Cable news or: "... and let's hope the magic negro does a good job"

Personally, I don't think it's wrong for FOX to have broadcasted it.

It's a ridiculous and blatantly racist statement, unless there's some kind of tongue and cheek thing behind it. Though I think any broadcaster should be expected to uphold a certain level of decency, I don't think this one goes beyond the limit, it may be close but not quite there.

In the least, it keeps people mindful of what kind of nutters are still out there.
 
From tvtropes:

In order to show the world that minority characters are not bad people, one will step forward to help a "normal" person, with their pure heart and Closer To Earth wisdom. They are from a minority that is discriminated against, physically or mentally disabled, or social outcasts (drifters, the homeless, ex-cons). They step (often clad in a clean, white suit) into the life of the central character (often white, American and racist) and, in some way, enrich the central character's life.

While this can work as a plea for tolerance, or simply An Aesop about not dismissing people just because they're different, it's all too easy to go too far and make them into an all-knowing Mary Sue or pseudo-narrator whose magical minority-powers save the day. It also tends to raise the question that if the Magical Negro is so powerful and intelligent, why he's never saving the day, himself, instead of helping the mainstream hero to get all the glory. Also, quite often he's just ditched off or even killed after he's fulfilled his purpose for the plot.

If the Magical Negro is from a society of Noble Savages, expect an Anvilicious Aesop about the failings of the society which protagonist comes from - which usually leads to the protagonist 'going native' and ending up better at everything than his Magical Negro mentor.

The reason the Magical Negro is problematic is because it is a moral and artistic shortcut, replacing a genuine moral message with a well-intentioned but patronizing homage to the special gifts of the meek.

Morgan Freeman is the ultimate Magical Negro actor. Referenced on The Daily Show when discussing Barack Obama's need to pick a running mate who won't just turn him into one.

See also Whoopi Epiphany Speech and Black Best Friend. For a similar trope about women, see Manic Pixie Dream Girl.
 
The biggest defender of the Bill of Rights in this thread? A Canadian. :lol:
It's not a matter of the bill of rights, it's about broadcasting standards. Fox could sing Barrack the Magic Negro before every commercial break if they wanted to. Doesn't mean they should.
 
That's a clever euphemism for "censorship."

I'm talking editorial standards, the type of thing to which journalists are supposed to hold themselves. I'm not outraged it was broadcast, nor do I want Fox's right to screw up be infringed upon. I just want news to have some standards.
 
That's a clever euphemism for "censorship."
Are you kidding me man? Lookee here. You remember when Don Imus got in trouble? If you don't remember, it was because he used the words "nappy-headed ho". Then he got suspended by ABC. ABC (which by the way stands for American Broadcasting Company) suspended him not because the government (aka the FCC) did anything, it was because a lot of people (with help from a despicable man named Al Sharpton) were upset by it and ABC didn't want to support this man anymore. Sponsors ditched him because they didn't want their products associated with it. It's not censorship. It's a company applying their own standards. If Fox wanted to they could make their entire network into a 24-hour Nazi News station and there would be no law to stop them. Wouldn't last very long because people would get angry, they'd have no sponsors, and no way to sustain themselves. It's the free market! It's very American, and by no means is it censorship.
 
That's a clever euphemism for "censorship."

No one is saying that they shouldn't be able to say or do questionable things. We're just saying that if they make a habit of it, of course the likelihood of taking them seriously will gradually drop.

About this incident in particular, I've nothing to say but that I can't possibly be surprised.
 
Negro isn't offensive, and magic shouldn't be either.

Jesus christ, why don't you go out and start calling people "negro" and see where it gets you? I imagine a one way trip to the hospital, moron.
 
Jesus christ, why don't you go out and start calling people "negro" and see where it gets you? I imagine a one way trip to the hospital, moron.

Are you daft? We want him to do that!
 
Magic negro comes from a parody song "Obama the Magic Negro" from Puff the Magic Dragon (I've never heard the parody). Personally, I think it is pretty racist, as he could be "Obama the Magic Lefty"... I see no need to take the black angle in parodying Obama. Anyway, the song was played on Rush Limbaugh and then someone in the RNC forwarded a joke christmas card (or something) with a reference to the song.

Poor taste? Certainly. Bringing up race for no reason? I think so. Lame? Oh yea.
 
Magic negro comes from a parody song "Obama the Magic Negro" from Puff the Magic Dragon (I've never heard the parody). Personally, I think it is pretty racist, as he could be "Obama the Magic Lefty"... I see no need to take the black angle in parodying Obama. Anyway, the song was played on Rush Limbaugh and then someone in the RNC forwarded a joke christmas card (or something) with a reference to the song.
That was an actual song? I thought I made it up. Rushie did this? He should've stuck to the Banking Queen. That was at least funny.
 
I dunno who made the song, but the Maha played it and some RNC guy mentioned it or put it on a CD or something in a group mail.

Too bad El Rushbo sucks since he got off the OCs. Like Howard, it has been years since I bothered to listen in for the same old crap.
 
Too bad El Rushbo sucks since he got off the OCs. Like Howard, it has been years since I bothered to listen in for the same old crap.
If you want some new conservative flavors you should check out Curtis Sliwa. Now that guy speaks my language, plus he keeps it just silly enough. He doesn't think he's changing the world the way Savage does. Or Steve Malzberg, though you'd probably have a hard time getting him outside of NY. WOR guy.
 
The comment wasn't Fox's fault. And it wasn't racist either. Poor taste yes but not racism because it was just referencing a song. That song though is another matter. As Efofarm said, it could just have easily been the magic lefty. There was no need to bring race into it.
If you want some new conservative flavors you should check out Curtis Sliwa. Now that guy speaks my language, plus he keeps it just silly enough. He doesn't think he's changing the world the way Savage does. Or Steve Malzberg, though you'd probably have a hard time getting him outside of NY. WOR guy.
My dad likes Hugh Hewitt. I don't think he's a major one
 
See I thought this was a reference to the movie trope, but if there's a specific stupid song then that's probably what was actually being invoked.
 
Top Bottom