I loath the movie Treasure Planet. I imagine this is mostly because I love Treasure Island , especially the Wallace Beery version, and Treasure Planet is a betrayal. Also, the star ships look like tall ships from the Golden Age of Pirates. "Spacers" run around on deck with no breathing gear and the hulls of the star ships are build for sailing on seas, not navigating deep space. (I'm willing to accept the sails because they are explained to be solar sails.) Recently I came across a YouTube vid wherein the reviewer likes Treasure Planet. The reviewer makes several salient points. So I am willing to give the movie another viewing. What sayeth you? Treasure Planet: good movie or terrible movie?