Spaceballs: The Mafia Game!

[NinjaCow64]

Vote: Ninjacow64

Pretty sure this guy is mafia.

You're wrong. I know why you would think that I'm Scum, hell I would probably vote for me if I was in your shoes too. But I'm not scum and killing me is a waste of time. I can't offer more defence than that.

 

[NinjaCow64]

Damn, my one suspect panned out. Oh well, back to the drawing board.

Vote: Mat93 as a placeholder.

 

[Jarrema]

We should look closer at the fact, that there is faction of good guys, and another one, I think of neutrals. And there is a lot of the latter here. And, of course, there is also a mafia.
Who could be ATPG's buddy?
Classical Hero, Choxorn & Zack voted for MartinLuther when he was fighting with ATPG for a lynch.
vote: classical herobut I may change to other among players named above

 

[NinjaCow64]

We should look closer at the fact, that there is faction of good guys, and another one, I think of neutrals. And there is a lot of the latter here. And, of course, there is also a mafia.
Who could be ATPG's buddy?
Classical Hero, Choxorn & Zack voted for MartinLuther when he was fighting with ATPG for a lynch.
vote: classical herobut I may change to other among players named above

Although you are wrong about us being Neutral, I like your thinking with classical_hero and choxorn, although I think Zack is town. Unvote; Vote: classical_hero

 

[cardith_lorda]

We should look closer at the fact, that there is faction of good guys, and another one, I think of neutrals. And there is a lot of the latter here. And, of course, there is also a mafia.
Who could be ATPG's buddy?
Classical Hero, Choxorn & Zack voted for MartinLuther when he was fighting with ATPG for a lynch.
vote: classical herobut I may change to other among players named above

Choxorn and Classical Hero both voted for ML BEFORE ATPG's name came up, and Zack hopped around a bit before settling while ATPG only had one vote. The only reason there were two votes on ATPG is because of two OMGUS, robbiecon early and then ATPG switched his vote to JoanK and the vote was returned for him. Basically we got hella lucky getting ATPG, and I'm not sure jumping on a bandwagon based on that is going to get us very far.

 

[Jarrema]

cardith, you are (partially) right. But do you have better lead?

 

[classical_hero]

This is risky but we need to get the mafia. I am a jailer and on night 1 I Jailed MartinLuther, so that meant he couldn't do anything or have anything done to him. On night 2 I forgot to send in an order. So when ML didn't turn up as mafia then it was obvious that I protected him from one of the night kills on night one. If I had remembered I would have jailed him again on night 2 and see what happened. Tonight I jailed someone and there again was one missing night kill, so I will talk to that person and if I get a good response then I won't reveal who it was. If I get a bad response, then I will reveal that person.

I just hope someone can protect me.

 

[Zack]

Why did everyone suddenly forget about Terran Emperor?

 

[Darth Feather]

I am tempted to vote BSmith for flying under the radar, but in the other game over at the org, I am fairly sure he is not scum, and he showed exactly the same behaviour.

I am not convinced on either of the lynch candidates. (ninjacow and C_H)
I won't vote robbiecon either because if he keeps on doing this he will get WOG'ed anyway.

For now vote: choxorn. It is rather a placeholder vote though, untill a better case arrived

(cause I don't see any)

 

[Darth Feather]

Sorry, x-posted

You are right, Terran Emperor was acting scummy last round; the only reason why I did not vote him was due to the large wagon, and bandwagonning on large wagons is usually not in tthe towns best interest.

unvote; vote Terran Emperor

 

[Zack]

NinjaCow64 told me in private he is Spaceballs (this is around Day 2), and he also said he had performed x ability on me. I replied that spaceman was my masonic partner, and that sirtommygunn had also claimed Spaceballs to me in private. Guess who died Night 2?

I was willing to write that off as a freak coincidence, especially since NinjaCow had verified his ability that same night. I told him that mechaerik was the roleblocker. Guess who died Night 3?

Too crazy to be coincidence at this point. Add to that his blind trust in me and my decisions and his bandwagon hopping, and his alignment looks pretty clear.

 

[cardith_lorda]

Why did everyone suddenly forget about Terran Emperor?

For the same reason that we forgot about you, everything surrounding Martin Luther's vote became kinda void when he was proved innocent, honestly you are a better lead right now because of your insistence on that ML was guilty, but I don't think you're guilty... at least not yet.

 

[cardith_lorda]

NinjaCow64 told me in private he is Spaceballs (this is around Day 2), and he also said he had performed x ability on me. I replied that spaceman was my masonic partner, and that sirtommygunn had also claimed Spaceballs to me in private. Guess who died Night 2?

I was willing to write that off as a freak coincidence, especially since NinjaCow had verified his ability that same night. I told him that mechaerik was the roleblocker. Guess who died Night 3?

Too crazy to be coincidence at this point. Add to that his blind trust in me and my decisions and his bandwagon hopping, and his alignment looks pretty clear.

So wait, how does this add to your case against Terran Emporer? Or are you changing your vote? INSTA-EDIT: Nevermind, I guess you never voted, just pointed out that we shouldn't forget him, carry on.

 

[choxorn]

Vote: NinjaCow64

You look very scummy, and you can't offer a better defense than "I swear I'm not mafia!"

 

[Mat93]

You're wrong. I know why you would think that I'm Scum, hell I would probably vote for me if I was in your shoes too. But I'm not scum and killing me is a waste of time. I can't offer more defence than that.

Based on that, it seems clear that what Zack said is true. Not that it means Ninja is scum, but highly likely to be.

@cardith: Terran could of defended ML so much because he already knew that he was innocent, by virtue of being scum. Just because he was right doesn't clear him, and unless he has a seriously good reason to have defended him so much, whether he was right or not doesn't affect that defending someone that much is scummy.

classical's last post I find highly suspicious, early role reveal (not huge chance of being lynched at that point), and claiming night action on someone dead who can't confirm if they got a result PM from that night (which might not of happened anyway), and the wording of him revealing whoever it was last night really sticks out as strange.

FoS: classical, vote: Ninjacow64

 

[Zack]

For the same reason that we forgot about you, everything surrounding Martin Luther's vote became kinda void when he was proved innocent, honestly you are a better lead right now because of your insistence on that ML was guilty, but I don't think you're guilty... at least not yet.

Huh? I retracted my accusations against Martin before he was lynched.

And besides, being wrong on a Day 3 lynch is not an indicator of guilt by any means.

And yeah, classical's roleclaim is odd.

 

[NinjaCow64]

Vote: NinjaCow64

You look very scummy, and you can't offer a better defense than "I swear I'm not mafia!"

Well I can't, and honestly I think someone would be framing me. I mean, excuse the drinking of the wine, but would I really be that stupid to kill a Masonic partner after Zack told me who he was? I mean Masonic partners aren't that strong anyway.

By the way, I'm a tracker. First night I was tracking MartinLuther, but I was redirected to Zack who was doing nothing. Next night I tracked Mech who targeted Zack. And last night I tracked Terran Emperor who did nothing.

Anyway, Classical's claim...can anyone confirm that claim? That would make me consider unvoting.

 

[Zack]

No one could possibly be framing you - you're the only person I told.

I think you went ahead and killed them, thinking you could get away with the "I'm not that dumb" or "someone's framing me" defense.

 

[BSmith1068]

vote: classical. I'm fine with him or Ninja for the Lynch.

 

[NinjaCow64]

No one could possibly be framing you - you're the only person I told.

Then it's freaking weird coincidence. I still think you are townie, but it seems like I am doomed today.