1. We have added a Gift Upgrades feature that allows you to gift an account upgrade to another member, just in time for the holiday season. You can see the gift option when going to the Account Upgrades screen, or on any user profile screen.
    Dismiss Notice

ways into happiness

Discussion in 'Civ4 Strategy Articles' started by cabert, Oct 16, 2006.

  1. cabert

    cabert Big mouth

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2005
    Messages:
    7,710
    Location:
    France
    (This could be a religious thread, but no it's only a game )
    Happiness, as we all know is the key to everything, much more important than health (don't flame me, I put another article on health here).

    This article identifies the factors that will lead a population to be happy, and also notes some of the unhappiness-causing elements.

    As the player selects more difficult levels, cities become quickly unhappy ("We just enjoy life" bonus gets smaller at higher levels) even with small populations, so having a good knowledge of the happiness factors will help the player to create and manage a stronger empire.

    Here you can see the happiness bonus you start with at every level :
    • SETTLER : _ 6
    • CHIEFTAIN: 6
    • WARLORD : 5
    • NOBLE : _ _ 5
    • PRINCE : _ _4
    • MONARCH : 4
    • EMPEROR : _3
    • IMMORTAL : 3
    • DEITY: _ _ _3
    Generally speaking, you will try to have more happiness than unhappiness. It doesn't matter where the happiness and unhappiness comes from.
    As long as you have more happiness than unhappiness, you have no angry faces.
    If unhappiness is higher than happiness, you'll have
    [unhappiness - happiness] angry faces = citizens eating and costing but not working.

    Note that you can not have a "we love our leader day" if there is an angry face in a city. It's not game changing, but it's a loss and it's avoidable.


    So, how do you get the happiness you need to grow?

    In vanilla cIv, there are exactly 7 ways to get more happiness (and a helluvah lot to have unhappiness).
    In warlords, you have 2 more ways to gain happiness : charismatic trait ("OH YEAH"), and vassals (yes, having vassals makes your people think they're big and strong :) )


    • resources
      (Fur;Ivory;Gems;Gold;Silver;Dye;Incense;Silk;Spices;Sugar;Whale;Wines)
    • buildings
      (Palace, colosseum, theatre*, Broadcast Tower, temples, markets*, cathedrals*, forges*, barracks**)
    • religion** (+1 isn't much, + 7 is better)
    • civics
      (free religion, nationhood, environementalism, representation , Hereditary Rule)
    • wonders
      (globe theater in the biggest city will make a huge difference in one city ,
      Notre dame a small one but everywhere,
      Broadway/hollywood/rock'n'roll will provide a happy resource)
    • commerce slider
    • future techs : I won't expand a lot on future techs. Every future tech gives you +1 happiness in every city. But who cares? The game is over at this point!

    * : depends on a resource
    ** : depends on a civic.

    where does unhappiness come from :
    • population itself = "too crowded" :
      1 unhappiness for each population point (yes the 1st pop thinks it's already too crowded :crazyeye: )
    • "We fear for our safety" :
      a big city (size 3 and more AFAIK) without garrison unit will have unhappiness. A warrior is enough to remove this.
    • slavery penalty = "cruelty" :
      1 unhappiness for each whip. The penalty goes away after 10 turns. If you whip more than once, the penalty only gets removed one at a time.
      (example :in the first turn after revolt you whip a captured city for a theater and a granary, you get 2 unhappiness for 10 turns, then 1 unhappiness for 10 other turns)
    • drafting penalty = "we won't go":
      3 unhappiness for every draftee in a city. The penalty goes away after 10 turns.
    • war weariness"what is war good for?" : the more you fight outside your borders, the more unhappiness you get. full information on this in krikkitone's article : war weariness mechanics
    • "we yearn to return to our motherland" :
      when you capture a city, the ancient culture of the previous owner gives you unhappiness. This is removed when your culture gets dominant (=more than the ex-owner's) or when you kill the ex-owner.
    • "we won't fight our brothers in faith" :
      when you attack a civ which shares the religion of this city, you get another share of unhappiness
    • "We demand emancipation" :
    If other empires run emancipation, and you don't, you get unhappiness. This can be huge, when most of the others run emancipation.

    WW, emancipation, brothers in faith, mother land penalties all are size dependant = a big population city will face a bigger penalty.

    edit : after so much time, I'll simply assume I have them all.

