1. We have added the ability to collapse/expand forum categories and widgets on forum home.
    Dismiss Notice
  2. All Civ avatars are brought back and available for selection in the Avatar Gallery! There are 945 avatars total.
    Dismiss Notice
  3. To make the site more secure, we have installed SSL certificates and enabled HTTPS for both the main site and forums.
    Dismiss Notice
  4. Civ6 is released! Order now! (Amazon US | Amazon UK | Amazon CA | Amazon DE | Amazon FR)
    Dismiss Notice
  5. Dismiss Notice
  6. Forum account upgrades are available for ad-free browsing.
    Dismiss Notice

Give the Film Studio to all Civs: A proposed overhaul to America

Discussion in 'Civ - Ideas & Suggestions' started by TheSpaceCowboy, Sep 12, 2017.

  1. TheSpaceCowboy

    TheSpaceCowboy "Save a horse..."

    Joined:
    Jul 14, 2013
    Messages:
    163
    Gender:
    Male
    I’d like to propose a complete overhaul of the American civilization, including an additional leader.

    Firstly, America’s unique building, the Film Studio, would be available for all civilizations. It’d be unlocked at Radio, and like the Art Museum and Archeological Museum, it’d be an alternative build to the Broadcast Center. It’d no longer have the 100% tourism bonus, nor produce any Great Artist or Musician points. Instead, it’d be the only building to produce Great Director points, and would house up to three Great Works of Cinema.

    America’s new unique district would be the Suburb, a replacement of the Neighborhood. It’d cost only half the production of a Neighborhood, but would have a maximum housing of only five. Each Suburb would include a Main Street, the content of which would change depending on the adjacent tiles. On a Suburb’s Main Street, you might see a:

    • Bar (if adjacent to a Vineyard): +1 Amenity
    • Church (if adjacent to a Worship Building): +1 Faith
    • Coffee Shop (if adjacent to a Coffee Plantation): +1 Production
    • Elementary School (if adjacent to a University): +1 Science
    • Gas Station (if next to an Oil Well): +1 movement to friendly units
    • Grocer (if adjacent to a Farm or plantation): +1 Food
    • Jeweler (if adjacent to a Jewel or Silver Mine): +1 Gold
    • Movie Theater (if adjacent to a Film Studio): +1 Culture

    Replacing Founding Fathers as America’s unique ability is E Pluribus Unum. America does not found cities but States. When founding a State, any of the 50 States may be selected, each with a unique benefit based on the maps geography, as follows:

