[RD] Russia Invades Ukraine: War News Thread: Round 6

Status
Not open for further replies.

The AP investigation also refutes Russian claims that the theater was demolished by Ukrainian forces or served as a Ukrainian military base. None of the witnesses saw Ukrainian soldiers operating inside the building. And not one person doubted that the theater was destroyed in a Russian air attack aimed with precision at a civilian target everyone knew was the city’s largest bomb shelter, with children in it.

James Gow, a professor of international security at King’s College London, said documenting what happened at the theater is critical to establishing a pattern of crimes against humanity in Ukraine.

“This strong witness testimony will be important in establishing that (Russian illegal) conduct was widespread or systematic,” said Gow, who also served as an expert witness at the U.N. International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia.

Mariupol has taken on outsize importance as a symbol of the devastation inflicted by Russian forces and of the resistance from Ukraine. The city’s fate is now hanging in the balance, and officials say around 20,000 civilians died during the Russian siege. With Mariupol cut off from access, many fear the bombing of the theater presages more war crimes that have yet to be discovered.

The Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe has declared the attack on the Mariupol drama theater an “egregious violation” of international humanitarian law. The organization’s mid-April report found that “those who ordered or executed it committed a war crime.” It also found no dispute that the destruction of the theater was deliberate.

This finding was echoed by two munitions experts interviewed by the AP, who said the scope of the destruction points to a 500-kilogram bomb from a Russian warplane.

“It’s much too much for an artillery shell,” said Mark Cancian, an explosives analyst at the Center for Strategic and International Studies and a former artillery officer. “The fact that it hit square on would lead me to believe that’s what they were aiming at.”
 

For the first year of Russia’s war on Ukraine, The Associated Press and FRONTLINE gathered, verified and documented evidence of potential war crimes during the conflict. The events detailed here include direct attacks on civilians and civilian infrastructure, including hospitals, schools, residential areas and sites protected under international humanitarian law. War Crimes Watch Ukraine is organized by event or attack. Each event could spawn multiple criminal charges.

From February 2022 to February 2023, AP and FRONTLINE verified 653 events involving potential war crimes.
 

Russian journalist Maria Ponomarenko jailed for highlighting Mariupol killings

Russian journalist Maria Ponomarenko has been jailed for six years for posting on social media about a deadly attack by Russian warplanes on a theatre in Ukraine.

The court in Barnaul in Siberia found her guilty of spreading "fake news", under laws introduced aimed at stifling dissent about the invasion of Ukraine.

She was also barred from activities as a journalist for five years.

Hundreds of civilians died when the Mariupol theatre was bombed last March.

Ponomarenko was detained last April, weeks after the bombing, for posting that Russian warplanes had carried out the attack even though the Russian defence ministry had denied it.

She is one of a growing number of Russian dissidents jailed for criticising the war in Ukraine.


Some 1,200 civilians were seeking shelter inside the theatre when it was bombed by Russian fighter jets. Ukrainian authorities believe 300 people were killed but an Associated Press investigation said the number was closer to 600. Many of the bodies were found in the basement.

Amnesty International said it was a war crime carried out by Russian forces and the international monitoring group OSCE said it had not received any indication to back up Russian allegations that a Ukrainian battalion had blown up the theatre.

Prosecutors said Maria Ponomarenko had committed a criminal offence brought in within days of the invasion of spreading "knowingly false information" about the Russian armed forces.


Addressing the court ahead of her sentence she stressed that under Russia's constitution she had done nothing wrong: "Had I committed a real crime then it would be possible to ask for leniency, but again, due to my moral and ethical qualities, I would not do this."

Declaring herself a patriotic, opposition pacifist, she ended her address by saying: "No totalitarian regime has ever been as strong as before its collapse."

The journalist and activist, who has two young children, has suffered mental health problems in jail, according to her lawyer, and last year compared her conditions in pre-trial detention to torture.

Last summer, Moscow councillor Alexei Gorinov was jailed for seven years after he was filmed speaking out against Russia's war in Ukraine in a city council meeting. Earlier this week a UN working group called for his release, concluding that his detention was arbitrary and contravened the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

In December one of Russia's most prominent opposition figures, Ilya Yashin, was jailed for eight-and-a-half years for spreading "fake news" about the military after he went on YouTube to condemn the killing of hundreds of Ukrainian civilians by Russian occupying forces in Bucha, near Kyiv.
 
She said Russia wasn't bombing Mariupol ?
No, she had no way to know that for sure.
She said her photo and interview were used by the Western media for the purpose of misinformation, without her knowledge or consent.
That her interview was edited and the parts contradicting Ukrainian version were removed.
And that "only an outright propagandist and manipulator can unilaterally blame the Russian side".

If you are curious to know more details, I gave a link to her social media above. Use auto-translate.
 

More than a dozen European Union member states have agreed to supply Ukraine with at least one million artillery shells over the next year.
The plan, worth €2bn in total, was agreed in Brussels on Monday.
Ukraine had told the EU it needed 350,000 shells a month to hold back advancing Russian troops and launch a counter-offensive this year.
Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba hailed the "game-changing decision" from the EU.

"Exactly what is needed," he wrote on Twitter. "Urgent delivery and sustainable joint procurement."
 
Our Russian Friend has no problem figuring out the media manipulation and distortions of the western media
But when it comes to Russian media though, it amazes me that he consumes and repeats everything without checking or thinking

Even When the Russia GOVERNMENT said it was all staged, faked and she is(was) a liar.
 


