This table incorporates the data from the OP as well as data to date. If you find any errors or have any suggestions for improvements, please append them to this thread.
Games 1-72 are indexed in Post #3 (this post).
Games 72-115 are indexed in Post #11.
Games 116-current indexed in Post #13.
[table="head"]TSG|Civ|AI|CS|Map Type|Map Size|Diff|Pace|Game Options|VC|Notes|Ann|GIP|AAR|GIP|Start|Finish|Version
72|Assyria|7|18|Pangaea|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)||Diplomatic|Mongols|
Ann|
OAT|
AAT|
R&C|01-Nov-13|01-Dec-13|BNW 1.0.3.142
71|Venice|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Prince(4)|Standard(2)|NB|Diplomacy|No DLC|
Ann|
OAT|
AAR|
R&C|16-Oct-13|15-Nov-13|BNW 1.0.3.142
70|Poland|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Deity(8)|Standard(2)||Culture|Mongols|
Ann|
OAT|
AAR|
R&C|1-Oct-13|01-Nov-13|BNW 1.0.3.80
69|Portugal|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Warlord(3)|Standard(2)|#69|Science|No DLC|
Ann|
OAT|
AAR|
R&C|15-Sep-13|15-Oct-13|BNW 1.0.3.80
68|Zulu|8|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|NAR|Domination|No DLC|
Ann|
OAT|
AAR|
R&C|01-Sep-13|01-Oct-13|BNW 1.0.3.80
67|Morocco|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|NAR|Diplomacy|No DLC|
Ann|
OAT|
AAR|
R&C|15-Aug-13|15-Sep-13|BNW 1.0.3.18
66|Polynesia|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)||Culture|#66|
Ann|
OAT|
AAR|
R&C|01-Aug-13|01-Sep-13|BNW 1.0.3.18
65|Polynesia|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)||Culture|#65|
Ann|
OAT|
AAR|
R&C|15-Jul-13|15-Aug-13|G&K 1.0.3.18
64|Rome|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Immortal(7)|Standard(2)|RB|Science|No DLC|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|01-Jul-13|01-Aug-13|G&K 1.0.2.44
63|Denmark|7|20|Mystery|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|PolS|Domination|No DLC|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|15-Jun-13|15-Jul-13|G&K 1.0.2.44
62|Byzantium|7|18|Mystery|Standard(4)|Deity(8)|Standard(2)||Any|No DLC|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|01-Jun-13|01-Jul-13|G&K 1.0.2.44
61|Huns|7|18|Mystery|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|NAR, RB|Culture|#61|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|15-May-13|15-Jun-12|G&K 1.0.2.44
60|Carthage|7|20|Mystery|Standard(4)|Immortal(7)|Standard(2)|PS|Domination|No DLC|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|01-May-13|03-Jun-13|G&K 1.0.2.44
59|Netherlands|7|18|Mystery|Standard(4)|Prince(4)|Standard(2)||Diplomatic|No DLC|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|15-Apr-13|15-May-13|G&K 1.0.2.44
58|Austria|7|20|Mystery|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS, PolS, NAR|Culture|No DLC|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|01-Apr-13|01-May-13|G&K 1.0.2.44
57|Inca|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|None|Science|#57|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|15-Mar-13|15-Apr-13|G&K 1.0.2.44
56|Ethiopia|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Immortal(7)|Standard(2)|PS|Diplomatic|No DLC|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|01-Mar-13|01-Apr-13|G&K 1.0.2.21
55|Spain|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Warlord(3)|Standard(2)|None|Domination|No DLC|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|15-Feb-13|15-Mar-13|G&K 1.0.2.21
54|Maya|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS|Science|No DLC|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|01-Feb-13|03-Mar-13|G&K 1.0.2.21
53|Celts|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Prince(4)|Standard(2)|None|Cultural|No DLC|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|12-Jan-13|15-Feb-13|G&K 1.0.2.21
52|Sweden|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Immortal(7)|Standard(2)|PS|Domination|No DLC|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|01-Jan-13|03-Feb-13|G&K 1.0.2.21
51|Babylon|5|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Deity(8)|Standard(2)|PS|Any|#51|
Ann|
OAR|
AAR|
R&C|23-Dec-12|21-Jan-13|G&K 1.0.2.21
50|Austrian|7|18|Mystery|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|none|Diplomatic|No DLC|
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Dec-12|15-Jan-13|G&K 1.0.2.21
49|Sweden|5|20|Mystery|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS|Culture|No DLC|
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Dec-12|01-Jan-13|G&K 1.0.2.21
48|Ethiopia|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Prince(4)|Standard(2)|none|Science|No DLC|
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Nov-12|15-Dec-12|G&K 1.0.2.13
47|Spanish|6|12|Mystery|Small(3)|Immortal(7)|Standard(2)|PS|Diplomatic|No DLC|
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Nov-12|02-Dec-12|G&K 1.0.1.705
46|Carthage|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|none|Domination|No DLC|
