Traitorfish
The Tighnahulish Kid
No, we've established that you don't like reparations. We've yet to establish that they are immoral. We haven't even clearly established that they involve taking from "the innocent"; most of us are assuming that they'd be paid out of general taxation, while you seem to be imaging that, that, I don't know, Antifa Supersoldiers break into the homes of every white people and strip out the copper wire.This is not a competition between victims, just whether or not reparations are moral. If I oppose them in one case I wont support them in another because my ancestors are involved. Start a thread about it if you like, but we've been told not to talk about it here.
I mean, if you're really dead-set against taxing "the living", we can apply a retroactive inheritance tax on deceased slaver-owners. Work out what they would have paid, and recoup it with appropriate interest from their descendent, and apply this to a program of reparations. Now, to me, that does't seem fair, because it will probably catch a lot of working class people in the net, possibly even working class black people! But if you insist on the impossibility of inherited responsibility for the misdeeds of the dead, you must also acknowledge the impossibility of legitimately inherited profit from the deeds of the dead.
Last edited: