Better late then never or Poland works to heal communist era anti-Semitism.

Oerdin

Deity
Joined
Mar 30, 2002
Messages
2,965
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
In 1968 the Polish Communist Party revoked the citizenship and deported one half of the country's Jewish population in a bout of anti-Semitism. University students had protested in the streets after a dispute over a play and the communist party wanted a scapegoat. Publicly the communists blamed Jews for the unrest and deported 15,000 Jewish people most of whom were holocaust survivors.

Poland to welcome expelled Jews
Poland's president has promised to restore citizenship to thousands of Jews who were expelled from the country by the communists in 1968.

Lech Kaczynski described the decision to kick out about 15,000 Jews - many Holocaust survivors - as "shameful".

The purge followed nationwide student protests that began after a decision to close down a patriotic play.

People of Jewish origin were blamed, stripped of Polish citizenship and ordered out of the country.

Police violently broke up a student demonstration at Warsaw University 40 years ago.

It had been caused by the communist authorities' decision to close down a patriotic play by Poland's national poet, Adam Mickiewicz.

The protests quickly spread across the country before being crushed with considerable violence.

Many of the students and professors were of Jewish origin and the communist party used that fact to purge Jews from public life.

An estimated 15,000 people - half the country's Jewish population - were given a one-way ticket out of the country and stripped of their citizenship.

Loss of talent

Among those attending Saturday's anniversary ceremony was Michal Sobelman, one of those forced out in 1968.

"We left because we couldn't be Poles and we couldn't live here as Jews," Mr Sobelman said.

"The Poland of those times did not want us," he said.

I treat this as my personal contribution to reversing the consequences of those sad, shameful events. Never more
Lech Kaczynski
Polish President

"But with our suitcases we took a little bit of Poland that was with us for 40 years. Today, in some symbolic way, we return it to end this sad chapter," Mr Sobelman said.

Mr Kaczynski said the campaign was an enormous loss for Poland.

"It was a very bad and shameful time," he said.

"The nation lost its reputation for many years and the damage has still not be completely repaired.

"An even greater loss was that thousands of often very talented, ambitious and entrepreneurial people had to leave our country."

The president went on to promise to make up for the communist-era decision by restoring Polish citizenship to those who wanted it.

"I am ready, without any formalities or even requests... to return citizenship to everyone from those times who will want it," Mr Kaczynski said at a ceremony in Warsaw at one of the train stations where thousands had boarded to leave.

"I treat this as my personal contribution to reversing the consequences of those sad, shameful events. Never more.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/7285304.stm
 
Stalinism not Communism.

Lenin had actually been a big opponent of Anti-Semitism.

I still claim its not fair to completly blame the Communists for this... Especially seeing that most Soviet Era 'Communists' were more so fascist then Communist.
 
The Soviets were always anti-Semitic, and since they couldn't plausibly blame the US or West Germany for this incident, the Jews were the sensible scapegoat.

I don't really see what this has to do with the modern world.
 
Stalin's death actually saved many soviet Jews from massive purges he was planning. Stalin's suspicious mind was naturally freaked out about the perceived nationless jewish people.

The soviets indeed carried out many campaigns against the Jews, saying they were fighting the "cosmopolitans" (an euphemism to make them sound different from the Nazis).
 
Stalinism was also allied with religious fundamentalism, or actually, religion allied with Stalinism, like it did with all those empires and totalitarianists throughout history.

Now, it's true that there were many Jewish marxists and leftists in Russia, I think, because they were the most repressed minority in Czarist Russia , and were probably thus attracted to such ideology. The same is probably true for the rest of Europe where antisemitism was rife. And consiquently, these ideologies might have spread strongly in Jewish communities.

Anyway, the return to antisemitist hate-mongering just goes to show how completely Stalin reverted back to Czarism. Also, Stalin's purges targeted the socialists, even leninists, who apparently had to be shot (which seems to indicate a differences of opinions between the stalinists and leninists, and especially between real socialists and stalinists).
 
In 1968 the Polish Communist Party revoked the citizenship and deported one half of the country's Jewish population in a bout of anti-Semitism. University students had protested in the streets after a dispute over a play and the communist party wanted a scapegoat. Publicly the communists blamed Jews for the unrest and deported 15,000 Jewish people most of whom were holocaust survivors.

I grew up in communist Poland and I didn't even know that this happened. Mind you, I wasn't alive in 1968, but still.. Speaks volumes of Commie propaganda and misinformation.

It's a bit annoying when people think that Poland is generally anti-Jewish.. In medieval times we were very tolerant of people of other religious beliefs, at a time when Jews were despised in most of Europe - which is why we ended up with such a huge Jewish population in the first place.

The Nazis, and then the Soviets did most of the damage.. Sure, you'll find Poles here or there who are racist and hate Jews, but we are not, nor have we ever been, an anti-Jewish people.
 
Stalin was not inherently anti-Jewish, he had a Jewish foreign minister for many many years. Stalin hated any group that identified themselves as an ethnicity or nation, rather than part of the Soviet state. and yes, for once al Da Great is right, in the early days of the bolshevieks, Jews were over-represented, but they were "racial" Jews, not religious ones, generally completly Russified and if they were in the Bolsheviek party then they obviously didnt particularly identify themselves as Jews. Jews were over-represented, but its meaningless. To suggest it was a"jewish" movement is ridiculous.

