Discussion in 'Mafia/NOTW' started by Montmorency, Nov 15, 2019.
who is megs
"So far I like Syn the least"
ah childhood, good memories
One might think sharing information in the game thread will profit the mafiosi, but I think 9 informed people are worth more than 3 so here I go:
It reads as follow:
column player casted a vote on line player (not sure this is meaningfull in any sort of language, but I have faith in you)
votes are numbered in the order they were casted each day (each new vote was preceded by an unvote ofc)
green votes are support
yellow votes are the final ones
lynched player is shown in red if scum, and green if townie
grey columns/lines match lynched/killed players (displayed from D2 update)
Re-reading the thread, I got mafia reads on pzelda, Seon, Synsensa, and Omega... I will go on more details about this later on today (before the end of the ingame night)... and more hopefully.
RL interfering for a couple of hours...
edit: the excel comment on Tak is about him voting choxorn (who isn't playing if you hadn't noticed)
Ah yeah, love me some spreadsheets!
I forgot Mary!
You've got a mafia read on Omega yet you think the Yako wagon is pure?
5 mafia members, that's excessive
"Re-reading the thread"... I was wrong taking Yako's train, but at times it felt like a valid target. A tidy bit better than Omega at least.
You pretend to know who the mafiosi are?
Obviously they are more challengers than elected ones.
Now on to my review:
Tim: regularly thinking out loud (sharing is good imo). No standard deviation from his townie play (well that's my second game with him so you might want to nuance that a bit)
Tak: nonsense, pressure (he dared to try on me!). I note that his last votes match what I feel about the game. I like it for now
Manasi: Late and opportunistic... she must been watched out imo.
JohannaK: sensitive. kind of opportunistically following Snerk though. but still looking good
Snerk: I value his reads. Nothing weird posted so far (well excepting the licking fingers gate)
Visor: pressuring a lot. The mayor for now.
Seon: very low activity with no strong arguments ("might as well go unnoticed"), one unjustified vote on Omega that might be seen as distancing
I find it weird to praise Tak for his constant effort at pressuring, and not trying to do something of the sort... Tak wasn't under pressure anymore to deserve a support vote either. I dunno, maybe it's nothing, but maybe it's also a way to stay off the radars, while not helping the town (no lynch vote in the end).
Omega: well also low activity untill this morning... and yet another support vote (in all objectivity, this one has a better timing). But I am tempted to believe the IRL drama arguments (lying about it would be evil)
Synsensa: high activity! but very few pressuring or justifications for his moves. I appreciate fluff but still. Oh and his first vote was for Seon who I have doubts about, so it could also be distancing.
Mary: Playing the same cards than last game. Mirroring Snerk's votes. Not buying it for now...
I voted for Seon as a placeholder, but also because they were the only name I didn't know as they hadn't participated yet.
Tu vois plusieurs Seon? (Are you seeing multiple Seon?)
Dunno their gender so they get the singular "they" treatment.
Snerk? I'm a bit puzzled. We voted in completely different ways.
It's not as if we had a post by the GM that said there's three mafiosi.
Thanks. It's meant to be both.
Could you offer us an interpretation of those spreadsheets?
I think Mary needs to step up or go. She got a pass last game and bamboozled enough of us to get away with it. She has nothing to hide behind now.
Actually you are right. I got this impression with posts #200 and #201...
That's how I undestand post #119 (link on OP) but who knows (Montmo I guess)
Umm, there's nothing I haven't touched upon yet. Still love the spreadsheet though.
Snerk has a finger in every pie. He's finger-lickin' good. I know it.
Separate names with a comma.