    Note that there are ways to reduce unhappiness.
    For example police state reduces war weariness,
    and emancipation removes unhappiness from lack of emancipation :yup:
    Jails also reduce WW, mount rushmore (national wonder) also reduces WW.
    Slavery : Whipping reduces population, and so reduces "too crowded", WW, emancipation, "brothers in faith", "mother land" unhappiness .

    example :

    here you see

    • a size 6 city : 6 unhappiness "too crowded"
    • a captured city (was german, now aztec) : 2 unhappiness "we yearn to join our motherland"
    • a hinduist city, when in a war against a hinduist civ: 1 unhappiness from "we won't fight our brothers and sisters in Faith"
    • This city has been whipped twice (temple and theater) : 2 unhappiness "we cannot forget your cruel oppression"
    • war weariness : 4 unhappiness "war.. what is it good for? nothing"
    making a total of 15 unhappiness

    • 1 happiness from the building (temple) : "some buildings are making us happy"
    • 12 happiness from resources (including forge, market, theater doubling effect on resources like gold, ivory and dye) : "we enjoy our luxurious resources"
    • 1 happiness from Hinduism being in the city while our state is hinduist : "in our religion we trust"
    • 4 happiness from the culture slider (20% with a theater) : "we appreciate our entertainment"
    • 1 happiness from Notre Dame (not in this city, but somewhere in my empire) : "some buildings are making us happy" [Could be clearer!]
    • 4 happiness because it's monarch level : "we just enjoy life"
    for a total of 23 happiness
    = room to expand to size 14, or to stay at war while growing.
     
  2. cabert

    cabert Big mouth

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2005
    Messages:
    7,710
    Location:
    France
    early game:
    You don't have access to civics, you have limited access to resources and buildings = low happiness potential.
    What to do?
    - live with it
    - search the best way to improve it.

    Obviously a very low happiness cap is making life difficult, but with slavery you can live with it.
    I often do (cap at 5 is usual), but it's a choice. Under 4 you can do so few moves it's not funny anymore, since with the whip, you'll have a cap at 3 for 10 turns without WW!

    3 things are to be considered in this order, IMHO:
    - the map
    - your traits/starting techs
    - your victory goal (if you start with this one, be prepared to suffer!).

    The map will show you what happiness resources you can have.
    Your traits will give you an advantage on certain buildings or on civic swaps.
    If you're industrious and the map has gold, silver and gems, don't go for religion! you need metal casting for forges, and connected mines.
    You really should tech to mining (if you don't have it already), then BW then MC, while building settler and workers to connect those ressources.
    +6 happiness is a lot. With this on hand, you don't need monarchy right now and you don't need to switch to a state religion.

    Same thing, if you have ivory and fur, teching to currency is huge.
    If you don't, a religion is better + priesthood for temple + open borders for other religions.

    OTH if you have calendar resources everywhere, calendar becomes a priority, so don't spend time building stonehenge.

    You see the point.
    More in chapter 1 below on what tech are needed for each resource/associated building.

    What's the thing about victory condition?
    If you aim for cultural, you need the religions. open your borders to let them in and tech to priesthood for the temples. If you manage to found a religion on the path, good for you. If you don't, it doesn't matter really. + you'll run a high culture slider in a not too distant future. Tech towards drama!

    If you aim for conquest, you don't need big cities, and you will be able to take a resourceful city somewhere. Look harder on the map : there is gold somewhere probably.

    If you aim for diplo (it's a bit early but who knows), you may be able to trade some resources for others or for money or even for free. Take it into account.

    Domination/space really need loads of happiness, usually. Cannot say more.

    mid game
    Here it's basically giving up something for something else.
    Religion spreading / temple building costs hammers.
    Unit building costs hammers.
    Culture sliding costs beakers or gold (though gaining land is a side benefit).
    You need something to trade if you want a resource = giving up another resource.

    You can use HR while building up an army, then the slider while warring.
    Or you can have 5 big cities, and keep the others low on pop if you run representation (hello pyramids).
    Or you can trade for resources.
    Or you can turn builder and have all those bonus buildings everywhere.
    Or you can be in between :eek:.

    I value Notre Dame a lot, and conquering it (you won't build it, will you?) is high on my priorities. Same thing for ressources I miss, obviously.

    late game
    If you did well up to that point, you should have little happiness problems in peace time.
    My usual way is to go to war for "short" periods, in which i crank up the culture slider. You can live with 40% culture, believe me.
    Other tactics include mount rushmore, jails, police state to reduce WW.

    I favour the culture slider because i go for domination mostly. And 20/30/40 % culture for a few turns is always welcome when you need land.
     