    • Alabama: The Land of Cotton (+1 Culture from Cotton, +1 Gold w/Plantation)
    • Alaska: (x2 Silver from Mines or Oil from Wells built over either Snow or Tundra)
    • Arizona: (+1 Appeal to Desert tiles)
    • Arkansas: Diamond Mine (+1 Gold for Gems)
    • California: Napa Valley (+1 Culture from Wine)
    • Colorado: Mile High (+1 Appeal adjacent to Mountains)
    • Connecticut: Whalers (Whales provide +1 Oil after Square Rigging)
    • Delaware: Tax Haven (x2 Gold from Commercial Hub adjacency)
    • Florida: Florida Oranges (+1 Food from Citrus)
    • Georgia: Sweat Tea (+1 Culture from Tea, +1 Gold w/Plantation)
    • Hawaii: Vacation Destination (x2 Tourism from Seaside Resorts)
    • Idaho: (+1 Food from Potatoes (new resource))
    • Illinois: Navy Pier (allows construction of a Royal Navy Dockyard on Lake tiles)
    • Indiana: Land of the Indians (+1 Culture on any tile formerly occupied by a Barbarian village)
    • Iowa: Caucus (+1 Amenity from triangular farms)
    • Kansas: America’s Breadbasket (+1 Food from Wheat)
    • Kentucky: Derby (+1 Amenities from Horse Pastures)
    • Louisiana: Bayou (+1 Culture from Marshes)
    • Maine: +1 Food from Lobsters (new resource)
    • Maryland: Chesapeake Bay (+1 Food from Crabs)
    • Massachusetts: Boston Clam Chowder (+1 Food from Pearls)
    • Michigan: Motor City (+1 Production from Aluminum)
    • Minnesota: 10,000 Lakes (+1 Appeal adjacent to Lake tiles)
    • Mississippi: Cash Crop (+1 Culture from Sugar, +1 Gold w/Plantation)
    • Missouri: Gateway to the West (+100% Production towards Settlers, who gain additional movement points)
    • Montana: Yellowstone (x2 Tourism from National Parks)
    • Nebraska: Cornhuskers (+1 Amenity to Farms adjacent to a University)
    • Nevada: Viva Las Vegas (Entertainment Complex receives +1 Amenity per adjacent Desert tile)
    • New Hampshire: Old Man of the Mountain (+1 Tourism from Natural Wonders and adjacent tiles)
    • New Jersey: Jersey Shore (Can construct Seaside Resorts on any Coastal tile)
    • New Mexico: Los Alamos (Desert tiles reduce the Production cost of the Manhattan Project)
    • New York: Greatest City in the World (+50% Production towards Broadway and the Statue of Liberty, no Governor needed for Washington Square Park)
    • North Carolina: Blackbeard’s Treasure (x2 Tourism from Artifacts recovered from shipwrecks)
    • North Dakota: Fracking (+1 Gold from Oil over plains)
    • Ohio: Rock & Roll Hall of Fame (x2 Tourism from Great Works of Music)
    • Oklahoma: (x2 Oil from Oil Wells)
    • Oregon: (+1 production to Lumber Mills)
    • Pennsylvania: Pittsburgh Steel (+Production from Iron)
    • Rhode Island: Colossus of Rhodes (+50% Production towards the Colossus)
    • South Carolina: Indigo Plantation (+1 Gold from Dyes)
    • South Dakota: Rush Mount Rushmore (+50% Production towards Mount Rushmore (new Wonder))
    • Tennessee: Athens of the South (x2 Great Musician Points)
    • Texas: Everything’s Bigger (Extra territory upon founding, can expand further than normal)
    • Virginia: Old Dominion (+1 Culture from Tobacco, +1 Gold w/Plantation)
    • Vermont: Green Mountains (+1 Appeal next to hills with forests)
    • Washington: Seattle’s Best (+1 Food from Coffee)
    • Wisconsin: Dairyland (+1 Food from Cattle)
    • West Virginia: “Take me home, country roads” (+1 Production from Coal)
    • Wyoming: (+1 Food from Buffalo (new resource))


    Feel free to offer suggestions for Arkansas, Connecticut, Delaware, Nebraska, New Hampshire, Ohio, Oregon, South Dakota, and Utah.

    While I’d keep Teddy as is, I’d also add



    Gen. Dwight D. Eisenhower
    Leader Ability: Supreme Commander of the Allied Forces

    • America immediately has access to the Liberation Casus Belli
    • Wars of Liberation generate no Weariness or Warmongering
    • When declaring a War of Liberation, America will automatically levy all of its suzerains’ units for free for up to 20 turns - this is forfeited if America starts any other conflicts

    Leader Agenda: Containment
    Ike likes Civilizations with whom he shares a government and will push strongly for an alliance. Ike and loathes civilizations with a different government that try to expand. Ike will always try to liberate captured City-States.
     
    Last edited: Dec 6, 2017
  2. stinkubus

    stinkubus Chieftain

    Joined:
    Aug 21, 2016
    Messages:
    1,037
    Arkansas is the home to the only working diamond mine in the Americas so they could buff gems.

    Delaware is home to many credit card companies due to their lax usury laws, so they could get some sort of buff to banks or maybe commerce hubs in general.

    There's no corn resource so add one and give it a buff with Nebraska. You forgot Iowa so maybe they can also get some sort of Agriculture related buff like double adjacency for farm triangles or maybe only requiring two adjacent farms if that's too much.

    Connecticut was home to the Hartford Whalers (former NHL team) so they could buff whales.