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|18-Oct-12|15-Nov-12|G&K 1.0.1.705
45|Dutch|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS|Science|No DLC|
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Oct-12|01-Nov-12|G&K 1.0.1.705
44|Korea|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Warlord(3)|Standard(2)|OCC, RB|Cultural|#44|
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Sep-12|15-Oct-12|G&K 1.0.1.705
43|Hunnic|10|10|Mystery|Standard(4)|Immortal(7)|Standard(2)|PS|Domination|No DLC|
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Sep-12|01-Oct-12|G&K 1.0.1.705
42|Maya|6|14|Mystery|Small(3)|Prince(4)|Standard(2)|PS, CK, RB|Diplomatic|No DLC|
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Aug-12|16-Sep-12|G&K 1.0.1.705
41|Byzantium|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS|Cultural|No DLC|
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Aug-12|02-Sep-12|G&K 1.0.1.705
40|Celts|9|16|Arborea Mystery|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|PS|Science|No DLC|
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Jul-12|15-Aug-12|G&K 1.0.1.705
39|Egypt|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS|Diplomatic||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Jul-12|01-Aug-12|1.0.1.674
38|Japan|8|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|none|Domination||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|18-Jun-12|15-Jul-12|1.0.1.674
37|China|8|20|Mystery|Standard(4)|Immortal(7)|Standard(2)|PS, NCR|Science||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Jun-12|01-Jul-12|1.0.1.511
36|Russia|7|20|Mystery|Standard(4)|Warlord(3)|Standard(2)|PS|Diplomatic||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-May-12|15-Jun-12|1.0.1.511
35|Songhai|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|OCC, PS|Domination||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-May-12|01-Jun-12|1.0.1.511
34|Iroquois|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|Prince(4)|Standard(2)|RB, PS|Science||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Apr-12|15-May-12|1.0.1.511
33|Romans|5|12|Mystery|Small(3)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS|Cultural||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Apr-12|01-May-12|1.0.1.511
32|Ottoman|7|16|mt|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|RP, PS|Diplomatic||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Mar-12|15-Apr-12|1.0.1.511
31|German|7|16|mt|Standard(4)|Immortal(7)|Standard(2)|RB, PS|Domination||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Mar-12|01-Apr-12|1.0.1.511
30|Greek|7|20|Mystery|Standard(4)|Warlord(3)|Standard(2)|PS|Cultural||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Feb-12|15-Mar-12|1.0.1.511
29|Persia|7|20|Mystery|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|NCR, PS|Science||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Feb-12|01-Mar-12|1.0.1.511
28|Mongols|7|16|Mystery|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|PS|Domination||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Jan-12|15-Feb-12|1.0.1.511
27|French|7|24|Mystery|Standard(4)|Deity|Standard(2)|none|Cultural||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Jan-12|01-Feb-12|1.0.1.511
26|America|5|16|Mystery|Small(3)|Prince(4)|Quick(1)|RP, PS|Diplomatic||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Dec-11|15-Jan-12|1.0.1.383
25|England|12|25|Archipelago|Large(5)|Immortal(7)|Epic(3)|CK, RB, NCR, PS|Domination||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Dec-11|01-Jan-12|1.0.1.383
24|India|8|20|Random|Standard(4)|Warlord(3)|Standard(2)|OCC, RB, RP, PS|Science||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Nov-11|15-Dec-11|1.0.1.383
23|Siam|10|16|Random|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS|Diplomatic||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Nov-11|01-Dec-11|1.0.1.383
22|Aztecs|7|16|Lakes - Random Size|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|PS, NAR, RP|Cultural||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Oct-11|15-Nov-11|1.0.1.383
21|Egypt|7|16|Random|Standard(4)|Immortal(7)|Standard(2)|PS|Domination||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Oct-11|01-Nov-11|1.0.1.383
20|Arabia|7|16|Random|Standard(4)|Prince(4)|Standard(2)|PS, NCR, RN|Science||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Sep-11|15-Oct-11|1.0.1.383
19|German|7|16|Random|Standard(4)|Deity|Standard(2)|PS|Cultural||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|03-Sep-11|01-Oct-11|1.0.1.383
18|Ottoman|7|16|Random|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|PS|Diplomatic||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|15-Aug-11|15-Sep-11|1.0.1.383
17|Mongols|7|16|Random|Standard(4)|Immortal(7)|Standard(2)|PS|Domination||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Aug-11|01-Sep-11|?