  3. cabert

    cabert Big mouth

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2005
    Messages:
    7,710
    Location:
    France
    1) resources :
    there are 12 happiness resources

    For each resource, you need either to
    - have it on a tile included in you cultural borders, have the right improvement built and have the tile connected to your cities
    - trade for it

    Fur : camp improvement, requires hunting tech
    Ivory : camp improvement, requires hunting tech
    Gems : mine improvement, requires mining tech
    Gold : mine improvement,requires mining tech
    Silver : mine improvement,requires mining tech
    Dye : plantation improvement, requires Calendar tech
    Incense : plantation improvement, requires Calendar tech
    Silk : plantation improvement, requires Calendar tech
    Spices : plantation improvement, requires Calendar tech
    Sugar : plantation improvement, requires Calendar tech
    Whale : Whaling Boat, requires optics tech
    Wines: winery improvement, requires monarchy tech


    with Broadway (hit musical),
    rock'n'roll (hit single) ,
    hollywood (hit movie) you can have 3 more resources
    Those wonder resources don't require tile improvement of course, but require the wonder. They can be traded.




    Here you can see
    2 hunting happiness resource, both doubled by markets (currency tech)
    3 mining happiness resources, all doubled by forges (metal casting tech)
    5 calendar resources, one doubled by theaters (drama tech), one doubled by markets (currency tech), one doubled by cathedrals (music tech)
    1 monarchy resouce
    1 optics resource, doubled by markets (currency)
    3 late wonder resources (linked to Electricity, Mass Media, Radio techs), all doubled by broadcasting tower (Mass Media)

    That's a grand total of 15 ressources, 11 of which can be doubled, one can be multiplied by 8 (incense with cathedrals, see next chapter) =
    33 potential happiness from resources.

    Beware :
    plastics obsoletes fur
    industrialism obsoletes ivory
    Combustion obsoletes whales
     
  4. cabert

    cabert Big mouth

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2005
    Messages:
    7,710
    Location:
    France
    2) buildings
    - colosseum (construction tech): 1 happiness + 1 happiness for every 20% culture from the slider (see slider effect),
    - theatre (drama tech): +1 happiness for every 10% culture, + 1 for dyes,
    - Broadcast Tower (mass media tech): +1 happiness for every 10% culture rate, +1 happiness from hit movies, hit single, or hit musical,
    - temples (priesthood tech): +1 happiness (you can gain +1 one happiness from every temple, regardless of state religion = potential of 7 happiness)
    - markets (currency tech): +1 happiness from furs, ivory, silk, & whales,
    - cathedrals (music tech): +2 happy face if state religion, +1 happy face from incense (for every cathedral so it's potentially +7 from incense),
    - forges (metal casting tech): +1 happy face from gems, gold, & silver,
    - barracks (nationalism tech for civic choice): +2 happy faces if running nationhood

    The slider is specific, see further. No counting on culture slider, that's a grand total of 30 potential building happiness points, 18 of those have already been counted in the resource chapter.
    So it's another possible +12.

    Hey we're already at 45! Why do you have a happiness cap at 5 :crazyeye: ?
     
  5. cabert

    cabert Big mouth

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2005
    Messages:
    7,710
    Location:
    France
    3) religion
    If you have a state religion, all cities that have this religion will gain +1 happiness.
    If you run free religion civic (requires Liberalism tech), every religion in a city will give 1 happiness
    ( so potentially +7 happiness)

    That's 52! Is this guy mad?
     
  6. cabert

    cabert Big mouth

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2005
    Messages:
    7,710
    Location:
    France
    4) civics
    - free religion is adressed in chapter 3 (every religion gives +1 happiness),
    - nationhood is adressed in chapter 2 (barracks give +2 happiness),
    - environmentalism (+1 happy face from jungles & forests)
    - representation (+3 happy faces in the 5 largest cities : "We love this great city of ours!" )
    - Hereditary Rule (+1 happiness for every unit in a city : "we are impressed by the military presence")

    Hey where is the limit? With HR, there is no limit!

    Now, there is no limit! :confused:
     
  7. cabert

    cabert Big mouth

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2005
    Messages:
    7,710
    Location:
    France
    5) wonders

    globe theater (requires drama + theatre in 6 cities, map size dependant) in a city will make a huge difference in this city : no unhappiness (national wonder).
    Notre dame (music tech) gives a small benefit but everywhere : +1 happiness in every city,
    Broadway/hollywood/rock'n'roll will provide a happy resource, this is already adressed in chapter 1.

