For me, being consistent with any of the holy books would actually be evidence that it's some kind of trick.
I don't believe there is anything that can't be explained by science, only things that haven't been explained by science. Simultaneously, I'm accepting of the fact that some things haven't been explained yet, and I don't ascribe supernatural or divine causes to things that people haven't figured out yet. Lots of phenomena previously thought to be supernatural or divine have been shown to be natural, predictable, understandable, and even harnessable. Nobody today believes that a person struck by lightning has somehow offended Zeus. You mentioned The Angel of Death. We just had one, it was named COVID-19. I think Angels of Death have mostly been disease outbreaks. It's easy to see how pre-Enlightenment people would view a years-long drought, a mega-tsunami, or a massive earthquake as being the work of an Angel of Death, too, and we've seen every one of those things in recent years. The history of things that had once been ascribed to a divine being having since been explained by science is so long that, at this point, the idea of divine beings just seems implausible. If we've had it wrong 7,000 times in a row, why would we think, "okay, this time it's really god(s) at work"? Just how gullible do we need to be?
Science & technology is real magic.
D'oh. Ninja'd.