Rank our civs

[Tubby Rower]

Ok post your ranking of the civs that you want. (if it matters for map type, post seperate lists)

5 points will given to your #1
4 points will given to your #2
3 points will given to your #3
2 points will given to your #4
1 point will given to your #5
0 points will be given to your #6 and below


Available Choices (> 3 in other poll)
Ottomans
Iroquois
Japan
France
Dutch
China
Celts
Germany
Byzantines
England
Sumerians
Vikings



People to vote
BCLG100
Whomp
Emp. Killyouall
Robi D
socralynnek
Butterball
Vind2
Tubby Rower
DaveShack
Wotan
Beorn-eL-Feared
Kickbooti
gmaharriet


Current results(11 out of 13 voting)

[U]non-archi[/U]		[U]archipeligo[/U]
Ottomans (49)		Dutch (44)
Iroquois (35)		Ottomans (30)
China  (24)		Byzantines (19)
Japan (22)		England (16)
France (16)		Iroquois (13)
			
Dutch (12)		France (13)
Celts (5)		Japan (12)
Sumeria (2)		Vikings (10)
			Carthage (4)
			Sumeria (3)
			China  (3)

freaking Whomp stirring the poop bucket

 

[Tubby Rower]

Tubby's picks independent of map type

#1 Otto
#2 Japan
#3 Dutch
#4 Iroquois
#5 France

 

[socralynnek]

considering the new options...

archi map:

#1 Dutch
#2 Otto
#3 Iro
#4 France
#5 Japan
#3 Byz
#4 Engl
#5 Sumerians

non-archi
#1 Otto
#2 Iro
#3 Dutch
#4 France
#5 Japan
#3 Celts
#4 Sum
#5 France

 

[Beorn-eL-Feared]

Map independant:
EDIT: Map dependant

Non-Archipelago:
#1 France
#2 Dutch
#3 Jap
#4 Iro
#5 China

Archipelago:
#1 Byzantines
#2 French
#3 English
#4 Dutch
#5 Viks

 

[Robi D]

non-archi
1.Ottoman
2.Japan
3.China
4.Iroquois
5.Dutch

archi
1. Byzantine
1. 2.Dutch
2. 3.Ottoman
3. 4.Japan
4. 5.France
5.Iroquois
*as a note had Byzantine been available i would have put them 1st on the archi map

Vote changed

 

[gmaharriet]

non-archi
Ottomans
China
Iroquois
Japan
Celts


archi
Dutch
Ottomans
Iroquois
France
China

I almost never play SEA civs or archi maps, so I'm not well-informed. If that ends up being the type of map we play on, I'll leave the choice of which civs to those with more experience than I and abstain from that section. Maybe I'll even learn something when we actually play the game.

 

[BCLG100]

Otto
Iro
Japan
China
Dutch

 

[Beorn-eL-Feared]

*as a note had Byzantine been available i would have put them 1st on the archi map

I know I would have included England and Byzance in my top 3 alongside France.

 

[DaveShack]

I had suggested write-ins if you really want different ones on archi map. I might just pick those two myself.

Guess since I suggested this, better do my homework and vote.

 

[Tubby Rower]

we did this in MTDG 1 I believe inside Team Kiss. so it was a good idea and apparently it doesn't exactly reflect the other poll.

RE: Theodora fans.... You should have voted for her. IIRC only Vind voted for her.

 

[Whomp]

I'm going to mess this up a bit since they're two distincly different situations imo.

Independent
1. Ottos
2. Iroquois
3. China
4. France
5. Japan

Arch map
1. Dutch
2. Byz
3. England
4. Sumerians
5. France

 

[Tubby Rower]

Whomp, Byzantines, England, & Sumerians didn't make the cut since no 3 people would vote for them in the other poll. Please vote for the civs that I have listed or everyone will have to re-vote.

Byzantines only got one vote (from Vind), England was barely mentioned by a post from BEF, and Sumerians were never mentioned.

I guess I can add them, but if anyone changes their vote they need to PM me or I won't see it.

 

[Whomp]

I'm not trying to complicate kindergarten but I think there's two distinct situations here.

Pangea type map or arch map. I see very different strengths on arch than I do pangea.

Can we break this down into two map types?

 

[Tubby Rower]

it is.. see the first post

 

[Beorn-eL-Feared]

I changed mine for archipelago, but not otherwise, so if you want to change the total for archipelago it's [(Arch * rank) - (pang * rank)]

 

[Tubby Rower]

Stop adding civs

Ok I've updated the list in post #1 with socralynnek's and Beorn's updated rankings. This almost made me pull out the calculator.

BCLG said that his vote didn't change... neither did mine

 

[Beorn-eL-Feared]

Sorry for that - I wish I could've just edited your post with my changes to save you the hassle.

Hey wait a second, if someone changes his/her vote, they should put up a self-updated list in their post so tubs only has a bit of cut/paste to do at most, this could work I think.

 

[Butterball]

Non-Arch
1. Otto
2. Iro
3. Dutch
4. Chine
5. Nippon

Arch
1. Dutch
2. Otto
3. Byz
4. Iro
5. Nippon
BB

 

[DaveShack]

Non-Arch

1. Iro
2. Otto
3. Japan
4. France
5. China

Arch

1. Dutch
2. England
3. Ottomans
4. Byzantines
5. Vikings

 

[Vind2]

Non-Arch

1. Ottomans
2. China
3. Iroquois
4. France
5. Celts

Archi

1. Vikings
2. England
3. Dutch
4. Byz.
5. Otto.