Team Fortress 2 Mafia: Game Thread [concluded]

[Jarrema]

I would like CivG to show up and confirm that he scanned Visor.
Of course, it is almost 100% sure, but well.

I do not change my vote now, as we do not have to put all eggs into one basket (we can try more than one lynch)

 

[DarthNader]

Seeing as how CivGeneral made an accusation against Visorslash so quickly after the update, and the fact that there is a claim that CivGeneral has the ability to scan, methinks the lynch of Visorslash is a safe bet. Its better than attacking other players blindly, seeing as we have reason to believe he's RED. Granted, if CivG is wrong on this both Optical and CivG would look extremely scummy.

The fact that Visorslash has flip-flopped on his lynch votes and added names to his hitlist doesn't help his situation either.

Vote: Visorslash

 

[Visorslash]

Seeing as how CivGeneral made an accusation against Visorslash so quickly after the update, and the fact that there is a claim that CivGeneral has the ability to scan, methinks the lynch of Visorslash is a safe bet. Its better than attacking other players blindly, seeing as we have reason to believe he's RED. Granted, if CivG is wrong on this both Optical and CivG would look extremely scummy.

The fact that Visorslash has flip-flopped on his lynch votes and added names to his hitlist doesn't help his situation either.

Vote: Visorslash

Note that a lot of the people who have voted me, I alienated because I added them to my hitlist. I am not attacking people blindly and I am encouraging them to play. Can you please elaborate why that could possibly be a mafia tactic, to make players agaisnt you and not be on your side? I've been playing mafia for a while now, and I like to think I'm not too bad at it, and I don't think I would be as stupid as what you and others are suggesting. Honestly, think about the logistics of it.

 

[Double A]

SO! The good news is that we have at least another vig. The bad news is that he hit me for 100 damage.

Help.

 

[Mergle]

CivGeneral said he scanned you as mafia.

Now, if you are, and I believe him, then you'll (hopefully) get lynched and reveal as mafia. All good. If by some random chance you turn out not to be, CivGeneral will be extremely suspicious, but at the moment I'm inclined to believe him.

Thinking on, I'd originally thought visorslash seemed suspicious, then when Zack seemed to go all bizarre, I thought Visor justified. But now we know Zack was one of the good guys. And visor's continued to crusade on little evidence.

unvote; vote:visorslash

 

[Visorslash]

So what are you going to do when I turn up innocent?

 

[robbiecon]

Vote: CivGeneral, instantly in on the action to get a Visorslash lynch, with logic in relation to Visorslash's sig, and CivCube being killed on the third night (which doesn't make sense unless CivCube third on the Visorslash's list?) But at the same time, someone with a kill ability is not going to have a list of people they're going to kill, in the order they're going to kill him.

I'm not wholly convinced by mgsmuhammad and this "prophecy" he was talking about. Any prophecy related thing in TF2? And not knowing that JoanK was dead? Surely the first thing someone checking the thread should do is make sure the person they're voting for is actually alive!

 

[mgsmuhammad]

I'm not wholly convinced by mgsmuhammad and this "prophecy" he was talking about. Any prophecy related thing in TF2? And not knowing that JoanK was dead? Surely the first thing someone checking the thread should do is make sure the person they're voting for is actually alive!

You do me great injustice with your words, sir.
Perception is irrelevant, as long as we hold true our faith in the prophecy.
I can only hope to redeem your unbelieving souls by showing you the light of such wisdom.

 

[Zack]

Mgsmuhammad must bring balance to the Force (by completely annihilating half of it, which somehow brings balance to it).

 

[Mat93]

vote:visorslash

Simply as he is the most active player, and seemingly the one most motivated to get everyone involved, but yet the red team seem not to have killed him yet. Clearly something is amiss there.

I am interested in this 'prophecy', but with mgsmuhammad's seemingly unique position in the game, it doesn't sound unreasonable to me.

 

[Visorslash]

vote:visorslash

Simply as he is the most active player, and seemingly the one most motivated to get everyone involved, but yet the red team seem not to have killed him yet. Clearly something is amiss there.

I am interested in this 'prophecy', but with mgsmuhammad's seemingly unique position in the game, it doesn't sound unreasonable to me.

So because I am active, I should be lynched. That is... depressing.

 

[Methos]

Vote: VisorSlash

 

[Methos]

Vote: VisorSlash

Rumor has it V has been scanned and shows up as mafia, so for everyone listening, this is something we can't ignore. I've heard CG is the scanner and I've heard he's pretending to be to protect the real scanner, either way, its the same outcome. Target VisorSlash to determine if we really have a true scanner.

For anyone to target anyone else seems scummy.

I'll say it again, Vote: VisorSlash.

 

[classical_hero]

Why is the 'CivGeneral scanned you as mafia' argument weak? We test it by lynching you and then if you're not then he's scum (or a paranoid cop, or an insane cop).

It's better than what you guy had on me, and you've dealt me over a 100 damage.

CG might be able to see role and he got a role that he thinks is scum? Just a thought, so we don't rush straight away at CG. But of course if he gets it wrong he has some serious explaining to do.

 

[Mat93]

So because I am active, I should be lynched. That is... depressing.

Nope, because the red team haven't tried to kill you (I know there are ways to stop a night kill, but there has been the same number of kills every night). And the fact that someone has claimed to scan you as red. I see no reason for a team with a kill every night to fake that.

Although it would be nice if CivGeneral, in private preferably, to someone, confirmed whether it was them, or whether someone told them that they scanned visor. If its the latter, then I am a bit more cautious, but still, it's better evidence than what anyone else has provided.

 

[DaveShack]

CG might be able to see role and he got a role that he thinks is scum? Just a thought, so we don't rush straight away at CG. But of course if he gets it wrong he has some serious explaining to do.

This is exactly what he got. Careful review of the thread will show that someone saw him checking (so we can infer it is a real result and not made up). Even more careful review may show you what kind of role Visor is according to the scan.

 

[Buddhafish]

Could you elaborate, for those of us who don;t have the time ATM to review it?

 

[Jarrema]

I do not understand why you suggest that mgsmuhammad situation is so special, Mat.
What do you mean?

 

[mgsmuhammad]

He's my number one fan.

 

[Buddhafish]

So what is your different situation Mat93 and mgsmuhammad?

I'm basically echoing Jarrema here, but I'm curious.