    Oregon has tons of forests so maybe a buff to chops?

    Mt. Rushmore is located in South Dakota, so they should get that buff. Oil is North Dakota's biggest industry, so they could get a buff to that instead.

    New Hampshire is home to a giant granite cliff which looks like a man's face, so maybe they should get some sort of bonus for having a natural wonder in the borders?

    Given how miserable Ohio's professional sports teams are (the Cavs title two years ago not withstanding) I propose that the arena building in the entertainment complex give -1 amenity :). Being serious they are the birth place of the tire industry. Ohio grants vulcanized rubber a unique resource which grants extra production to any industrial zone which has a factory. Their proximity to the Great Lakes could also make +1 amenity for every lake tile adjacent to the city center an interesting option.
     
  3. TheSpaceCowboy

    TheSpaceCowboy "Save a horse..."

    Joined:
    Jul 14, 2013
    Messages:
    163
    Gender:
    Male
  4. UncivilizedGuy

    UncivilizedGuy Civ is brain candy.

    Joined:
    May 24, 2012
    Messages:
    713
    Location:
    Southern California
    I like your ideas. The only problem is that it's not possible to attach a bonus to a specific city which in your mod would be a state. The bonuses can only come from buildings, improvements, policies, techs/Civics, districts. You would need a creative work-around.
     
  5. clapyourhands

    clapyourhands Chieftain

    Joined:
    Jul 16, 2017
    Messages:
    312
    Gender:
    Male
    I remembered this idea after Chrisy15's reworked Iroquois for V--it was a similar idea, where there were five tribes with unique bonuses instead of 50 states. The bonuses were tied to a reworked longhouse, but I'm sure they could just as easily be attached to a dummy building to provide bonuses to resources/terrain/improvements. I think this mod feasibly could be put together for V, so I simplified the state bonuses with that in mind--but I also included a few Civ VI-specific bonuses as well in the event something similar ends up being possible in the future.

    One of the main things I liked the most about Chrisy's reworked Iroquois was that the randomness was attached to the longhouse so that you were guaranteed some sort of bonus as long as you settled near forest--with truly random bonuses, you could end up with something like a bonus to crabs for a landlocked city. I tied state bonuses directly to improvements or terrain to alleviate this, as there is a way to check what's nearby when you settle a city, and thus select a state from a smaller set that would benefit rather than a truly random set. Essentially, if you settle a city by the coast, it'll be a state that has some sort of coastal benefit; a city near forest should have a related benefit, and so on. Features/terrain would have a priority list to prevent conflict; if you settle next to both coast and river, for instance, coast would take precedence and you would get a coastal state... unless you've already settled all the coastal states, then you'd get a river state. A rough priority list would be as follows:

    Tundra > Natural Wonder > Coast > Lakes > Marsh/Floodplain > Mountain > Desert > Camp > Pasture > Plantation > Forest/Jungle > River > Quarries > Hills > Grasslands/Farms > Plains > Neutral

    So if you settle next to a tundra tile and a river, you're guaranteed Alaska (the only tundra state). Settle again in tundra bordering river, and you'll get a river state. Exhaust the river states and you get a neutral state, and if you get through those, then a truly random state. This way you can bias the states you found one way or another while still being somewhat random. With that in mind, here's how I loosely laid out the state lists. As with the original idea, the bonuses only apply within the city's borders.

    Capital (always the first city):
    Washington D.C.: +1 Governor Title upon completing a district

    Tundra:
    Alaska
    : +1 Production from tundra tiles

    Natural Wonders:
    Arizona
    :
    +1 Culture from tiles adjacent to Natural Wonders

    Coast:
    Massachusetts:
    +1 Science from Fishing Boats
    Maryland: +1 Food from Fishing Boats
    Rhode Island: +1 Production from Fishing Boats
    Maine: +1 Gold from Fishing Boats
    Connecticut: +1 Culture from Fishing Boats
    Hawaii: +1 Appeal to all tiles

    Lakes:
    Minnesota:
    +2 Culture from lake tiles
    Michigan: +2 Production from lake tiles
    New Jersey: +2 Gold from lake tiles

