Can't speak for that poster --
But I agree with the sentiment.... There are a few titles that I buy sight unseen, without even bothering to know what's in the next iteration or expansion. Don't care about the reviews, don't care about the features list -- I've come to "trust" certain titles. Ever since Civ I became Civ II - Civilization has been on that list... It's not, as of this release... and I got over the Civ III PTW expansion (which was essentially $20 for a dozen scenarios) really quickly and easily.
Since you took the time to write a good post i'll do a proper reply for you.
Think back a few months, Command and Conquer 4 was announced, The Final Chapter of the Tiberium chronicles!
Everyone was zomg must have!
After release everyone was disgusted with what they were playing, that game has the name but was not like Command and Conquer, the whole core mechanics were actually altered to a diffrent games mechanics, good or bad that's beside the point.
But would anyone ever imagined a "bad" command and conquer game existed?
I was smart and just waited to try it out or actually be able to see some from it, i decided later against it, not my type of gameplay at all.
Basically what im saying here is : Alot of Companies are trying diffrent things, some people will like it, some wont.
Give it a try in these days before buying, you will spare yourself alot of money by not buying things you wont endup liking.
And hey who knows, maybe a few months later you can buy it for cheap and give it a try anyways