1. We have added a Gift Upgrades feature that allows you to gift an account upgrade to another member, just in time for the holiday season. You can see the gift option when going to the Account Upgrades screen, or on any user profile screen.
    Dismiss Notice

Idea for Religion: Holy City States

Discussion in 'Civ - Ideas & Suggestions' started by craig123, Aug 13, 2010.

  1. GigaNerd

    GigaNerd His Nerdiness

    Joined:
    Sep 13, 2007
    Messages:
    270
    Location:
    Violet City, Johto
    HOLD IT!!!

    Perhaps each (major) Christian denomination should receive its own Holy City? Mormons are Christians too, y'know!

    Catholocism - Vatican City
    Mormonism - Salt Lake City
    Protestantism - Wittenburg(?) [Could a Protestant please give their opinion on this one?]
    Orthodox - ??? [I'm a bit clueless here. Help? :confused:]
    Anglican - Canterbury


    A few more ideas to top the cake!
    • Not every religion should be available simultaneously in every game - the player should be able to decide how many can show up at a time.
    • Also, Holy Cities don't have to be the "literal" holy cities - Jerusalem works for Jews, but Vatican City works for Catholics.
     
  2. Ahriman

    Ahriman Tyrant

    Joined:
    Jun 8, 2008
    Messages:
    13,266
    Location:
    Washington, DC
    If you're going to have 5 flavors of Christianity, how many flavors of Islam (just Shia/Sunni or Wahabbist, Sufi, ....), hinduisum, and so forth?

    And why just the European Christians? No Coptic christians or Monophysites?

    Getting into this kind of detail is a mistake I think.

    [If you did pick an Orthodox Christian Holy city it would be Constantinople.]
     
  3. johny smith

    johny smith Deity

    Joined:
    Mar 10, 2007
    Messages:
    2,273
    Well the idea is not bad. But it always could just come back to why not have a faction of religion in the game that the city states nor civilizations have control over. I am always for adding more features that player has little control over.

    But as for this idea of city states being the religious centers...It depends how many religions you want to determine holy cities. If you are just looking at the previous model in Civ4 like I assume then Mecca should be the city state and Baghdad the capital of the Arab Caliphate. I assume the Arabs are being represented as the caliphate. America's first capital was not Washington but was built as the capital. The same case applies to the Arabs. Baghdad was built as the capital for Caliphate.

    Now Judaism and Christianity is another issue. Catholics see the Vatican as holy city, but not all Christians. I would suggest Jerusalem for Judaism, and Bethlehem for Christianity. Which most people would find lame because you want the Vatican in.

    So why not just expand the number of religions? Then have Catholics in the Vatican, Orthodox in Constantinople. We could on go with a large list. How complicated would you want religion?

    Confucianism was very important as well in that effected all of the surrounding East Asian civilizations. More so then Taoism did. But I would agree Taoism is more of a religion.

    Buddhism's holy city is not in Tibet. Vajrayana Buddhism is in Tibet, and it is not the largest group. I have no clue on what would be a better place though for Buddhism.

    Hinduism is similar to the Buddhist question. What is the most important city?

    I don't know what the proper amount should be for religions. If just 7 I would suggest Zoroastrianism to be added.

    Here is link to show followers if you split up the religion into denominations.
    http://www.adherents.com/adh_branches.html
    Scroll to the bottom of the linked page to see a break down by denomination.

    I am not saying this idea is bad. It is simple and better than most. I just don't think anyone has thought out what religions would be attached to what city states.

    PS:
    Click my Rapture signature if you want to see an insane amount of religions that I was trying to add to Civ4.
     
  4. D712

    D712 Queen

    Joined:
    Jul 15, 2010
    Messages:
    528
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    USA
    HOLD IT!!!

    You are being way too christiancentric. That would upset so many people. Generalizations make people less upset because when you say "christian" that includes all christian groups, "Muslim" includes Sunni and Shi'a, and so on and so forth. It makes everything better.
     
  5. craig123

    craig123 Prince

    Joined:
    May 13, 2010
    Messages:
    314
    Location:
    UK
    It does - the more the merrier! :D (You can show you're support in your signature too :mischief:)

    I dunno; civ4 managed to avoid any offense AFAIK.

    Bloody hell! :scared: Was not expecting font that large! Not many would be brave enough to go for :crazyeye:
     
  6. Cull

    Cull Big Daddy

    Joined:
    Feb 21, 2010
    Messages:
    2,838
    Exactly why this idea is bad.

    Hinduism similar to Buddhism? Then why isn't the religions of Islam, Christianity, and Judaism put together, not even just including Mormonism, Catholicism, and so on? How about Shi'a and the other one? How about...?

    And too much is based on opinion. X holy city is Y that you believe is true but what if somebody else thinks its Z?
     
  7. johny smith

    johny smith Deity

    Joined:
    Mar 10, 2007
    Messages:
    2,273
    Well as for offending or not...I think it has more to do with being somewhat close versus being total lost on the religion you are representing. And that is why I argued it is the same for civilizations as well. So I will hush now, but there is no simple way of making everyone happy imo.

