No, you're missing the point, because again, Camikaze DID say in this update that Saruman had told his minion something, and that nobody was killed. Since every single time without fail it's been "Saruman orders Ugluk" then if Saruman ordered Ugluk to do nothing this seems like what we'd get. I'm also not ruling out the possibility that Isengard was punished/lost their kill tonight because of Bad Player. But obviously Camikaze could never publicly verify that and I do think it's a long shot, however that's something you couldn't expect to see explained explicitly, yet would result in something like this here. And I DO think Bad Player was Mafia, and he was clearly breaking rules to a far greater degree than many other "dead" players did yet nothing really came of that. Also, you're likely wrong about Night Three just for reference; I don't see why you think that someone being saved by the Eagle was different than, say Gandalf not saving someone. Note Camikaze did NOT reveal that it was the Eagle who extended Night to 48 hours/got an "automatically save someone" deal. And you're definitely wrong about Night Four, because Sauron was specifically roleblocked, NOT inactive. It was interesting at the time that it obviously did not seem like he was roleblocked in the writeup, but that was what happened verified by others later. If anything, again suggesting that because this writeup very explicitly does NOT say "Ugluk was dead after today's lynch" that it shouldn't be blindly assumed.