1. We have added a Gift Upgrades feature that allows you to gift an account upgrade to another member, just in time for the holiday season. You can see the gift option when going to the Account Upgrades screen, or on any user profile screen.
    Dismiss Notice

which UU is the best?

Discussion in 'Civ3 - General Discussions' started by Jawz II, Apr 5, 2004.

  1. Gr3yL3gion

    Gr3yL3gion Voice of Madness

    Joined:
    Mar 19, 2004
    Messages:
    2,202
    Location:
    KL, Malaysia<->Singapore
    Swiss Mercenary
     
  2. HalfBadger

    HalfBadger The Great Whackyness

    Joined:
    Nov 13, 2003
    Messages:
    356
    Location:
    Winnipeg, MB
    My Faves are the Gaelic Swordsman, Mounted warriors, Hoplite, Coassacks, Enkidu Warriors, Javalin thrower and Berskers, Haven't tried out all Civs yet though.

    The 'Best' will always be disputed, since ppl play with varying difficuluty levels and for different reasons, points, winning and try to win so many different ways.

    My Best Guess though would be the Gaelic Swordsman.
     
  3. dze27

    dze27 Monarch

    Joined:
    Dec 29, 2002
    Messages:
    159
    Location:
    Ottawa
    I can't pick one, that's for sure.

    The early attacking units are great: Immortals, Gallic Swordsmen, Mounted Warriors.

    I really like the Swiss Mercenary too. It seems overpowered since it's basically a half-price Musketman (minus an attack point, but who cares about that) and is the best for a whole age: Feudalism to Nationalism, and good until the age of Tanks.

    The Sipahi is nice but it doesn't feel like a real difference-maker to me, and it's 25% more expensive than Cavalry.

    I have tried the Vikings a couple of times but the Berserk is very expensive (70 shields against 40 for the Longbowman) and I haven't been able to exploit its advantages well.

    UUs that I don't like include Chasqui Scout (but the Incas rule anyway), Cossack (hard to really use the Blitz capability all that much when you're attacking mostly Musketmen), Carrack and Bowman.
     
  4. Mad Bomber

    Mad Bomber Commander

    Joined:
    Jul 17, 2002
    Messages:
    655
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    Immortals, Riders, and Ansar Warriors are the three best UU's
     
  5. Adalid

    Adalid Chieftain

    Joined:
    Mar 28, 2004
    Messages:
    10
    Location:
    MD
    GS and Rider
     
  6. Darkness

    Darkness Shadow creature

    Joined:
    Jul 18, 2002
    Messages:
    6,755
    Location:
    Rotterdam, the Netherlands
    Sipahi, Rider and Mounted warrior, in that order...
     
  7. HalfBadger

    HalfBadger The Great Whackyness

    Joined:
    Nov 13, 2003
    Messages:
    356
    Location:
    Winnipeg, MB
    I've kinda overanalysed this and my conclusion was that the Hoplite was overall the best UU.

    I've never myself nor seen the AI, do much with bombard units, naval units nor air units. so any UU of those are kinda out of the running.

    In thinking that you'll try to build lots of these units since they are the best you should have available:

    all un mounted ground units upgrade to Guerillas, which are usually the expendable units at that time. I'd rather not have dozens of Guerillas running around, when I could have Cavalary etc

    Mounted units all upgrade to Calvary/cossacks/Sipahi. They are very Dominant for a long time and Sipahi was a close 2nd, but again once Tanks come around (in huge map games you'll usually research to this point eventually), again they're almost obsolete, espeically when MA come around. Sure many ppl will have finished the game by then, but if say 30% or so of players don't, then the obsoleteness of calavary units becomes significant. Ansar rider, chinese riders are in the top 5 still though.

    Then it comes down to Defensive units, which will never be obsolete, they'll upgrade into the 2nd most powerful unit int he game, MI. so a choice from enkidu warrior, impi, hoplite, swiss mercanary and Muskateer.

    Enkidu warrior, no resources + half cost = 2 points
    Impi, extra movement + no resources = 2 points

    Hoplite, extra defense + no resources + lets you ignore next upgrade = 3 points

    Swiss mercanry, extra defense + ignore next upgrade = 2 points
    Muskateer, Extra defense + bombard + partially lets you ignore next upgrade = 2.5 points

    I may have missed them in my analysis, or underestimated something, but this was the basic logic I used.
     
  8. Halcyon

    Halcyon 9000

    Joined:
    Mar 19, 2004
    Messages:
    930
    Unfortunately, merely counting the number of things a unit has going for it isn't a good analysis of how useful it is. It's better if it only has one very big thing going for it than half a dozen trivialities. I'd also argue that having the UU upgrade to a useful unit isn't terribly advantageous, as so do normal units. However, having a useful unit upgrade to your UU is potentially deadly - think war with knights, think mass upgrade to Sipahi.