    That's one city immune to unhappiness, and 1 more happiness for every city.

    phew! there was already no limit, and now one city doesn't even care[pimp]
     
  8. cabert

    cabert Big mouth

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2005
    Messages:
    7,710
    Location:
    France
    6) commerce slider

    (To use this, you need the drama tech)

    For every 10% culture, you gain 1 happiness.
    +1 more with a theatre
    +1 more with a broadcast tower
    +1/2 more with a colosseum (you need 20% culture for 1 happiness with the colloseum).

    +1 permanent happiness from colosseum is already adressed in chapter 2

    So, with a theatre, a colosseum and a broadcast tower what do you gain at every culture level:
    0% : 0 (really? yes!)
    10% : +3 (1 from slider, 1 from theatre, 1 from broadcast tower)
    20 % : +7 (2 slider, 2 theatre, 2 broadcast tower, 1 from colosseum)
    30 % : +10 (3/3/3/1)
    40 % : +14 (4/4/4/2)
    50% : +17 (5/5/5/2)
    60% : +21 (6/6/6/3)
    70% : +24 (7/7/7/3)
    80% : +28 (8/8/8/4)
    90% : +31 (9/9/9/4)
    100%: +35 (10/10/10/5)

    Here we see there is a potential of +35 happiness from the slider.

    What do you want with 35 happiness when there was no limit ?:hmm:

    That's it for a start.
    Any constructive criticism is welcome.
    To do list :
    - show the text for each source of happiness (including civics like environementalism)
     
  9. scottcstoness

    scottcstoness Chieftain

    Joined:
    Apr 29, 2006
    Messages:
    83
    Location:
    Groton, CT
     
  10. cabert

    cabert Big mouth

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2005
    Messages:
    7,710
    Location:
    France
     
  11. playshogi

    playshogi Chieftain

    Joined:
    Nov 1, 2001
    Messages:
    1,387
    If you accept a vassal, you get some happiness in your cities, but I don't know exactly how it works and may be changed in the patch. I usually play with vassals turned off.
     
  12. cabert

    cabert Big mouth

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2005
    Messages:
    7,710
    Location:
    France
    as far as I know, it's 1 happiness for every vassal in every city of the master
     
  13. CivCorpse

    CivCorpse Supreme Overlord of All

    Joined:
    Nov 15, 2005
    Messages:
    1,930
    Don't forget the temples. 7 religions with temples for each is +8 with a state religion and + 14 with free religion. :hammer:
     
  14. akuratnik

    akuratnik Chieftain

    Joined:
    Feb 13, 2007
    Messages:
    6
    Ok so I've been playing civ for a while (not to say that I'm any good at it, but still) and I've never seen this one:

    "We love this great city of ours!" (+2 happiness)

    What the hell is that?
     
  15. DaviddesJ

    DaviddesJ Chieftain

    Joined:
    May 5, 2003
    Messages:
    4,348
    Location:
    Burlingame CA
    That's the bonus for Representation. It applies only to your largest cities.
     
  16. akuratnik

    akuratnik Chieftain

    Joined:
    Feb 13, 2007
    Messages:
    6
    oo hmm strange that i've never seen it before. that's cool, thanks!
     
  17. cabert

    cabert Big mouth

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2005
    Messages:
    7,710
    Location:
    France
    As DaviddesJ (I only saw your article about happiness a few days ago! If I had seen it before, I wouldn't have bothered with this one!) said, it's the representation bonus.
    I've added the text in the chapter 4 (civics).
     
  18. feldmarshall

    feldmarshall Dictator

    Joined:
    Jan 25, 2007
    Messages:
    387
    so, having 2 sources of one type of happiness resources is useless? so it is better to trade it away?
     
  19. cabert

    cabert Big mouth

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2005
    Messages:
    7,710
    Location:
    France
    useless in the happiness departement,
    but since it let's you trade one it's not totally useless ;)
     
  20. KMadCandy

    KMadCandy giggling permanoob

    Joined:
    Oct 16, 2005
    Messages:
    3,993
    Location:
    Peepsville
    the rep bonus depends on map size. it applies to 4 cities on duel map and 6 cities on huge for example. those were the only 2 i bothered to start fake games for and check the civilopedia to see if my memory was correct. i forgot to check the whether the number of happy faces changes also.

    signed, KMad, who hasn't seen DaviddesJ's article and is now off to go search for it.
     

Share This Page