On the OP: it's about time. This was an appalling crime, and should have never happened, never mind taking 40 years to apologise for. Shame on anyone who participated in it.
 
The Nazis, and then the Soviets did most of the damage.. Sure, you'll find Poles here or there who are racist and hate Jews, but we are not, nor have we ever been, an anti-Jewish people.

Hm..... not true, you odnt know Polish history that well if you believe that. Poland didnt stand out as particularly anti-semetic because of other countries being worse, but that dosent absolve them of their crimes (of which surely no country in Europe is not guilty):

In the 1650s the Swedish invasion of the Commonwealth (The Deluge) and the Chmielnicki Uprising of the Cossacks resulted in vast depopulation of the Commonwealth, as over 30% of the ~10 million population has perished or emigrated. In the related 1648-55 pogroms led by the Ukrainian uprising against Polish nobility (szlachta), during which approximately 100,000 Jews were slaughtered, Polish and Ruthenian peasants often participated in killing Jews (The Jews in Poland, Ken Spiro, 2001). The besieged szlachta, who were also decimated in the territories where the uprising happened, typically abandoned the loyal peasantry, townsfolk, and the Jews renting their land, in violation of "rental" contracts.

In the aftermath of the Deluge and Chmielnicki Uprising, many Jews fled to the less turbulent Netherlands, which had granted the Jews a protective charter in 1619. From then until the Nazi deportations in 1942, the Netherlands remained a remarkably tolerant haven for Jews in Europe, exceeding the tolerance extant in all other European countries at the time, and becoming one of the few Jewish havens until nineteenth century social and political reforms throughout much of Europe. Many Jews also fled to England, open to Jews since the mid-seventeenth century, in which Jews were fundamentally ignored and not typically persecuted. Historian Berel Wein notes:

"In a reversal of roles that is common in Jewish history, the victorious Poles now vented their wrath upon the hapless Jews of the area, accusing them of collaborating with the Cossack invader!... The Jews, reeling from almost five years of constant hell, abandoned their Polish communities and institutions..." (Triumph of Survival, 1990).
Throughout the sixteenth to eighteenth century, many of the szlachta mistreated peasantry, townsfolk and Jews. Threat of mob violence was a specter over the Jewish communities in Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth at the time. On one occasion in 1696, a mob threatened to massacre the Jewish community of Posin, Vitebsk. The mob accused the Jews of murdering a Pole. At the last moment, a peasant woman emerged with the victim's clothes and confessed to the murder. One notable example of actualized riots against Polish Jews is the rioting of 1716, during which many Jews lost their lives. Later, in 1723, the Bishop of Gdańsk instigated the massacre of hundreds of Jews.

On the other hand, it should be noted that despite the mentioned incidents, the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth was a relative haven for Jews when compared to the period of the partitions of Poland and the PLC's destruction in 1795 (see Imperial Russia and the Soviet Union, below).

Anti-Jewish sentiments continued to be present in Poland, even after the country regained its independence. One notable manifestation of these attitudes includes numerus clausus rules imposed, by almost all Polish universities in the 1937. William W. Hagen in his Before the "Final Solution": Toward a Comparative Analysis of Political Anti-Semitism in Interwar Germany and Poland article in Journal of Modern History (July, 1996): 1-31, details:

"In Poland, the semidictatorial government of Piłsudski and his successors, pressured by an increasingly vocal opposition on the radical and fascist right, implemented many anti-Semitic policies tending in a similar direction, while still others were on the official and semiofficial agenda when war descended in 1939.... In the 1930s the realm of official and semiofficial discrimination expanded to encompass limits on Jewish export firms... and, increasingly, on university admission itself. In 1921-22 some 25 percent of Polish university students were Jewish, but in 1938-39 their proportion had fallen to 8 percent."
While there are many examples of Polish support and help for the Jews during World War II and the Holocaust, there are also numerous examples of anti-Semitic incidents, and the Jewish population was certain of the indifference towards their fate from the Christian Poles. The Polish Institute for National Memory identified twenty-four pogroms against Jews during World War II, the most notable occurring at the village of Jedwabne in 1941 (see massacre in Jedwabne).

I admit they weren't the worst though. Jews were persecuted by Stalin, but not for racial reasons, the man persecuted almost every nation in the USSR, including the Georgians, of which he himself was one.
 
, the return to antisemitist hate-mongering just goes to show how completely Stalin reverted back to Czarism. Also, Stalin's purges targeted the socialists, even leninists, who apparently had to be shot (which seems to indicate a differences of opinions between the stalinists and leninists, and especially between real socialists and stalinists).
To suggest that the fact that Stalin killed leninists indicates a difference between leninism and stalinism is nonsense, as Stalin also killed many of those who supported him from the begining.
 
Good for the Polish people to heal the scars of the cold war past :).

Stalinism not Communism.

Lenin had actually been a big opponent of Anti-Semitism.

I still claim its not fair to completly blame the Communists for this... Especially seeing that most Soviet Era 'Communists' were more so fascist then Communist.

Was Lenin a proponent of oppressing religion and persecuting the religious?
 
Top Bottom