comparing the 500 BC saves (gkey, doshin, snaaty)
@ doshin:
our saves at 500 bc are really quite similar. you will take mosow next turn i guess, giving you also 10 cities and an ai capital. i did trade more then you did, that´s why i have more techs, but if you would start to trade up with mansa, you would be as far down the tech tree as i am. overall research with 230 (yours) to 260 (mine) is also quite equal. what shows a bit is the placement of the helper cities. my capital is a bit bigger (pop 11 to pop 8) and i was able to work both gold all the time (if you would work both gold, your research also would be around 250+). you have quite some more inprovements then i have, it starts to show now that i´m having 30% less workers (you 10, me 7). this might turn into a considerable advantage of your game later.
that you have achived the same with archerpults as i have with elepults doesnt make my warring skills shine btw. but attacking gandhi first might prove an advantage maybe, because he simply is stronger on this map as peter
...
@ gkey:
biggest capital, best research rate, most improvements, also 10 cities... ...not much to say about your save but IMPRESSIVE... ...your playing so far seems close to ideal.
even the ai in your game was a lot more cooperative... ...just look at the placement of Viagra and New York: Viagra has some food in your game (in my game no food and not even access to water via chain irrigation without farming some fps in delhi) and New York... ...alone for founding Boston (New York position in your game) where lincoln did in my game, he must die...
adding wastintime and vranasm:
@ wastintime:
really intersting to see a totally different approach. settling city nr. 2 near double gold + fps was something nobody considered before, but it quite obviously helped A LOT in early research.
settling only 2 cities and going for a HA rush AND getting 6 unis + oxford done around 500 BC... ...i wouldnt have thought that possible to be honest... ...resulting in
12 cities and 400+ beakers around 500 BC (250 from capital). like already mentioned before, i havent thought it possible to improve the play gkey showed up to 500 BC, but well, it apparently is possible...
-> questions that come to my mind and problems i see:
- what is your planned techpath? why gunpowder now?
- you have crippled and/or annoyed basically all ai´s, except of mansa. what´s your plan on keeping up techtrading a bit longer (i undetook a lot of efford to keep 3 ais (mali, england, persia) in the techtading circus, including gifting them techs) - or dont you plan on keeping techtrading and start researching all by yourself?
- do you plan to go for the reli-combo (apo, sankore, spiral)? you havent researched theo, so getting apo in time might be close, i already started it around 700 BC
- you dont plan on getting music first for the free artist?
- your army is really, really small with less then 10 units, mainly ha´s. now with the ai´s having phants and such, how do you plan on keeping conquest running (do you build more units or slow it down - wasnt it very risky to conquer with that few units?). just to compare, i had like 15 cats and 20 phants + some axes to conquer the ais and still felt unsave (i´m not really good at warfare i have to admit, so i usually like bringing more units)
- you missed on the hg wonder. didnt you go for it or was it bad luck?
- 17 workers!!!!! where did you get them from? i had less then 10 at 500 BC (8 or 9). is this another advantage of ha´s?
sorry for all these questions, but i want to understand what you did and where i can do better...
...
@ vranasm:
i used your 225 BC save to compare + the turnlog to trace back:
similar to what gkey did, but a bit less focussed on research (you went music like i did, not education directly), so it is somewhat between gkeys and my game. not having courthouses started will hurt soon, because all these cities will start to drag down income.
india vassaling to persia might turn into a problem and diplo is already hit by it. overall, i dont see it that pessimistic as you do i guess, but some more units and starting on courthouses are needed...