    It may be possible though to go into a little more detail but keeps the mechanics just as simple. Anyway I will hear people tell me I don't want to do that I like my games simple. I am not suggesting complicating the mechanics. I am only suggesting expanding the selection and the AI would simply randomly choose from a larger selection. I know I will me hammered at now. I don't care to argue about the issue though.

    Here are the real world stats on religion, but we are playing history not the present time remember. This applies only on who you might offend.
    Spoiler :
    Catholic Christianity 1,050,000,000
    Sunni Islam 940,000,000
    Vaishnavites Hinduism 580,000,000
    Orthodox/Eastern Christian Christianity 240,000,000
    Shaivites Hinduism 220,000,000
    Conservative Protestant Christianity 200,000,000
    Mahayana Buddhism 185,000,000
    Liberal Protestant Christianity 150,000,000
    Theravada Buddhism 124,000,000
    Shiite Islam 120,000,000
    African indigenous sects (AICs) Christianity 110,000,000
    Pentecostal Christianity 105,000,000
    Anglican Christianity 73,000,000
    Sikhism Sikhism 23,000,000
    neo-Hindus
    and reform Hindus Hinduism 22,000,000
    Lamaism
    (Vajrayana/Tibetan, etc.) Buddhism 20,000,000
    Jehovah's Witnesses Christianity 14,800,000
    Latter Day Saints Christianity 12,500,000
    Ahmadiyya Islam 10,000,000
    Veerashaivas (Lingayats) Hinduism 10,000,000
    Baha'i World Faith Baha'i Faiths 6,000,000
    Conservative Judaism 4,500,000
    Unaffiliated and Secular Judaism 4,500,000
    Svetambara Jainism 4,000,000
    Reform Judaism 3,750,000
    Seicho-No-Ie New Japanese 3,200,000
    Shinto all branches Shinto 3,000,000
    Tenrikyo New Japanese 2,800,000
    PL Kyodan New Japanese 2,600,000
    Orthodox Judaism 2,000,000
    New Thought
    (Unity, Christian Science, etc.) Christianity 1,500,000
    Sekai Kyuseikyo New Japanese 800,000
    Sthanakavasis Jainism 750,000
    Zenrinkai New Japanese 600,000
    Druze Islam 450,000
    Tensho Kotai Jingukyo New Japanese 400,000
    Friends (Quakers) Christianity 300,000
    Ennokyo New Japanese 300,000
    Digambaras Jainism 155,000
    Reconstructionist Judaism 150,000
    Parsis Zoroastrianism 110,000
    Gabars Zoroastrianism 20,000
     
  8. EvanMeisterX

    EvanMeisterX Warlord

    Joined:
    Sep 20, 2009
    Messages:
    162
    Location:
    Behind you.
    HOLD IT!!!
    Why put religions in the actual city? Why not just put them go random cities? Not offending anyone>Realism.
     
  9. Caeserportugal

    Caeserportugal Prince

    Joined:
    Aug 9, 2010
    Messages:
    526
    Location:
    Portugal
    This is a lis of holy cities

    Judaism - Jerusalem

    Catholicism - Rome, Jerusalem Santiago de Compostela and Fatima that is in Portugal by the way.

    Orthodox Christianity - Constatinople , Antioch , Jerusalem , Moscow since it is the Third Rome and Alexandria

    Protestantism - Wittenburg

    Calvinism - Geneva

    Anglicanism - Canterbury

    Islam - Mecca, Medina and Jerusalem (I don't know if there are specific ones different to Shia or Sunni)

    Hindusism- Varanasi?

    Buddhism - Lhasa

    Confucionsim - some city near southern china

    Taoism - I don't know as well

    Hellenism - Athens or Sparta perhaps
     
  10. Cull

    Cull Big Daddy

    Joined:
    Feb 21, 2010
    Messages:
    2,838
    Lolwut.

    Links or better proof, not broad claims.
     
  11. Schuesseled

    Schuesseled Deity

    Joined:
    Mar 31, 2008
    Messages:
    2,081
    why not just one religion appropriately called "mass delusion", and have that in.

    Personally i hate how you needed religions in civ 4, there was no atheist religion for the non-believers.
     
  12. johny smith

    johny smith Deity

    Joined:
    Mar 10, 2007
    Messages:
    2,273
    Calvinism I would just drop. It was a movement really within Protestantism.

    Shia does has an extra layer really imo. The best is the first of 12 Imans probably.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imam_Ali_Mosque (The same place that was blown up in Iraq you can see why it angered Shiites probably better now)

    Hellenism was never unified. No other groups really followed Hellenism. It was more of a culture features of the Greeks. I mean there was never really an organized religion around it.

    Anyway you could see how the makers of the game dropped religion. Probably too much work for them to do it right.
     
  13. marioflag

    marioflag History Addict

    Joined:
    Oct 20, 2005
    Messages:
    1,902
    Location:
    Napoli, Italy
    I support your excellent idea :)

    Lol, we should copyright that signature only for supporters if we wanna make a successful campaign :p
     
  14. stealth_nsk

    stealth_nsk Deity

    Joined:
    Nov 28, 2005
    Messages:
    5,514
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    Novosibirsk, Russia
    Generally idea is good, but without the general religion mechanic it's useless. How religion is spread? What bonuses it gives? etc.
     