    The true answer is that there isn't really a 'best' UU overall, though there may be for a particular playstyle or situation. The best UU would then be the one which is most useful for the greatest range of situations. As such, probably one of the fast defensive units - Ansar, Sipahi, et cetera, depending on when you're attacking. With the exception of the Chasquis scout, each UU is deadly in its niche. The Byzantines can dominate the seas until Magnetism, whereupon the English take over the seas and keep them. Even H'wacha can be lifesavers if you're waging an artillery-heavy war, though, and you probably should be. The exceptions are probably the F-15 and the Chasquis Scout, neither of which strike me as game-breakers.

    You also forget that ancient units get minus points for the risk of triggering a despotic golden age, something which you're better off avoiding. The risk is greater for defensive UUs, meaning that you'd best remove one point from that Hoplite.
     
  9. Gengis Khan

    Gengis Khan Deity

    Joined:
    Jun 13, 2003
    Messages:
    2,760
    Location:
    Wilmington, NC
    People talk about Despot GAs like they're the worst thing in the world, I disagree. If you plan ahead & time it right you can turn a despotism GA into the biggest flood of settlers you've ever seen. Often this is enough to take a commanding lead of the game, which the AI is hard pressed to catch up.

    Despotism GA's aren't great, but they are deffinatly not bad if you know its coming & can use it to your advantage.
     
  10. Frostyboy

    Frostyboy Never Beaten

    Joined:
    Nov 17, 2003
    Messages:
    1,046
    Location:
    Norway
    Wake up people!

    There is no such thing as THE best UU. It depends on many factors as playstyle, oppononents and so.
    But as a rule of thumb you can say that the lower the stats are the larger percentage the bonus is and therefore the value of the bonus. As with the Enkidu warrior, a jump from 1 to 2 is a gain on 100% while a Samurai that gains a bonus from 3 to 4 in defence is only 33% (and the lack of horse requirement as well)
    Regarding playstyle, you may not like to have your GA too early as a result in using your UU, neither too late as with the Americans F-15 (which usually must rely on getting a wonder iniated GA)
    Some people like attacking units best (Immortals, Mounted Warriors), others defensive units (Hoplites and Enkidu warriors)

    _Personally_ regarding my playstyle (tiny pangea conquests)
    I like most the Immortals - which are Awsome. The Mounted warriors are also great. I like these since they come early and give a nice % bonus as mentioned.
    Immortals are just the same as medieval infantery (Persians cant build this) and you get them from the start, they endure until the appearance of Riflemen.
    On the defensive side I find Enkidus and Hoplites best for massive pillage raids since your enemy will be in serious trouble agains them and they are cheap.

    All UU's that go outside the straight road to Military tradition I don't care at all about since I should have won by then (or it may be too late anyway)
    The chasqui scout is a special one. You can't build normal scouts and are forced to build these, but if playing on a huge map you may win back the cost by moving on mountains as much as possible and therefore indeed increase your scounting radius a lot without loosing speed.

    the F-15 is by far the worst one, and Conquistadors - I still except for pillaging and stealing workers, haven't seen the good use of them (since they are som excpensive).

    Frostyboy
     
  11. Jawz II

    Jawz II Oh Dear

    Joined:
    Feb 5, 2004
    Messages:
    6,671
    Location:
    Arizona Bay
    the "lower stat/cheaper unit/most numerous" sounds right,but then one could argue that that the jump from 1 to 2,which indeed is a gain of 100% still isnt enough of a bonus to really make a big diffrence,since spearmen with def = 2 and archers with att=2 are available from the get go

    i dont know if u read my 1st post or not,but by best i meant the one unit that makes it easiest to beat the game

    given with diffrent styles of play there has to be diffrent best choice for diffrent people,but still there has to be one single unit that is slightly better than others from a pure logical/mathematical point of view

    still with diffrent terrain everytime and special skills on some UUs,for example enslaving mayans and ampnibious vikings its even harder to decide


    see this as the whats yo favourtie/which is the best UU thread!;)
     
  12. Tomoyo

    Tomoyo Fate

    Joined:
    Feb 21, 2004
    Messages:
    9,698
    Location:
    Boston, Mass
    The best UU... This should be the favourite UU. Some UUs are better on certain maps, against certain civs, even. For example, if your UU is the impi, you won't do very well against say, Persia, with their slow attacking UU, but you would do better against the Iroquois, because of their retreating UU. The Jaguar Warrior would be useless on a huge map with two civs because it will be long obselete when (if) war starts. (And it would take forever for the jag to get to the other civ)

    As to the question of which UU makes it easier to win the game, it would depend on your playing style. Sir Pleb would be able to use the Jaguar Warrior, while a purely peaceful builder would like the Hoplite better. It all depends on the player.
     
