Rioter Who Pinned Officer With Shield Gets 7½ Years
BY C. RYAN BARBER
WASHINGTON—Among the most searing images of Jan. 6, 2021, was a police officer, bloodied and pinned inside a doorway, screaming for help as a rioter at the front of a pro-Trump mob pushed against him with a stolen riot shield.
More than two years later, that rioter received one of the lengthiest prison sentences to date in a prosecution stemming from the attack on the U.S. Capitol.
A federal judge on Friday sentenced Patrick McCaughey of Connecticut to 7½ years in prison after finding him guilty in September of assaulting police and obstructing Congress’s certification of the 2020 presidential election results. Mr. McCaughey elected to have a so-called bench trial, leaving it up to Judge Trevor McFadden rather than a jury to review evidence and render a verdict. Handing down the sentence, Judge McFadden said Mr. McCaughey, 25 years old, had become a “poster-child of all that was dangerous and appalling” about the Capitol assault. But he said the defendant’s role in the Capitol assault marked a “strange aberration” from an otherwise law-abiding life. “You can do better than this,” said Judge McFadden, who was appointed to the bench by President Donald Trump. Ahead of Friday’s sentencing, the Justice Department recommended a nearly 16-year prison term for Mr. McCaughey.
Mr. McCaughey’s defense lawyer, Dennis Boyle, earlier suggested a year-long sentence but said at Friday’s hearing he would “concede that is too low” and instead recommended a two-year prison sentence. “Jan. 6 is over. It’s done,” Mr. Boyle said. The sentence fell below the 10-year prison term that Thomas Webster, a former New York City police officer, is currently serving after being convicted of violently assaulting a police officer in a melee outside the Capitol. That remains the longest sentence ordered in a case related to the Jan. 6, 2021, attack.
Federal prosecutors described Mr. McCaughey’s conduct as “ heinous” and recounted a violent scene where dozens of rioters joined him in a “ heave-ho” push against a police line defending a door into the Capitol. Mr. McCaughey gained control of a police shield, prosecutors said, and headed to the front of the mob, where he came face-to-face with D.C. Metropolitan Police Officer Daniel Hodges. Mr. McCaughey apologized for his role in the Capitol assault, describing his conduct as the “greatest embarrassment of my life.” From now on, he said, anyone can go online and find a “video of me behaving like a thug.” In an address to Judge Mc-Fadden, Officer Hodges
‘Of all the weapons used that day, the most effective was the mob.’
In this image from a U.S. Capitol Police video, released and annotated by the Justice Department, Patrick McCaughey appears on police body-worn camera footage at the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE/ ASSOCIATED PRESS
said a day doesn’t pass without him remembering the Jan. 6 attack and police officers’ efforts to defend the Capitol. “Of all the weapons used that day, the most effective was the mob,” he said.
Of Mr. McCaughey, Officer Hodges added, “He was not just part of the mob. He was at the vanguard of the assault.”