Well, Im one of the few that gave it a 10, and I think a 10 is well deserved.
The anxiety I had waiting on this game to come out was immeasurable. After the game installed, and I watched the opening movie in awe, I felt I was in a place I've been to only a few times before. Only a few select classic games can give you that feeling. You guys know what I mean. The old classic games where you try to savor the 1st few days you play because you'll never enjoy that kind of feeling again once the newness and the excitement wear off. Or later on, you reflect on how great the first few times you played were. Its why we continue to play computer games at all. To capture that feeling again. Civ IV did this very thing for me.
Im not a very good Civ player, but I do know one thing about this version. I started with Civ III and I never played long enough to even reach railroads. I just loved to start the game, get so far, then when the competition got heated, I'd make an excuse to start a new game.
So far in Civ IV, I've not only reached railroads, but I can not wait to play this game till its final conclusion. I've had absolutely no inkling of starting a new game. Not till this one is complete.
There is only one kind of "perfect" game, and that is a game that you make yourself. Because this can not be the case, it's very easy to point out one thing or another that you would change, but the game is made for the masses in which you have to sacrifice for the whole. So those little changes we'd want to see in a game will not detract from me the way this game has played out so far.
I love this game to death and with the upcoming modding, patches, expansions, fixes, it can only get better from here.
There can only be one game that will ever be better than Civ IV to me, and that is.........Alpha Centauri II.........
Till then, this one rules all.