  13. Point13

    Point13 Like a ton of bricks!

    Joined:
    Jan 28, 2004
    Messages:
    536
    Location:
    Birmingham, AL
    First Prize: Immortals- basically, a Medieval Infantry with Iron Working, cheaper too!

    Second Prize: Hoplite- a pikeman with Bronze Working, and cheaper too!

    Third Prize: Beserks- an early powerful marine, can you say, domination?

    Honorable Mention:

    Legionary- Good, extra defense makes it good as Pikes, but Immortals still dominate

    Siphai- Offense powerhouse, but on defensive it lacks the ability to survive, Immortals can kill them...

    Mounted Warrior- An early Siphai, but weak on defense as well...
     
  14. Tomoyo

    Tomoyo Fate

    Joined:
    Feb 21, 2004
    Messages:
    9,698
    Location:
    Boston, Mass
    @Captainkeyes23: You said that the Mounted Warrior and the Sipahi are weak on the defensive, lacking the ability to survive. I find that the Immortals fit this descrption as well, yet you placed it first.
     
  15. Saltamontes13

    Saltamontes13 Chieftain

    Joined:
    Feb 13, 2004
    Messages:
    1
    Well you also have to look at what other units are available when the Immortals come into play. The highest attack you'll see for a unit around this time in the game is 3 (swords, ac, other uu's). Comparing 3 attack to 2 defense isn't that huge of a gap and the gap closes even more when you consider the possible defensive bonuses. The available defensive unit at this time would be the spearman which also has a defense of 2 so it's not like you'd have a better defender available without using another civ's uu.

    Compare that to the point in the game when the Sipahi becomes available. Even if you make a beeline for Military Tradition another civ can be 3-4 techs behind and still have Longbows, MI, or Knights to kill off your Sipahi. If they are on par techwise then you've got to deal with cavalry (Attacking 6-3 is much better odds than attacking 3-2). Also if you're going to escort the Sipahi with defensive units you take away the advantage its increased movement points would normally provide you with. The upside is the ability to run away and fight another day.

    It just boils down to what you said a few posts up Tomoyo.... it really depends on the situation. I just started a game as the Persians and I'm a long ways away from any of the other civs. Even after establishing my core of about 6-7 cities I'm still 12-15 tiles away from any iron. I'd rather fill in the open land than send a stack of immortals a good distance just to win me some cities that will suffer from really high corruption. This basically means that Immortals are going to be useless this game since they'll be obsolete before I have to start wiping out the other civs. Sipahi would have easily been 10x more useful in said situation.
     
  16. Ision

    Ision Master

    Joined:
    Mar 8, 2003
    Messages:
    452
    Isions personal list:

    1. Immortal
    2. Rider
    3. Man O' War (island maps only)
    4. tied between - Hoplites and Enkidos

    Ision
     
  17. CIVPhilzilla

    CIVPhilzilla Reagan Republican

    Joined:
    Aug 24, 2003
    Messages:
    4,714
    Location:
    Pennsylvania
    I actually like the F-15, as I don't engage in early wars. Its much better than the regular jet fighter and is excelent for reconsance.
     
  18. Zardnaar

    Zardnaar Deity

    Joined:
    Nov 16, 2003
    Messages:
    5,674
    Location:
    Dunedin, New Zealand
    There is no best UU it depends on the map, playstyle and difficulty level. My personal favourites in no particular order.

    1. Hoplite/Enkidu Warrior
    2. Man O War
    3. Siphai
    4. Immortals
    5. Ansar Warrior

    In most cases they are all an undercosted unit. Eg Enkidu Warrior is a undercosted spearman, Hoplite undercosted and early pikeman. The Siphai are just very good and the Man O War to versatile/powerful on non pangea maps to igmore and allow different tactics a full age early.
    5.
     
  19. Giotto

    Giotto Eagle

    Joined:
    Feb 9, 2004
    Messages:
    586
    Location:
    Medina, WA
    vanilla civ3 I'd say Mounted Warrior


    PtW/conquest: Siphai
     
  20. The Last Conformist

    The Last Conformist Irresistibly Attractive

    Joined:
    Aug 25, 2001
    Messages:
    27,779
    Location:
    Not on your side
    This is about the zillionth time this question pops up.

    My faves remain Sipahi, Rider, Ansar Warrior, Immortal, in that order.
     

Share This Page