I guess it really depends on your own taste... I can recommend the review section, which, while it does not yet contain so many reviews, does list a number of top-notch scenarios which comes highly recommended.
I just downloaded John Valdez' Civ1 modpack, to try and see what he did to simulate Civ1 within Civ2, since I'm exploring the possibilites of simulating some Civ2 concepts/artwork within Civ3. I guess I'm really more of a ripper/creator than a player, so I like to get into what kind of graphics and ideas others have used in their scens. And I prefer historical scenarios over sci-fi and fantasy.
Among many others, I've been very entertained/inspired with scenarios like Brown Man's Burden by Carl Fritz, El Dorado by Jesus Balsinde and kobayashis Zweiter Weltkrieg. But there are MANY others, that are cool. There was a thread some time ago trying to compile a "top 100"... try searching for it.
Also John Valdez Dinosaurs patch was quite unusual, and very atmospheric.
Its better if you are a bit more specific. If a scenario is of a theme you like, you will tend to enjoy it even if it is "not so good". On the other hand, you may find a "good" scenario boring. It may be possible to give a list based on technical proficiency and historical realism but I doubt if that's what youhave in mind.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.