And especially in Russia there was the problem with POWs and not enough to feed them(i don't mean the large-scale planned starving, but individual units).
Tough Titties. The Kwangtung Army had to deal with the same problems with the Yangtze valley, yet I've never seen anyone rush to their defense.
Up to 10:1 for each soldier killed by partisans was accepted by all belligerent parties and thus no war crime, too.
Absolute Rubbish. The Allies took no such policy in dealing with Werewolf or Fascist Partisans. In fact, This policy wasn't even accepted throughout the Axis. Mussolini wrote extensively to Hitler demanding a cessation of this Policy.
I didn't say the Wehrmacht was out of war crimes. She did also some. But in contrast with the SS or NKVD or Red Army units this was much less.
Then why are the civilian:military casualties so skewed in Russia as compared to Germany? Why was the German Army the FIRST to recieve orders from Hitler for the extermination of the Jews?
Also why Hitler did never really trust the Wehrmacht, if she was such a strong base for him?
By this logic, The Communist Party, Red Army, and NKVD were never a source of support for Stalin, the Falange was never a source of support for Franco, and the Zaibatsu were never a source of support for the Japanese Militarists.
There are, in fact, documented cases of American units slaughtering German POWs and shooting soliders attempting to surrender. Look it up.
False comparison, the U.S. never gave out orders that they not only were allowed to, but expected to do so. We see that in the Wehrmacht.
Nevertheless the partisans were not protected. They did not wear a symbol recognizable on long distances, bear no arms openly and it is doubtful they were in some kind lead by responsible officers in the sense of the Hague Land War Order. Thus they were criminals in the eyes of the law. And as it was martial law the shooting or hanging was justified. Even if it was nazi martial law.
Actually in the East and Southeast, the vast majority of Partisans were enlisted in the armies, merely operating behind the lines. They Held recognized military ranks within an established army structure. However, applying this policy to the Germans, I'm sure you'd be fine if we hung everyone from the SA, Marine-SA, Waffen-SS, SS, Gestapo, Ordnungpolezei, and party structure we came across. And anyone who has facial features resembling a racial stereotype (say Blonde and Blue eyed?) once we got into Germany? After all, it was justified under military law when the Wehrmacht did it.
Did you hear about the 20th of July?
You mean the day that the entirety of the Wehrmacht, except for a few men, decided to side with Hitler?
Some did not act as they feared for their families, some did not act because of the oath, which was for a Prussian officer something holy, much more full of means than today.
Or, evidently, then it had a few years prior, when they were sworn to uphold Constitution of the Weimar Republic. Or a few years later, when they were sworn to tell the truth when they were on trial.
7. Atrocities made by single soldiers were punished severely.
Atrocities made by groups of soldiers were rewarded handsomely.
Still, it wasn't the Austrians who voted AH.
While its tough to judge accurately, do to intimidation, when the Nazi moved into Austria, popularity for the Austrofascists had declined, the Nazis did have the majorities support.
Göring ran the Luftwaffe, but despite his party memebrship it reamained as unpolitical as the other branches.
This is true, but not in the way you meant it. The Lufftwaffe was ideological from the start. It was a branch of the armed forces built entirely under the Nazis, ideology was entrenched in it.
Also be aware that showing emotions for Prussian officers were not tolerated in general. Also they did not feel responsible for these crimes.
As a rather good webcomic points out "In this instance, being guilty means you did the crime, not how you feel about it."
I doubt anyone but a madman (or someone with the benefit of hindsight) would have decided to re-occupy the Rhineland. Or unite with Austria, or carve away Sudtenland, or take over all of Czechoslovakia. No my friend, WWII was a big result of tone madman.
No one would have cared if Hitler had reoccupied the Rhineland. It was Hitler's
army that reoccupied the Rhineland. If it was all "tone madman" then I believe we could have sent one British soldier to crack him in the mouth and the whole affair would be over. The problem was that it wasn't "tone madman" but a whole nation that agreed with him.
PH: If there is a doubt the pictures are not showing attrocities: Yes, you have to prove them!
Do you have any photos of the crimes you've accused the soviets of? If we were to apply your absurd standard, theres no evidence of wrong doing at Kolyma?
But from the laws accepted. And thus no crime.
Thats funny, I thought Legalism was thrown out with Qin Shi Huang.
Professional soldiers are trained to be A-Political. They are trained to carry out policy and will fight for their country regardless of what political party is in power... to a point.
German soldiers are not. The unification of Germany itself is tied to the fact that the German army was to be politicized. It was no less politicized in the 1930s then it was in the Wilhelmine era, and if you think they were apolitical then, you're screwier then Willy.
Desertion is a thing that idealists trot out when they don't understand that the core value of any military is the ability to take orders through thick and thin and not just when they suit.
I think it is Herr Von Seekt that is in need of this lecture, not us.
From the beginning of Prussian military tradition they had to stay out of the politics.
Again, absolute rubbish. The Prussian Military establishment had been politicized since the days of Bismark and continued to remain so until 1945.
Also there was absolutely no way that any political change was going to occur anyway. What would be the result of a successful coup? Hitler replaced. The Nazi party would still be in power.
Even that would yield worthwhile results. Look at Italy, the Fascist Party remains in power throughout the war, fighting for the allies.