16|Persia|7|16|Fractal|Standard(4)|Prince(4)|Standard(2)|PS|Cultural||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|18-Jul-11|15-Aug-11|?
15|America|7|16|Fractal|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS|Science||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|02-Jul-11|18-Jul-11|?
14|Japan|7|18|Fractal|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|OCC, PS|Domination||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|16-Jun-11|27-Jun-11|?
13|Siam|7|16|Fractal|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS|Science||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|30-May-11|13-Jun-11|?
12|England|7|16|Fractal|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS|Diplomatic||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|16-May-11|30-May-11|?
11|Arabia|7|16|Fractal|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS|Cultural||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|02-May-11|16-Jun-11|?
10|China|7|16|Fractal|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS, RB|Domination||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|05-Apr-11|18-Apr-11|?
9|India|7|16|Fractal|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS, PolS, NCR|Diplomatic||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|22-Mar-11|04-Apr-11|?
8|Greek|7|16|Fractal|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS|Science||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|07-Mar-11|21-Mar-11|?
7|Songhai|7|16|Oval|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS|Any||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|01-Feb-11|15-Feb-11|?
6|Russia|7|16|Archipelago|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|none|Any||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|17-Jan-11|31-Jan-11|?
5|Aztecs|7|16|Lakes|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Standard(2)|PS, PolS|Cultural|Wet|
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|21-Dec-10|10-Jan-11|1.0.1.135
4|Iroquois|7|16|Fractal|Standard(4)|Emperor(6)|Epic(3)|none|Diplomatic||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|22-Nov-10|06-Dec-10|?
3|French|7|16|West vs. East|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|none|Cultural||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|25-Oct-10|09-Nov-10|?
2|Egypt|7|16|Continents|Standard(4)|King(5)|Standard(2)|none|Science||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|06-Oct-10|20-Oct-10|?
1|Romans|||Pangea|Small(3)|Warlord(3)|Standard(2)|none|Domination||
Ann|
GIP|
AAR|
R&C|23-Sep-10|07-Oct-10|?[/table]
Game Option Abbreviations
PS=Promotion Saving, CK=Complete Kills, RB=Raging Barbs, NCR=No City Razing, OCC=One City Challenge
RP=Random Personalities, NAR=No Ancient Ruins, PolS=Policy Saving, NB=No Barbarians
Notes
44: DLC Required: Korea, Ancient Wonders of the World, Babylon, Mongols, Spain/Inca, Polynesia and Denmark
51: DLC Required: Nebuchadnezzar's Babylon, Genghis Khan's Mongolia, Gods and Kings expansion Pack and Upgrade Data 1
57: DLC Required: Spain and Inca DLC pack
61: DLC Required: Wonders of the Ancient World
65: DLC Required: Polynesia and Korea/Ancient Wonders of the World DLC
66: DLC Required: Polynesia, Mongols, Brave New World and Gods and Kings
69: All victory condition except Diplomacy are enabled; No Ancient Ruins
72: This game was created in Civ5 Brave New World version 1.0.3.142, but was reloaded into version 1.0.3.144
83:Renaissance Era start
Comments through post #10 have been incorporated.
Sorry for the delay in updating; the evil
Guildwars 2 is still taking quite a bit of my game time.