    Marsh/Floodplains:
    Florida:
    +1 Science and +1 Gold from marsh and floodplain tiles
    Louisiana: +1 Food and +1 Culture from marsh and floodplain tiles

    Mountains:
    Montana:
    +2 Culture from mountain tiles

    Desert:
    New Mexico:
    +1 Culture from desert tiles
    Utah: +1 Faith from desert tiles

    Camps (furs and bison):
    Oregon: +1 Gold from Camps
    Wyoming: +1 Food from Camps
    Iowa: +1 Production from Camps

    Pastures (dairy and livestock):
    Texas: +1 Science from Pastures
    Vermont: +1 Food from Pastures
    Tennessee: +1 Production from Pastures
    Wisconsin: +1 Gold from Pastures
    Kentucky: +1 Culture from Pastures

    Plantations:
    Pennsylvania:
    +1 Science from Plantations
    Alabama: +1 Food from Plantations
    Georgia: +1 Production from Plantations
    South Carolina: +1 Gold from Plantations
    Virginia: +1 Culture from Plantations

    Forest (lumber mills):
    North Carolina: +1 Production from Lumber Mills
    New Hampshire: +1 Gold from Lumber Mills
    Washington: +1 Culture from Lumber Mills

    Rivers:
    Mississippi:
    +1 Food from tiles adjacent to rivers
    Missouri: +1 Production from tiles adjacent to rivers
    Colorado: +1 Culture from tiles adjacent to rivers

    Quarries:
    West Virginia:
    +1 Production from Quarries
    North Dakota: +1 Gold from Quarries

    Hills/Mines:
    California:
    +1 Science from Mines
    Nevada: +1 Culture from Mines
    Arkansas: +1 Production from Mines

    Farms:
    Ohio:
    +1 Science from Farms
    South Dakota: +1 Food from Farms
    Idaho: +1 Production from Farms
    Indiana: +1 Gold from Farms
    Oklahoma: +1 Culture from Farms

    Grasslands:
    Nebraska:
    +1 Food from grassland tiles
    Illinois: +1 Production from grassland tiles

    Plains:
    Kansas:
    +1 Food from plains tiles

    Neutral:
    New York:
    +1 Housing from districts
    Delaware: +1 Envoy upon completing a district

    I played it a bit loose with state bonuses--the resource first, then the bonus. ie: Californian mines obviously aren't very science-y, but California's history is intertwined with mining, and it is home to some of the top universities in the world; hence, mines + science. Similarly, Nevada has mines to represent its 'silver rush' and culture to represent tourism. Most of the science-yielding states are the ones with big universities in general; culture-yielding ones are ones that are big on tourism (ie: Colorado, Nevada) or derive identity from the resource (ie: Minnesota and lakes, Connecticut and maritime industries). They're all relative to one another in the same group in terms of yields.

    I think a system like this would be an improvement over a truly random one, since 1) you have assurance the boost will be somewhat useful, 2) you have some control as to what state you'll get, but not total, and 3) it's intuitive--found a city near a resource, get a state whose history/economy is tied to that resource.

    Theoretical situations to help explain how the system would work:
    Spoiler :

    You found Washington D.C. You settle a second city surrounded by six plain tiles--the only plain state is Kansas, so this is automatically your next state. Your third city is surrounded by 3 plains tiles, a mountain, and a river bordering a forest. The mountain takes highest precedence, and your third city is Montana. You found your fourth city next to the coast, surrounded by 2 grassland land tiles. The coast takes precedence, so you end up with one of the six coast states; by luck, you get Connecticut. Your fifth city is also surrounded by six plains tiles; since there are no more plains states, and you have no other tiles surrounding you but plains, you get a neutral state--New York. Your sixth and final city is situated next to a river, a mountain, a lake, and three grassland tiles. The mountain takes precedence, but there are no mountain states left. The next-highest priority is the lake, so you'll get one of the lake states; it ends up being Michigan.
     
