around it, but I just don't see the advantage of them putting that extra pointer on my screen. The whole point of Google used to be its simplicity. I don't begrudge them their ads. Dudes've gotta make a buck, after all. But it's like they're using those bucks to just think of new ways to monkey around with my viewing experience, intrude into my comfort zone, and mess up a user interface system that proved to be perfectly acceptable and effective in the past.

But as above, the biggest problem is that they are interfering with how I use my own computer. I think they need to take a hint from Coca-Cola and introduce a Google Classic search engine. The American tradition of trying to fix success continues.
 
Yeah, that's annoying. A clear case of a program trying to be more "useful", but coming accross as just annoying and obtrusive. That Alan Cooper guy who writes books about user interface should mention it in the new edition of his book.
 
It's still not as bad as Microsoft Office 2007. Take an overly feature-heavy product and then add on so many bells and whistles that users have to toggle between 6 or 7 tool bars just to find the subtool bar where the desired feature can be found, if it can be found. In the word processor, change most of the familiar keystroke commands and make the columns feature nigh unusable. In the spreadsheet make the charts impossible to customize.

Why do they make their customers jump through all these hoops? Because they can.
 
I like the completing thing, because it will show me search phrases that are likely to find results. Sometimes, I'm searching for something and I don't really know how to phrase it. With the suggestions, I can click on a phrase that google already knows how to handle. It works pretty well, I think.

If I already know what I'm searching for then I just search for it and ignore the suggestions. I don't see why that's such a big deal for you tbh :p
 
The suggestions I'm OK with, but searching when you're in the process of typing?
 
I love the new google.

That is all.
 
It's still not as bad as Microsoft Office 2007. Take an overly feature-heavy product and then add on so many bells and whistles that users have to toggle between 6 or 7 tool bars just to find the subtool bar where the desired feature can be found, if it can be found. In the word processor, change most of the familiar keystroke commands and make the columns feature nigh unusable. In the spreadsheet make the charts impossible to customize.

Why do they make their customers jump through all these hoops? Because they can.

Ugh...I hate Office 2007.

They moved EVERYTHING from where you were used to finding it.
 
I was once trying to explain the concept of child grooming to a Twilight fan. If you start typing "child groo---" into google, it recommends "child grooming techniques" I found that very helpful.
 
They moved EVERYTHING from where you were used to finding it.
Which is horribly annoying, until you use it a few times and know where everything is.
I prefer 2007 layout, less digging through menus. Not that it doesn't have its own problems.
 
It's pretty helpful sometimes but sometimes it comes up with the weirdest things.. Just type in "why" and you'll see.
 
The autocomplete is awesome, but this "instant search" thing is a bit over the top. It should at least wait a bit before searching - instead of pulling up results as you type. Who looks down there as they're typing? I might look every once in a while, but don't pull up new results for every new letter I hit please, it's annoying.

By the way, the google instant search was introduced a bit later here in Canada than in the U.S.. has it been rolled out around the world now?
 
I turned off Google Instant.

Sometimes the autocomplete results are hilarious though so I kept it. I once got this

ilovetofartcookbook.png
 
I like the auto-complete function. It can actually be kind of hilarious sometimes.

I liked that blog until FailBlog took it over and put these huge ugly FAIL words on them :sad:
 
Is anyone else infuriated by that pesky band that's new to the left hand side? "Everything, Images, Movies" Christ, any half wit could just as well click the links on the top of the screen; why the hell do we need them on the side as well? Not to mention I'm using a netbook so the bar clogs up half of my monitor. :mad: It's probably the dumbest idea since the Windows dual startbar with the "All Programs" subfolder. :mad: Luckily I got the tools to eliminate them both, but why can't redundant features like that be simply turned-off?
 
Back
Top Bottom