I rewatched Lost (2004) because I came down with covid and I needed something to pass the time while I recovered.
S1 and 2 are great. I love the mystery and wonder of the island as well as the cast of characters and their relationships. The logic vs faith debate between Jack and Locke regarding "the button" is one of my favorite things in any TV series/movie. Only negatives for me is that there is some filler. Thereʻs like 25 episodes in the early seasons (ah the days of network TV) so the episodes arenʻt quite as streamlined as they could be. 9/10
I liked S3 overall and exploring The Othersʻ story. That Benjamin Linus fellow. Heʻs such a smarmy worm. Great bad guy. However it starts to become a little soap opera-y. Thereʻs a love triangle in S1 & 2 between Jack, Sawyer, and Kate which turns into a quadrangle with the addition of Juliet takes up significant amount of time. Near the end of the season characters start changing sides between The Survivors and The Others almost every episode. Motivations change on a whim or for no reason at all. 7/10
S4 and 5 are noticeably less compelling than seasons 1-2. I don't like the expanding cast of characters that know about the island. Daniel is the only one that seems to add anything to the show. Charlotte, Lapidus, and Miles have like 1 episode apiece where they are the focus, then they get lost in the background for the rest of the series. It was more fun was it was the original group looking to survive and get rescued. Now itʻs more of a full on sci-fi show. The contrivances, shifting loyalties, lies, deception, etc. from season 3 continue. Theyʻre making everything ʻconnectedʻ like itʻs some kind of cosmic fate that brought everyone to the island. Weakest two seasons by far. It survives mostly on being invested in the original cast and seeing how their stories unfold. Dharmaville in S5 was fun though. 5/10
S6 is focused on the Jacob vs Man in Black conflict which is framed as good vs evil. Like sure, the MiB is selfish, deceptive, and of course the killing in cold blood is bad. But heʻs been lied to, and been trapped on the island against his will. Plus thereʻs Jacob who has forced people to come to the island, causes them to suffer while doing nothing, and instructs The Others to kidnap people. He doesnʻt exactly seem like a beacon of morality either. Lots of questions start to get answered which is good but not all the answers are fully satisfying. The writing problems continue from S3, 4, and 5 continue. 6/10
Oh, I also watch The Penguin and S2 of The Diplomat. Both very good. 8/10.