Discussion in 'Mafia/NOTW' started by pzelda, Feb 21, 2021.
howa bout you play the game instead of relying on polarized meta
It was as a response to you asking what LAMISC is
No, I know!
El, can you please explain why you TR Arakhor?
I thought you were thinking I said it sarcastically as a response to your post.
would it mean anything?
If I'm a goner at least you could take my reads seriously
Kinda curious on that too because quote-bombing on Arakhor is next up on my to-do list.
How can you not know this? It was early D1 stuff and a major concern of several players.
But harmless kitties did not get Role PMs. It says so in the very first post of the game.
Tak then later said:
Tak has outted himself as not Vanilla Cat, because he has a role PM. And he's outted himself as not Cat PR, because if he was, he would not be claiming to bait the LYNCH like this.
Towns do NOT bait lynches. Sure, they might aggressively challenge people to vote for them and may even self-righteously self vote if they feel under threat, but they don't PLAN to make "scum slips" to "draw the lynch", because that's stupid. Towns bait NIGHT KILLS to protect PRs, not LYNCHES. Lynches are for WOLVES, which is what Tak is.
I literally did this in my prior analysis.
See also: walls.
I am a cat, though, I mean just look an inch to the left. UNIMPEACHABLE.
Must have missed this, sorry.
Zelda said at the start of night 1 that not all players may be able to post. Radishes was AWOL on night 1. I speculated this meant Radishes could have a scum role but Legacy thought that would be bad design. Hence I’m now wondering if Radishes is 2nd 3rd party.
Got distracted. Had wanted el-ahrairah to explain this but they already did.
I'm embarrassed to say this actually makes sense. Takhisis strongly implied VANILLA in that 'slip' post, NOT PR, which does make the later suggestion that they were trying to draw a lynch kinda ??? They're going to take this badly, but I don't care: el-ahrairah's logic is actually sound here.
I think it was Renata who said that but I agree that if Radishes is prohibited from talking at night then it is probably not linked to a certain alignment for balance reasons.
I literally just re-explained it in post 908.
Yes I have played IRL but it was with a group of friends with cards and candles. This game as I’m learning is far more sophisticated. It’s like saying chess and draughts are the same game as they share a board and some of the same rules...
I actually came up with most of my opening post days in advance and the message I was trying to convey was “I’m new but not a complete idiot, please be nice”
in terms of Johanna, yes it looks bad if you say it like that but I didn’t make the connection with the previous games until after the vote was over.
Overlapped. I was looking up Arakhor posts.
I never read Takh's first post carefully enough to realize what he was implying, and I thought all the accusations -- including yours -- were over the idea that Takhisis had suggested that he DID have a role PM. That's what I thought was stupid. Your take, in contrast, actually does make sense.
a legacy wont get anything done if you sit idly by and let other people be loud about their agenda
push your wincon
Marl, as somebody who has recently both worked and owned with him, what is your read on Ace?
Separate names with a comma.