Since Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022, almost all independent media have been banned, blocked and/or declared “foreign agents”. All others are subject to military censorship.

Media landscape​

All privately owned independent TV channels are banned from broadcasting, except for cable entertainment channels. The Russian version of Euronews was suspended by Roskomnadzor, the media regulator, on 22 March 2022. Among the big print media outlets, which have belonged to Kremlin allies for a few years, those that had preserved their independence and were under constant threat of closure, like the independent tri-weekly Novaya Gazeta, have had to suspend their publications. Radio stations are in the same situation. Media outlets that have survived are faced with very strict self-censorship because of banned themes and words, and Western social networks are gradually being blocked.

Political context​

President Vladimir Putin has seemed increasingly isolated from the outside world since the start of the pandemic. Only a very restricted circle now has access to him, and the last collective decision-making institutions, such as the Security Council, are no longer really collaborative. Parliament has become a chamber for recording decisions made by the Kremlin. The official discourse, relayed by an omnipresent propaganda, is mainly based on accounts of Russia’s “historical grievances” and conspiracy theories.

Legal framework​

No journalist is safe from the threat of serious charges under vaguely worded draconian laws that were often adopted in haste. Many laws relating to freedom of expression that had been adopted in recent years – including defamation and “fake news” laws – were amended in order to incorporate them into the Penal Code at the start of the Covid-19 pandemic. The invasion of Ukraine gave a new impetus to this process, with parliament hastily adopting amendments under which “false information” about the Russian armed forces and any other Russian state body operating abroad is now punishable by up to 15 years in prison.

Economic context​

The radical sanctions imposed on Russia by the Western democracies in response to the invasion of Ukraine have suddenly severed much of the Russian economy from Europe’s, with which it was closely integrated. This will likely result in a very long and extremely deep crisis. Beyond censorship – which has forced many media outlets to close and has impoverished the few remaining independent journalists, forcing them to change professions or go abroad – the regional media will be among the first victims of this economic crisis.

Sociocultural context​

Although the internet connection rate is very high, almost two-thirds of Russians get their news mainly from television, which is controlled by the government, and from Russian social media such as VKontakte. Subjects such as homosexuality and religious feelings have gradually become off limits for the media under Vladimir Putin, who has encouraged a certain conservatism in Russian society.

Safety​

In recent years, in addition to heavy sentences and even torture suffered by some journalists, mainly at the regional level, the frequent use of fines and short-term detentions under various pretexts have been added to the arsenal of systematic intimidation against journalists. The media are also under threat of arbitrary inclusion on the list of “foregin agents”, a status that comes with heavy bureaucratic hurdles and legal risks. Faced with additional risks incurred since the state of the war in Ukraine, many journalists working for independent media outlets have chosen exile.

Currently in prison
21 journalists
 
Our Russian Friend has no problem figuring out the media manipulation and distortions of the western media
But when it comes to Russian media though, it amazes me that he consumes and repeats everything without checking or thinking

Even When the Russia GOVERNMENT said it was all staged, faked and she is(was) a liar.
Should be crystal clear for now that discussing with this guy is like a huge loss of time. I think it is much more relevant to focus on things happening. For instance last joke by Russia second clown in command:
 
Interesting how posters who complain the most about whataboutism, immediately switch to "what about Russia?" mode when fakes and misinformation in Western media are pointed out.
 
No, she had no way to know that for sure.
She said her photo and interview were used by the Western media for the purpose of misinformation, without her knowledge or consent.
That her interview was edited and the parts contradicting Ukrainian version were removed.
And that "only an outright propagandist and manipulator can unilaterally blame the Russian side".

If you are curious to know more details, I gave a link to her social media above. Use auto-translate.

She is in enemy territory now, with a small child, so any statement of hers should be considered to be made under duress, what else can she say...be honest.

Any contrary statement and her child will be taken away to be "filtrated" and "re-educated" and "adopted", she herself convicted and locked up.

That's not even my opinion it is your governments stated policy.
 
Last edited:
Interesting how posters who complain the most about whataboutism, immediately switch to "what about Russia?" mode when fakes and misinformation in Western media are pointed out.

I gotta ask again
If you believe RUSSIAN testimoney that he slaughtered Ukranian Civilians ?
Because you believe TAPED INTERVIEWS right ? RIGHT ?

Ruski Mir Guity of telling Trurh.png
 
Interesting how posters who complain the most about whataboutism, immediately switch to "what about Russia?" mode when fakes and misinformation in Western media are pointed out.
I'm struggling to see the sincere care about this, considering this is exactly what you do, merely in reverse. Maybe people are just fed up with engaging with it, and would rather focus on providing the news around the conflict?
 
She is in enemy territory now, with a small child, so any statement of hers should be considered to be made under duress, what else can she say...be honest.
You can just as well say I'm in "enemy territory" and posting here under duress.

All she is doing as far as I'm aware is posting in her blog and delivering humanitarian aid to Donbass people.
You can assume of course that she is doing it because she is threatened. If you are in complete denial there is nothing I can do about it.
 
She is in enemy territory now, with a small child, so any statement of hers should be considered to be made under duress, what else can she say...be honest.

Any contrary statement and her child will be taken away to be "filtrated" and "re-educated" and "adopted", she herself convicted and locked up.

That's not even my opinion it is your governments stated policy.
Nah, that reasoning only applies to people who speaks against Russia.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom