Rare birds devour rare fish

[Speedo]

BERLIN, Germany (Reuters) -- A protected species of bird is devouring rare fish in the German state of Bavaria and creating a dilemma for local officials who now want federal permission to kill birds that once appeared headed for extinction.

The population of cormorants -- black, long-beaked fishing specialists which can stay underwater for up to 30 seconds -- has ballooned to over 6,000 in the Alpine state.

And they are feeding on rare fish species such as grayling and pearl fish, which are unique to the region, German officials said.

"The problem is that a protected bird is eating protected fish," a spokesman for the Bavarian environment ministry said this week.

Eager to save the fish from extinction in the wild, Bavaria has asked the federal government for permission to reduce the bird population, for example by shooting them or taking their eggs. It is also seeking help from the European Union.

"As the birds migrate from other countries we need a European-wide ruling for it to be effective," said the environment ministry spokesman.

The cormorant population has been growing in Germany since the bird was put under European Union-wide protection in the early 1980s when it appeared headed for extinction.

"About 90 percent of river fish are now under massive threat from the birds," said Oliver Born, an official from the Bavarian state fisheries union. "There are some rivers where we have shown that when Cormorants come, 95 percent of the fish disappear by the end of the winter."

But some say the government action is misguided.

"Their plan will not get us anywhere," said Andreas von Lindeiner of the Bavarian bird protection group. "We cannot destroy the bird colonies," he said.

Fishermen at Bavaria's Chiemsee lake, one of Germany's largest, say the birds are eating into their business.

The fish are reared in commercial fisheries that may look like all-you-can-eat buffets to cormorants because large numbers of fish are gathered in small areas of shallow water.

"My fishery loses some 40 tons of fish a year to the cormorants," said Holmer Lex, 75, who owns a fishery on the Chiemsee. "We only produce 90 tons a year."

"The Chiemsee is the only lake in Germany that has pearl fish," Lex said. "They have died out in the lake, but we're trying to raise them now."

The regional government ordered the cormorant population in the Chiemsee to be cut in half last year, but rejected a request put forward by Lex and others to halve it again this year.

"Cutting the population of birds will help solve the problem over the medium term," Born said.

http://www.cnn.com/2003/TECH/science/11/13/germany.bird.fish.reut/index.html

I love the irony

 

[superslug]

The fish seem to have more economic importance than do the birds. I say lock and load, fire at will!

 

[Aphex_Twin]

"Cutting the population of birds will help solve the problem over the medium term," Born said.

How about cutting the population of fishermen? That should solve the problem on the long term.

 

[rilnator]

Nah keep the birds! You hardly ever see fish- so no one will miss them!

 

[thestonesfan]

Holy crap...these birds can stay underwater for 30 SECONDS.

 

[superslug]

Originally posted by thestonesfan
Holy crap...these birds can stay underwater for 30 SECONDS.

Yeah, they can stay for even longer if they're shot out of the sky like they should be!

 

[thestonesfan]

Originally posted by superslug

Yeah, they can stay for even longer if they're shot out of the sky like they should be!

Yes, I find that they float rather poorly.

 

[superslug]

More food for the fish then, perhaps? But only if we blow the birds into small enough pieces correct?

 

[WickedSmurf]

Animals... Bah!

 

[thestonesfan]

And then just scoop up the little fishies in a net!

 

[Aphex_Twin]

Originally posted by thestonesfan
Holy crap...these birds can stay underwater for 30 SECONDS.

So basically, the birds are also fish. The title should say "Rare fish endangered by other rare fish"

 

[Sparrowhawk]

I'm not quite clear on what the role of the "fishermen" is. Are they raising fish in fish farms and then harvesting them, or raising fish in fish farms and then releasing them to catch freely, or are they raising endangered fish to be released into the wild as part of a conservation project?

If it's either of the first two, then I don't see that there is a problem with rare birds eating rare fish - it's more like rare birds eating fish-farmers money.

If it's the final possibility, then it sounds like there are too many birds for a proper balance.

Of course, some genius might consider putting netting over top of the fish pens, thus avoiding the problem altogether.

 

[Perfection]

Bah, just dump a whole lot of toxic waste into the system, and they'll both be dead! Problem solved!

 

[Double Barrel]

Shoot 'em with paintballs!!

Who, you may ask?

Why anything within range, of course!

 

[Puppeteer]

Once again, we could combine two threads to produce more than the some of the parts:

When the aliens come we can convince them to eat these birds instead of us.

 

[SuperBeaverInc.]

Here is my solution to the problem. I will even volunteer to do it!
6,000 cormorants, 5,999 cormorants, 5,998 cormorants, 5,997 cormorants

 

[TNG]

That's just yours here's mine

6,000 comorants:tank: :tank: :tank: :tank: :tank: 0 comorants

 

[Dark Ascendant]

I wonder why the birds were so important in the first place? After all, they were probably eating that same fish to extinction when they themselves were going extinct in the first place.

 

[Archer 007]

The Oscar for irony goes to........

 

[Eastern Knight]

Germans eat cormorants.
Germans eat fish.
Problem solved.