Guys,
I have the same problem and it is the second set. I think 2kgames really screwed us all and we did not pay $50 for all this mess. How about the time we have to put in to get a "working" copy? Who is gonna compensate us for our precious time?
I do not know if it will help but I have written a complain letter sent to their public relations contact. If we can gather enough frustration and make our voice heard, I believe 2kgames will move A LOT faster in fixing a ridiculous problem like this.
But before that happens, I guess I still have to go to Best Buy AGAIN. Btw, anybody successfully got store credit at Best Buy because of this? Thank you all.