Unhappiness in Shakespeare's theatre city
- Thread starter Revenant
- Start date
Looking at the city details, it appears Shakespeare's Theatre converts 16 unhappy citizens, assuming red shirts linearly count as two.
total citizens = 17
-3 from military suppression, temple = 14 unhappy
+5 red shirts = 19 unhappy
2 + 1 unhappy after Shakespeare = 3
19 - 3 = 16
This doesn't seem right, though. I thought the wonder could handle mega-cities under normal circumstances. Maybe there's a government multiplier.
total citizens = 17
-3 from military suppression, temple = 14 unhappy
+5 red shirts = 19 unhappy
2 + 1 unhappy after Shakespeare = 3
19 - 3 = 16
This doesn't seem right, though. I thought the wonder could handle mega-cities under normal circumstances. Maybe there's a government multiplier.
Interesting analysis Whelkman.
More conjecture...
http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=61704
The argument from the other thread sounds logical... that the wonder will convert all regular unhappy citizens, but starts stumbling after red shirts appear. However, this conflicts with the "16" you calculated above.
Perhaps (as Revenant suggested) one or two of the red shirts are counting as triple unhappy. If two of them are triple unhappy in this case, then it would match the CitySize+1 theory from the other thread.
12 unhappy citizens + (2 triple-unhappy red shirts)*3 + (3 double-unhappy red shirts)*2 = 24
-2 from temple = 22
-1 from martial law = 21
-18 from wonder (CitySize+1) = 3
Of course, if red shirts do sometimes represent triple unhappy citizens, then the net unhappiness amount might not even be 3 (it could be 4). It appears there's no way to tell.
More conjecture...
http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=61704
The argument from the other thread sounds logical... that the wonder will convert all regular unhappy citizens, but starts stumbling after red shirts appear. However, this conflicts with the "16" you calculated above.
Perhaps (as Revenant suggested) one or two of the red shirts are counting as triple unhappy. If two of them are triple unhappy in this case, then it would match the CitySize+1 theory from the other thread.
12 unhappy citizens + (2 triple-unhappy red shirts)*3 + (3 double-unhappy red shirts)*2 = 24
-2 from temple = 22
-1 from martial law = 21
-18 from wonder (CitySize+1) = 3
Of course, if red shirts do sometimes represent triple unhappy citizens, then the net unhappiness amount might not even be 3 (it could be 4). It appears there's no way to tell.
Valen
TWAYF Builder
In my experience, red shirts always count as double unhappy.
I concur with Whelkman's analysis. Shakespeare converted 16.
In the "Something weird" thread, they must have been looking at a city of 15 to see CitySize+1 converted.
There are precedents to Shakespeare's limit:
The book says all units in a defender's stack are lost when an attacker wins a battle. In fact only 10 (or is it 8) are lost. Anyway, there is a limit.
The book says sentried units wake up when an enemy units moves next to them. I've seen a case where 12 units were sentried in a city when an enemy unit moved adjacent. Only 8 woke up.
I concur with Whelkman's analysis. Shakespeare converted 16.
In the "Something weird" thread, they must have been looking at a city of 15 to see CitySize+1 converted.
There are precedents to Shakespeare's limit:
The book says all units in a defender's stack are lost when an attacker wins a battle. In fact only 10 (or is it 8) are lost. Anyway, there is a limit.
The book says sentried units wake up when an enemy units moves next to them. I've seen a case where 12 units were sentried in a city when an enemy unit moved adjacent. Only 8 woke up.
Valen
TWAYF Builder
Similar threads