    TheSpaceCowboy likes this.
  6. TheSpaceCowboy

    TheSpaceCowboy "Save a horse..."

    Joined:
    Jul 14, 2013
    Messages:
    163
    Gender:
    Male
    As a New Jersey native, I've got to ask: why would it be associated with Lakes? Its most notable lake is Sunfish pond, which a strong swimmer can easily swim from on side to the other. I'd think it;d either be a Coastal state (the Jersey Shore) or a Farms state (the Garden State).

    And while the Colorado River is notable, Colorado would definitely have to be a Mountain state.

    Would multiple features on a tile factor into your algorithm? Vermont, being the Green Mountain state, ought to be triggered by a hill with woods on it.

    Also, some of these are improvements, not features. How would a Quarry state be triggered without a quarry already built? Maybe West Virginia is triggered if there's a Coal resource instead? Kansas triggered by a Wheat resource, Florida by Oranges, Wisconsin by Cattle, etc.

    I'd probably push Natural Wonders to the front of your algorithm; Crater Lake would always trigger Oregon and Yosemite would always trigger California.
     
  7. clapyourhands

    clapyourhands Chieftain

    Joined:
    Jul 16, 2017
    Messages:
    312
    Gender:
    Male
    I probably should have been more clear about the improvement ones. Resources that would build those improvements would trigger the state, so stone would count as a "quarry" tile, sugar as a "plantation" tile, etc. The "Farm" states refer to wheat and rice resources, whereas the "plains" and "grasslands" categories are true flat land with no bonuses/luxuries. Multiple features on a tile would still follow the same path, so forest takes precedence over hill in that case. I purposely didn't make any double-requirement states or specific-natural wonder states so that you could feasibly found any state regardless of the game you're playing. It'd be more accurate for Crater Lake to be tied to Oregon, or specific luxuries like tobacco for the "plantation" states, but you don't always get those things on the map.

    As for the weird placement there are some states that I had trouble fitting--namely, New Jersey, Iowa, and Illinois. New Jersey's definitely a coastal state, but there weren't any bonuses left to tie to those; tourism or housing to seaside resorts could work out better. As for Colorado I agree it could go either way, neither category is exactly filled to the brim. I wanted both Montana and Colorado to get Culture from their terrain since it's important for them both, so I made Montana get culture from mountains and Colorado get culture from rivers; it also worked out so that all the major US rivers got relevant bonuses. Mountain Colorado would get +2 Gold per mountain since tourism is a big industry, but for most other ones tourism=culture bonus. There's room for change there so I'm not worried about that one, it'd be an easy flip.
     
  8. Phrozen

    Phrozen Chieftain

    Joined:
    May 7, 2012
    Messages:
    722
    Colorado could get +1 tourism for each mountain tile in the city range. Colorado is home to many ski resorts.
     
  9. Zaarin

    Zaarin My Dearest Doctor

    Joined:
    May 14, 2016
    Messages:
    4,163
    Location:
    Terok Nor
    I like the concept, though I doubt we'd ever see anything that complicated. A few thoughts as an avid coffee drinker: Americans consume a lot of coffee, but we only grow it in Hawai'i. As famous as Oregon and Washington are for coffee roasters (my favorite coffee, Stumptown, comes from Portland), I think a better bonus for Washington would be something to the effect of:
    • Cascadia: +1 :c5culture: for tiles adjacent to mountains.
     
  10. Depravo

    Depravo Siring Bastards

    Joined:
    Sep 28, 2005
    Messages:
    1,089
    Location:
    England
    New Hampshire: Live Free Or Die, +2 points towards CS envoys, no warmonger from annexing city states who DoWed you with their suzerain.
     
  11. Alexander's Hetaroi

    Alexander's Hetaroi Warlord

    Joined:
    Oct 17, 2017
    Messages:
    1,518
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    Texas
    The new water park /amusement pier could work although it's probably not an improvement but a district. But that could definitely work with the original Jersey Shore ability and leave the seaside resorts to Hawaii.
     

Share This Page

Ebates: Get Paid to Shop