Got two things that seem wrong with promotions and one thing that might be fun:
1. The Promotions that grant continued XP against Aminals and Barbarians past the limit don't work in Dynamic XP settings. Dynamic XP means you continue to gain XP past any set limits. If the promotions instead granted both allowing XP past limit AND +25% XP vs the type they would be worth taking regardless of XP settings.
2. Not all promotions are only beneficial, I'm thinking mainly of the Fieldsman promotions but of course all promotions that grant both positive and negative effects, and as such should really never be given as bonus promotion from battle but only able to chose yourself when gaining enough XP to gain a level.
3. To increase the interesting factor of battle promotions it might be fun to add the possibility of gaining the Flavour Promotions via Battle Promotions even if they are not otherwise accessible. That would increase the amount of Battle Promotions available so that some could be removed from being in the list of Battle Promotions (like the Fieldman ones though others could be removed too then if thought necessary or better for game play).
Cheers
1. The Promotions that grant continued XP against Aminals and Barbarians past the limit don't work in Dynamic XP settings. Dynamic XP means you continue to gain XP past any set limits. If the promotions instead granted both allowing XP past limit AND +25% XP vs the type they would be worth taking regardless of XP settings.
2. Not all promotions are only beneficial, I'm thinking mainly of the Fieldsman promotions but of course all promotions that grant both positive and negative effects, and as such should really never be given as bonus promotion from battle but only able to chose yourself when gaining enough XP to gain a level.
3. To increase the interesting factor of battle promotions it might be fun to add the possibility of gaining the Flavour Promotions via Battle Promotions even if they are not otherwise accessible. That would increase the amount of Battle Promotions available so that some could be removed from being in the list of Battle Promotions (like the Fieldman ones though others could be removed too then if thought necessary or better for game play).
Cheers
