Stacmon
Explorer
Those of you with some background knowledge in the areas of current affairs, history or Islam have probably noticed that the graphic for the Muslim Shrine, called "The Masjid Al-Haram," actually represents the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem, rather than the correct structure in Mecca.
I wasn't aware of any formal letter/e-mail sent to Firaxis to address the issue, so I decided to send one myself. I contacted a person responsible for Fan Concerns and eagerly await a reply.
Because I think this is a serious oversight, I believe it warrants attention and should be remedied. Imagine if the Church of the Nativity had a graphic representing the Vatican, or that the Dome of the Rock was used for Judaism's Temple of Solomon instead of the Masjid Al-Haram. I hope that I have the community's support regarding the matter, and encourage people to post here if they agree (as well as vote in the poll). Attention to detail and quality in a game like this is very important, and I feel that movement on the part of the game's developers is only likely if others show the same concern that I do.
The following is the exact e-mail that I sent to Firaxis, for those of you who are interested:
Now the ball is in your court.
I wasn't aware of any formal letter/e-mail sent to Firaxis to address the issue, so I decided to send one myself. I contacted a person responsible for Fan Concerns and eagerly await a reply.
Because I think this is a serious oversight, I believe it warrants attention and should be remedied. Imagine if the Church of the Nativity had a graphic representing the Vatican, or that the Dome of the Rock was used for Judaism's Temple of Solomon instead of the Masjid Al-Haram. I hope that I have the community's support regarding the matter, and encourage people to post here if they agree (as well as vote in the poll). Attention to detail and quality in a game like this is very important, and I feel that movement on the part of the game's developers is only likely if others show the same concern that I do.
The following is the exact e-mail that I sent to Firaxis, for those of you who are interested:
Dear sir or madam,
Although it is very likely that you are already aware of this issue, I thought it would be worthwhile to alert your staff to it in the event that you are not.
In Civilization IV, one of the wonders and religious shrines, the "Masjid Al-Haram," is misrepresented with the wrong graphic. The graphic actually portrays the Qubbat As-Sakhrah (or "Dome of the Rock") which is in Jerusalem. Here is a link for comparison: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Dome_of_the_rock_distance.jpg
The Masjid Al-Haram, in Mecca can be seen in this picture, along with the famous Kabba: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Mecca_skyline.jpg
This mosque is considered the holiest place among followers of Islam and it was a great disappointment when I noticed this oversight. Seeing a religious structure from Jerusalem built in Mecca, especially with an incorrect name and Civilopedia description, is a constant frustration to myself and many other Civilization IV players. Although I personally do not see the initial error as offensive, I feel that ignoring it further would show both religious insensitivity and a disregard for the quality and accuracy of an otherwise fantastic game.
I hope, that having been given this information, the game's developers will take action. If no game artists are able to make an appropriate representation of the proper Masjid Al-Haram, I hope that Firaxis would consider seeking help from the dedicated Civilization IV community. There is no shortage of players with the skill and competence to create a high quality graphic that could officially be incorporated into the game. I am also certain that they would do it eagerly.
Thank you for reading over this e-mail and forwarding it to the relevant people within Firaxis. If possible, I would appreciate a reply as confirmation, as well as an indication of whether or not the problem will be addressed.
Sincerely,
Rami Fayad
Now the ball is in your court.