palantirion
Chieftain
- Joined
- Sep 24, 2008
- Messages
- 22
Thanks for that.
As someone who has played both engines extensively I can say that it is a hotly debated subject. The are essentially the same engine in the way they work, but both have merits and demerits when compared. The general view is split, though tends toward Rome rather than Medieval 2. Medieval 2 gave us some better building graphics, but the additional wall levels etc. have created more game-breaking pathing issues with the AI. This is a real problem and cannot be modded away.
Many people prefer the cleaner graphics of RTW and the better unit cohesion. With RTW environments now becoming, to be blunt, stunning, as well as new buildings being created, the modded RTW engine - in my view - makes for a much better gaming experience.
But Medieval 2 is also a very good game.
Third Age, and other full-conversion M2 mods, are also still a long way off from being completed (as it takes some years to get a full-conversion done). FATW will be finished this year. The first Middle-earth mod to be completed for the TW series (in fact, for any other engine as far as I know). We think it will cause a few jaws to drop
As someone who has played both engines extensively I can say that it is a hotly debated subject. The are essentially the same engine in the way they work, but both have merits and demerits when compared. The general view is split, though tends toward Rome rather than Medieval 2. Medieval 2 gave us some better building graphics, but the additional wall levels etc. have created more game-breaking pathing issues with the AI. This is a real problem and cannot be modded away.
Many people prefer the cleaner graphics of RTW and the better unit cohesion. With RTW environments now becoming, to be blunt, stunning, as well as new buildings being created, the modded RTW engine - in my view - makes for a much better gaming experience.
But Medieval 2 is also a very good game.
Third Age, and other full-conversion M2 mods, are also still a long way off from being completed (as it takes some years to get a full-conversion done). FATW will be finished this year. The first Middle-earth mod to be completed for the TW series (in fact, for any other engine as far as I know). We think it will cause a few jaws to drop