Well Chand, I won't quote your post (because it's rather long), but I have to agree with most of it. btw, I've been paying particular attention to your game as of late, and I was just waiting for the new thread...
About Symph (since you named him) : He is special in many ways. First of all, of what I've seen of him, I hold him in high esteem for his dedication and imagination. Clearly this guy must be an hell of an amazing GM in a table top RPG. BUT, since he is so clearly above all of us, many of his posts make me cringe. A little bit of humility would go a long way to make him a perfect player.
So Symph, if you're reading this : Join a NotW and show us what you can do.
And also for the record, When I talked about NotW XXV : Armageddon in the NotW info thread, what I had in mind was a crossover NES-FG game. But first I need a NES rep, and this is where you (Chand) come into play... So, when is PreChaNES going to evolve in ChaNES ?
And to get back on topic : 40 players is unrealistic if we only recruit here, so it's not a question of 'must we advertise ?', it's 'where do we advertise ?' : And the NES forum is the perfect place.