  15. Sonereal

    Sonereal ♫We got the guillotine♫ Supporter

    Joined:
    Mar 31, 2008
    Messages:
    14,879
    Atheism isn't a religion. :rolleyes:

    The easiest way to pull it off in Civ4 would be able to allow Theocracy to run without a state religion and you'll pretty much have an Atheist State.

    I had another idea regarding religions which would make them slightly more realistic and interesting gameplay wise. The problem with the city-state idea is that more often than not, these cities were not city-states but part of a larger nation. Trying to put branches of each major religion would seriously cut down on the abstraction factor.

    Spoiler :
    Actually, it may be a full point against religions unless reimplemented correctly with Schisms and all.

    It could be simple too. Don't need to throw in "Protestantism" or "Sunnis" into the mix at all. Just need to change the name of the state religion of the resulting schism. Say that France and England are Christian and relations between the two nations sour to an extreme. France has the Christian holy city so England can either suck it up and bow down to Paris or break off from the church so now there are two Christian churches, English Christianity and French Christianity and a random city (or capital) of England becomes the holy city for EC.
     
  16. Aussie_Lurker

    Aussie_Lurker Deity

    Joined:
    Jul 21, 2003
    Messages:
    7,784
    Location:
    Adelaide, South Australia
    Don't feel bad, Craig. ShaqFu has displayed his unrelenting hatred & opposition to any representation of Religion in the Civilization Franchise on multiple occasions. I personally don't understand why someone can be so utterly opposed to *any* representation of religion in the game-especially when they don't even give very good reasons for said opposition.

    Aussie.
     
  17. Pouakai

    Pouakai It belongs in a museum. Moderator

    Joined:
    Jun 16, 2010
    Messages:
    7,158
    Location:
    Aotearoa
    If we're adding 50 different types of christianity, islam, hinduism etc. We CANNOT forget the allmighty...


    SCIENTOLOGY!!!
     
  18. chaotoroboto

    chaotoroboto Warlord

    Joined:
    Jul 24, 2010
    Messages:
    151
    I think this falls under the the same issue as city-states generally, which is that there's no real reason not to just have all of them. Scientology, Wicca, Kim Il-Sungism, Asatru, World of Warcraft, I'm sure there's millions we could think of. We certainly came to bat in the missing city states thread.

    Knowing what we currently know of Civ 5 without having actually played it, here's how I'd run this in a mod:

    Step 1: Script religions into the Civs
    - Religions would be empirewide, not by city.
    - There are no religion-specific buildings* or units.
    - Civs would ignore Religions for Civ-to-Civ diplomacy, as City State diplomacy should play well enough.
    - Civs can switch religions from start of game with no direct penalty*, or choose not to have a religion.

    Step 2: Create and script "Religious" City States (as opposed to MAritime, Cultural, or Militaristic).
    - Provide Happiness and a modicum of Culture.
    - Are ascribed a relevant religion.
    - Can ally with ALL Civs that share their religion, are never worse than neutral with Civs that share their religion.
    - Are never happier than neutral with Civs that are another religion, and never above friendly with Civs that have no religion.
    - The first Civ to ally with a religious city-state receives the "Holy City" wonder for that religion in a random city. This provides happiness, culture, and gold. If the Civ changes religion or abandons religion, it loses some or all of this bonus.
    - The City State only declares war if ALL allies have declared war, and never on a Civ that shares its religion.
    - Other city states do not ascribe to a specific religion and play as normal.

    Step 3: Script events, quests, and what not for the Religious city-states to pursue

    Step 4: Script Religious city-states into the world creation
    - Balance so that ~25% of city states are religious in any given game. Say 3 to 4 on a standard map.
    - To allow for lots of variety, have City States that otherwise would be parts of Civs, only pop if the related Civ isn't playing - So Boston(Puritans) and Salt Lake City wouldn't show if Americans were in play.

    Step 5: Adjust SocPols as needed (Hard to tell what needs to be tweaked without having played the game)

    I think this would provide a realistic and interesting enhancement to gameplay, without bogging like religions can tend to in 4. The existing City States mechanics should carry it the rest of the way.

    Oh, hey, Port au Prince could host Voudon, and Kingston Rastafari.
     
  19. wapamingo

    wapamingo Prince

    Joined:
    Sep 19, 2006
    Messages:
    399
    from a civ-simulation perspective of 'what if' where the theme of the game is: why tie existing cities to religions. this would mean that if that city state is not in game then that religion is not in game.

    make it random amongst the spawned city states per game map.
     
  20. grant2004

    grant2004 Citizen

    Joined:
    Jul 11, 2004
    Messages:
    1,315
    Location:
    America
    Hmm, interesting idea. I think this is a very good suggestion for how to bring religion back to Civ V while avoiding the problems we saw in Civ IV. I imagine this might even be something that a strong modder would be able to create. I have no doubt that this will be tried eventually.
     

Share This Page