Promise to not declare war should extend to protected City States

[Bromar1]

Attila and I agreed to not declare war on each other for 20 turns but then he turns around and declares war on my protected ally, with no diplomatic penalty. If I declare war, then I will be hit with negative diplo all other civs

 

[usadefcon1]

Gift the City State units to fight back.

 

[paul_soryu]

Well that's what's called a proxy war, isn't it?

 

[pochesun]

I think there definitely should be some sort of diplomatic penalty for attacking protected city state.

 

[Remito]

I think there definitely should be some sort of diplomatic penalty for attacking protected city state.

There is one.

 

[pochesun]

There is one.

yes, i meant there should be more severe one

 

[Fluffball]

Surround the city with your own units so they cannot take it.

 

[paul_soryu]

Surround the city with your own units so they cannot take it.

That reminded me of how neutral scouts tend to always be in the worst spot possible while you are fighting with someone, as if they choose these tiles on purpose to help your enemy. Surrounding a city with your own units is like an epitome of such behaviour, turned against the AI

 

[trinket]

Surround the city with your own units so they cannot take it.

the UN method