Lohrenswald
世界的 bottom ranked physicist
It used to be different: removing the swear and letting it pass
that's exactly the opposite of what I saidthe words weren't allowed to stay up.
I don't know what you're on aboutJust because you tell someone not to do something, that doesn't mean you don't clean up what they did. This applies to many aspects of life, whether it's tracking mud into the house when you're a guest... or dealing with swearing on a forum that has rules against it (most do, and I've seen some places a lot stricter than CFC).
No, I am questioning the change in policyIf you have an issue with a moderator action, please contact the moderator that took that action.
Yes, we can see when the actual words are typed and the filter removes them and when the member types asterisks.Is it possible to even tell the difference between a user manually inserting asterisks or the filter automatically replacing a naughty word with asterisks?
This is part of the problem. A large part of the complaints with some of the rules of this forum isn't the rule itself, but that it's not consistently enforced. There also needs to be common sense applied, as in the case of a word that could either be used as a racial slur or in a productive discussion about building armor or log cabins. Obviously if it's used as a slur, it should be infracted. But preventing people from discussing armor-building or log cabin construction is just ridiculous.What changed, perhaps, is how some moderators enforced the rules.
In that case the issue is not the language but the insult, and you can be insulting without any profanity at all.Just because it's filtered doesn't mean it's any less pleasant. People still know what you're saying. If someone said "**** you" to me, at best my response would be that I don't enjoy asterisks
.
Though I suppose what constitutes a bad word could be an issue. Some places have different thresholds beyond the obvious few. Such as damn.
The profanity rules are also starting to annoy me lately. Yeah, yeah, family forum.
What's the average age of an OT poster ? 35 ? 30 ? Almost certainly not lower than 30.
I mean, nobody here advocates for excessive swearing, or personal attacks, but sometimes profanities really help to get A Point across.
Our basic philosophy is that there is nothing that anyone needs to say on our forums that requires them to swear/cuss. If you can't get your point across without swearing, you will be infracted.